Role Madness Jojo's Bizzare Adventure Mafia

[Ali v2]

ostly looked at his sus pile tbh.

LMs big red flag to me was Nibel, in part because I don't know who nibel is this game

Nibel is red night = nuit rouge

 

[Flower]

I'm still hoping someone claims it.

But if they don't, I will look at it side-eyed but not dismiss it completely becaus that might be fatal. Because scum can reveal true censuses too, I imagine.

Yeah. But the number of Indies is disgusting tbh.

But welp.

 

[Ratchet]

You think I keep track of most individual town reads?

I can tell you Naomi's early list was fine, and PB's list made sense for him, I think.
I mostly looked at his sus pile tbh.

LMs big red flag to me was Nibel, in part because I don't know who nibel is this game.
And the Udell read was too early. I got that read when Udell did his catch-up, but I would need a refresher why LM got that early read.

I'm surprised yiu haven't also called out Melkor's town read of York early game. Think that's the best example of a bad town read I've seen in this game.

 

[Jan]

I'm surprised yiu haven't also called out Melkor's town read of York early game. Think that's the best example of a bad town read I've seen in this game.

I had the same read during my catch-up and thought being the only person to give that read was towny.

My experience with scum!York is exactly the one game where Alexis shot her n1.

 

[Ali v2]

Nevermind, sorry. I wanted to ask you about your statement that you'd nto considered Muugen might not be town before Zemmi's post, but I'd misremembered something you'd said previously. I do have to question the statement though, are you not starting from a baseline of "everyone is scum until proven otherwise"? That's the impression I had of your solving beforehand.

Correct, and the consensus made things even worse for me, I was starting to trust Muu more and more, however I can sometimes be easily pocketed and the consensus made trusting even more difficult Given the non town members the consensus revealed are much higher than what I originally expected.
The only person I completely trust right now is Zemmi.

 

[Jan]

Yeah. But the number of Indies is disgusting tbh.

But welp.

That is why I was hoping that Zemmi would count as one of the non-towns on the census.

 

[Yoho]

Correct, and the consensus made things even worse for me, I was starting to trust Muu more and more, however I can sometimes be easily pocketed and the consensus made trusting even more difficult Given the non town members the consensus revealed are much higher than what I originally expected.
The only person I completely trust right now is Zemmi.

Why is Zemmi the one you completely trust?

 

[Ratchet]

I had the same read during my catch-up and thought being the only person to give that read was towny.

My experience with scum!York is exactly the one game where Alexis shot her n1.

York loves being scum, relishes it even. Being happy and whimsical is not a tell for york being town.

 

[Charlie]

??? was triggered​

Is it me? I'm triggered xd

 

[Ratchet]

Correct, and the consensus made things even worse for me, I was starting to trust Muu more and more, however I can sometimes be easily pocketed and the consensus made trusting even more difficult Given the non town members the consensus revealed are much higher than what I originally expected.
The only person I completely trust right now is Zemmi.

I see. I guess that makes sense.

 

[Charlie]

Not necessarily bogus. Town must have a lot of shit to counter. That'll get misused or not used at all because of inactivity

Me looking at my role pm

 

[Jan]

York loves being scum, relishes it even. Being happy and whimsical is not a tell for york being town.

Really?
@Flower Do you agree?

I am confident that your read differed strongly in three houses from this.
I remember wasting time looking at old games to confirm you read back then.

 

[Ali v2]

Why is Zemmi the one you completely trust?

She feels genuine. Especially that last bit when she tagged ratchet and jan and told them she counts among the 12.

 

[krogothwolf]

Me looking at my role pm

Maybe you'll find the arrow

 

[Ratchet]

Really?
@Flower Do you agree?

I am confident that your read differed strongly in three houses from this.
I remember wasting time looking at old games to confirm you read back then.

I'm not suggesting she's more active as scum, just that her general happiness levels are more likely to be higher if she's scum. At the very least, I don't think her being happy is a good reason for her to be town and I don't think Melkor believes it is either.

 

[Flower]

Really?
@Flower Do you agree?

I am confident that your read differed strongly in three houses from this.
I remember wasting time looking at old games to confirm you read back then.

I don’t know what she prefers, but as scum I always get the feeling she just wants to hide and hopes nobody notices her too much lmao. I think she likes it a lot when her team is fun though.

 

[Yoho]

She feels genuine. Especially that last bit when she tagged ratchet and jan and told them she counts among the 12.

Fair i haven't played enough games with her to say if she's good at lying or not but i can see your headspace

 

[Ali v2]

I'm not suggesting she's more active as scum, just that her general happiness levels are more likely to be higher if she's scum. At the very least, I don't think her being happy is a good reason for her to be town and I don't think Melkor believes it is either.

If you were asked to choose to lynch one of Jan or york … who would you choose and why?

 

[Zemmi]

Sorry for tagging you twice, but I really want to hear from you @RippedCal

 

[Flower]

In Weebs 2024 York had a Super GF role and I remember she actively made herself a target to protect her team and was open scumming and having fun all game.