Role Madness Jojo's Bizzare Adventure Mafia

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Then we have reached a dead end unfortunately.
she claimed tracker D1 last game and ended up being shroud. The (she always claims D1 as town) reasoning is therefore just wrong.
She is scum and needs to go.
My reaspning was not "she always claims day 1 as town". It was "her claiming a role she really ought to not claim is not something that's scummy for her". This is very important, because otherwise you're attributing a tell to her that just doesn't mean anything in her case. I believe I've gone over the risks associated with fake claiming vigilante already? Happy to refresh though, but first - do you believe the census or not?
 

Ali v2

No regret, yet, every regret.
My reaspning was not "she always claims day 1 as town". It was "her claiming a role she really ought to not claim is not something that's scummy for her". This is very important, because otherwise you're attributing a tell to her that just doesn't mean anything in her case. I believe I've gone over the risks associated with fake claiming vigilante already? Happy to refresh though, but first - do you believe the census or not?
I do.
 
Top