General & Others Zoro or Sanji? Who is a better leader

[Albino 👑]

Irrelevant and a gag.

How? sanji was in charge of the group he was the one the rest were lookin to when tryna figure out what to do

When doffy was attacking
When the attacked big moms ship
When they got to zou
Dealing with capone

And no it wasn't because sanji was the strongest even tho he unquestionably was he was in charge of the group and their protection
If nami was in charge the group wouldve been named after her not sanji

 

[True God Moe]

Irrelevant and a gag.

That’s actually false. Nami leads whenever they’re on the sea, as you mentioned, but that’s the majority of the time. Nami, if you’d like to remember, led the majority of the time on Punk Hazard and when they were on Zou. She was in charge, as shown with the children and when she was the one to talk about saving the people on Zou. This was also displayed on the way to and on WCI.

Probably because 90% of them are lol.

I don't remember doing any of that especially in Franky's body. She was with children, but nit overall on anything as she relies on Sanji leading their side especially in Zou Arc was his call and his group as stated by others too.

 

[Gintoki]

Still waiting for zoro to round up the samurais

maybe next arc

 

[Albino 👑]

Sayin nami is more of a leader than sanji is basically like saying zoro is a better leader than luffy

 

[OEKaneki]

How? sanji was in charge of the group he was the one the rest were lookin to when tryna figure out what to do

When doffy was attacking
When the attacked big moms ship
When they got to zou
Dealing with capone

And no it wasn't because sanji was the strongest even tho he unquestionably was he was in charge of the group and their protection
If nami was in charge the group wouldve been named after her not sanji

He actually wasn’t, if you pay attention to the actions later. He wasn’t in charge for anything you listed other than when he dealt with Capone, because the Capone situation was related to him. Sanji attacked Doflamingo of his own accord, he wasn’t in charge and he wasn’t even near the ship when he attacked in the first place, and got saved. He wasn’t in charge when he attacked Big Mom’s ship. He asked for Luffy’s permission to proceed. He wasn’t in charge on Zou, he took direction from Nami.

I don't remember doing any of that especially in Franky's body. She was with children, but nit overall on anything as she relies on Sanji leading their side especially in Zou Arc was his call and his group as stated by others too.

Nami was the one that led the group through Punk Hazard until they were all together. Nami was the one to press for them to collect the kids, while Sanji didn’t give a shit. Once they were all together, it didn’t matter anymore. On Zou, Nami was the one that led and was the one that determined that they would help the Minks, Sanji questioned it. The two biggest things in both arcs were decided by Nami.

Sayin nami is more of a leader than sanji is basically like saying zoro is a better leader than luffy

It’s actually not.

 

[True God Moe]

He actually wasn’t, if you pay attention to the actions later. He wasn’t in charge for anything you listed other than when he dealt with Capone, because the Capone situation was related to him. Sanji attacked Doflamingo of his own accord, he wasn’t in charge and he wasn’t even near the ship when he attacked in the first place, and got saved. He wasn’t in charge when he attacked Big Mom’s ship. He asked for Luffy’s permission to proceed. He wasn’t in charge on Zou, he took direction from Nami.

Nami was the one that led the group through Punk Hazard until they were all together. Nami was the one to press for them to collect the kids, while Sanji didn’t give a shit. Once they were all together, it didn’t matter anymore. On Zou, Nami was the one that led and was the one that determined that they would help the Minks, Sanji questioned it. The two biggest things in both arcs were decided by Nami.

It’s actually not.

She did have some leading role, but in mid way it starts to shift with Sanji especially him leading G5 Marines and Tashigi in that arc and they develop a bond with him.

Nah Sanji was the one that lead them and decide on helping them especially Chopper as a doctor couldn't leave them be. They were in debt to many especially Sanji as they show worry on him being gone.

 

[OEKaneki]

She did have some leading role, but in mid way it starts to shift with Sanji especially him leading G5 Marines and Tashigi in that arc and they develop a bond with him.

Nah Sanji was the one that lead them and decide on helping them especially Chopper as a doctor couldn't leave them be. They were in debt to many especially Sanji as they show worry on him being gone.

She had the leading role for the most important plotline in PH outside of Luffy and Law targeting Ceaser and SAD. Sanji didn’t have a leading role after that, that’s not what G5 was. He didn’t lead anything in the crew at that point.

That’s actually not true. Sanji was not the one that decided on helping them. Sanji specifically warns against it in 811, saying that if they help the Minks it could come back to bite them. Nami talks to Wanda and says that they will save every single one of them. Nami lead on that when Sanji really didn’t want to.

 

[Sade]

After WCI Usopp or Chopper have more right in leading compared to Sanji.

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

hmm
In terms of personality, Zoro looks to us more to be a leader than Sanji!

Yet the reality of the matter is that Sanji lead more times than Zoro did during the story. Wano is a great example where Zoro SHOULD have showcased leadership when Luffy was absent, but he simply was a lone wolf!

So, for us, Zoro's seriousness and strong will...etc! they all strike us that he's fit to be a leader more, but when you look at what is happening in the story and "not what you think"
Zoro looks more of a lone wolf
Sanji more of a team guy
Which is why Sanji was shown leading more times than Zoro

In fact, the only time the name of the crew SHs changed into "curlyhats" was with Sanji. While during Wano because Zoro didn't lead anything, he's a lone wolf, there was no change in name like "marimo-hats" lol

But generally, Zoro fits more as the sound of reason/advisor for captain. Because he is less emotional and not allowing the captain to falter (Usopp scene in water 7)
However, being advisor is not the same as taking decisions.
So, even though Zoro may come up with a sound reason and great advise, and back up the captain the most, BUT that's a different role than being the guy with final say/decision.

There is a reason why advisors stay advisors and not become leader themselves. Because when it comes to taking decisions, even people with sound reason can falter and start losing it because taking the final say is not the same as saying your opinion

 

[Desolate Smaug]

Sanji is a better leader. Zoro only saving grace is his strength and he is barely above Sanji. If you create a checkbox on the qualities that a pirate captain should have, the only parameter Zoro will outdo Sanji is strength. And even that won't be by a huge margin. Sanji then mops the floor with him in things like Intelligence, Charisma etc.

 

[Inspector_Mu]

I really do feel like 90% of these zoro threads are bait

They are

Post automatically merged: Oct 3, 2019

Still waiting for zoro to round up the samurais

maybe next arc

Remember they even started saying zoro will round up before the raid starts

Their so called better leader didn't even recruit one samurai

 

[zorojurou]

They are

Post automatically merged: Oct 3, 2019

Remember they even started saying zoro will round up before the raid starts

Their so called better leader didn't even recruit one samurai

Remember, you said zoro only led when Sanji's absence. You never learn.

Sanji

Zoro led the crew ın tb

 

[OmegaPsyche]

Sanji is the best leader...in the kitchen.

 

[Sade]

Sanji is a better leader. Zoro only saving grace is his strength and he is barely above Sanji. If you create a checkbox on the qualities that a pirate captain should have, the only parameter Zoro will outdo Sanji is strength. And even that won't be by a huge margin. Sanji then mops the floor with him in things like Intelligence, Charisma etc.

Sanji charisma lol that's funny.

 

[Finalbeta]

Sanji is the best leader...in the kitchen.

Inversely proportioned to women

 

[Desolate Smaug]

Sanji charisma lol that's funny.

More like straight up facts.

 

[Zenos7]

Sanji is a better leader. Zoro only saving grace is his strength and he is barely above Sanji. If you create a checkbox on the qualities that a pirate captain should have, the only parameter Zoro will outdo Sanji is strength. And even that won't be by a huge margin. Sanji then mops the floor with him in things like Intelligence, Charisma etc.

thats extremely oversimplifying what intelligence and charisma are.

 

[Xione]

Nami is more brain, but not truly leader especially sitting back on more action and tense situation like Usopp's situation for one. Sanji take her place more than she dies lead, but more on money management and navigation.

She didn't take the backseat in the usopp situation.

In OP you need to be powerful to lead powerful people unless you're buggy.

 

[Desolate Smaug]

thats extremely oversimplifying what intelligence and charisma are.

Lol what are you talking about? I didn't even explain or simplify that stuff. I simply stated Sanji is the more intelligent and charismatic of the two.

This is the problem with Zoro fans. They don't bother to read what's presented to them

 

[Xione]

Sayin nami is more of a leader than sanji is basically like saying zoro is a better leader than luffy

It's really not. Nami would be the best leader of the crew if she was stronger. But since shes weak she lacks the determination/confidence the strong ones have. But in actual leading where she doesn't have to worry about power and such.. shes the best. Which is why she runs the ship.