One Piece Episode 1112 - Clash! Shanks vs. Eustass Kid

Rate The Episode

  • 5/5

    Votes: 47 82.5%
  • 4/5

    Votes: 3 5.3%
  • 3/5

    Votes: 2 3.5%
  • 2/5

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 1/5

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 0/5

    Votes: 5 8.8%

  • Total voters
    57
#24
Looked kinda ass, whoever directing and doing the storyboard just wanted to flex their skills not really making a memorable scene, 2 minute+ ass scene for what happened in 1 and a half page

Atleast it didn't have the usual aura vomit that they left over from dragonball super to make the dbs refugee fans clap
It was pretty good imo, but I do wonder who was in charge of this scene in general because they were brutal on Kidd. It's worse than the manga and I thought that was never possible
 
#27
It was pretty good imo, but I do wonder who was in charge of this scene in general because they were brutal on Kidd. It's worse than the manga and I thought that was never possible
Nah I think it was ass, like let me elaborate: Obviously Anime is a different Medium and you cant, and should not, adopt 1:1 but there is a "scene intent", so to say. The intent and presentation of the scene in the manga was clearly we seeing, like even the anime itself said, a glimpse of Shanks power for the first time. And from a narrative sense of point that Shanks only did this because he saw how many of his followers were killed, so he avoided unnecessary action or conflict or power display, something the gorosei also commented or we really even see in chapter 1.

Instead, they made a whole spiderman ass scene getting to the ship and then the actual attack was overindulgent and unnecessary like they made even get the cannonball explode and the mast getting cut for no reason beside "look how awesome it is!"


As for kid yeah they did him dirty. They even make him himself cream destroying the puddle pirates which is like what the fuck :willight:
 
#28
So the shanks downplay is he didn't cut kid himself and let his own weapon fucked him up instead? That even worse guess the evil shanks gang keep going backwards
 
#30
Nah I think it was ass, like let me elaborate: Obviously Anime is a different Medium and you cant, and should not, adopt 1:1 but there is a "scene intent", so to say. The intent and presentation of the scene in the manga was clearly we seeing, like even the anime itself said, a glimpse of Shanks power for the first time. And from a narrative sense of point that Shanks only did this because he saw how many of his followers were killed, so he avoided unnecessary action or conflict or power display, something the gorosei also commented or we really even see in chapter 1.

Instead, they made a whole spiderman ass scene getting to the ship and then the actual attack was overindulgent and unnecessary like they made even get the cannonball explode and the mast getting cut for no reason beside "look how awesome it is!"


As for kid yeah they did him dirty. They even make him himself cream destroying the puddle pirates which is like what the fuck :willight:
It's not that bad, though I agree him jumping off the ships was weird. Should have just had him get there with really fast Geppo/Kamisori or something.
And you're also right the attack was kind of overly hyped there. It was always really devastating and powerful (that's the point of it in the manga as well) but they had Kidd getting thrown into the ship and everything, when in the manga he just got floored and couldn't move.
 
Top