Speculations Shamrock is Bonney's father and may have targeted Ginny over what happened at gods valley

A

Album

‎
#1
#1


in an sbs with genderswapped supernova the genderswapped bonney looks alot like shanks and shamrock









and anne bonney who jewlery bonney is inspired by is irish
and shanks brother is named SHAMROCK
A symbol of ireland
when Ginny got kidnapped, we see heel like boots and we see shamrock, has on long thigh black boots





Shamrock is 39 years old, Bonney is 12 years old, that is, she was born when Shamrock was 27, the same age Shanks was when he met Luffy.

Bonney has a nika form so this could all just be a double parallel. Shanks being a family figure for Luffy, and Shamrock being Bonneys Rapist Dad



also its possible that shamrock targeted ginny because she is responsible for what happened at gods valley and he wanted to punish her for costing him his brother

since without her actions his brother wouldnt have been corrupted


https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1886548263714623652







( shamrock doesnt have any illwords for shanks
he just says he took a liking to this world

Last, So imagine, if he discover that Ginny was responsible for the god valley incident. Since she leak the info. Him always holding this grudge and Ginny maybe bragged about her being the cause of god valley and some spy for WG. Related this info back. Meaning him being the one that kidnapped Ginny and made sure she suffer for causing the incident, that separated him from his twin.
 
kyejames316

kyejames316

‎
#2
#2
Album said:


in an sbs with genderswapped supernova the genderswapped bonney looks alot like shanks and shamrock









and anne bonney who jewlery bonney is inspired by is irish
and shanks brother is named SHAMROCK
A symbol of ireland
when Ginny got kidnapped, we see heel like boots and we see shamrock, has on long thigh black boots





Shamrock is 39 years old, Bonney is 12 years old, that is, she was born when Shamrock was 27, the same age Shanks was when he met Luffy.

Bonney has a nika form so this could all just be a double parallel. Shanks being a family figure for Luffy, and Shamrock being Bonneys Rapist Dad



also its possible that shamrock targeted ginny because she is responsible for what happened at gods valley and he wanted to punish her for costing him his brother

since without her actions his brother wouldnt have been corrupted


https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1886548263714623652







( shamrock doesnt have any illwords for shanks
he just says he took a liking to this world

Last, So imagine, if he discover that Ginny was responsible for the god valley incident. Since she leak the info. Him always holding this grudge and Ginny maybe bragged about her being the cause of god valley and some spy for WG. Related this info back. Meaning him being the one that kidnapped Ginny and made sure she suffer for causing the incident, that separated him from his twin.
Click to expand...
No, Bonney was in the possession and care of the government for years. She has been arrested by Akainu who spoke familiarly to her and then proceeded to arrest her in chains. Shamrock is not neutral on Bonney if he is her father, he would not have let them give her a fake illness and leave her in the middle of nowhere with a low class CP agent if he cared about her. If he wanted her dead he would have killed her while they had her right there available. They are not related.
 
a_fan

a_fan

‎
#4
#4
They both also give off rapist vibe and "whatever's mine is mine" when they lock in.

Also, both have a thing for kidnapping too. It's such a shame Roger and Garb was in Xebec's way when Garling kidnapped his boy.

 
A

Album

‎
#7
#7
kyejames316 said:
No, Bonney was in the possession and care of the government for years. She has been arrested by Akainu who spoke familiarly to her and then proceeded to arrest her in chains. Shamrock is not neutral on Bonney if he is her father, he would not have let them give her a fake illness and leave her in the middle of nowhere with a low class CP agent if he cared about her. If he wanted her dead he would have killed her while they had her right there available. They are not related.
Click to expand...
I never said he wanted Bonney dead I said he wanted ginny dead
 
NAMELESS

NAMELESS

‎
#8
#8
Album said:


in an sbs with genderswapped supernova the genderswapped bonney looks alot like shanks and shamrock









and anne bonney who jewlery bonney is inspired by is irish
and shanks brother is named SHAMROCK
A symbol of ireland
when Ginny got kidnapped, we see heel like boots and we see shamrock, has on long thigh black boots





Shamrock is 39 years old, Bonney is 12 years old, that is, she was born when Shamrock was 27, the same age Shanks was when he met Luffy.

Bonney has a nika form so this could all just be a double parallel. Shanks being a family figure for Luffy, and Shamrock being Bonneys Rapist Dad



also its possible that shamrock targeted ginny because she is responsible for what happened at gods valley and he wanted to punish her for costing him his brother

since without her actions his brother wouldnt have been corrupted


https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1886548263714623652







( shamrock doesnt have any illwords for shanks
he just says he took a liking to this world

Last, So imagine, if he discover that Ginny was responsible for the god valley incident. Since she leak the info. Him always holding this grudge and Ginny maybe bragged about her being the cause of god valley and some spy for WG. Related this info back. Meaning him being the one that kidnapped Ginny and made sure she suffer for causing the incident, that separated him from his twin.
Click to expand...
oh no,plz,no.
 
LogicoftheVI

LogicoftheVI

‎
#10
#10
I have never been a fan of this theory. I get the feeling that Shamrock would not lower himself to sleeping with a petty slave. It seems beneath him given him and his father's portrayal so far in the story. I could be wrong, and I am willing to admit it if I am, but I feel like this theory is very forced and really hinges on the SBS post by Oda. If that did not exist, then neither would this theory.

My personal take is no Shamrock is not Bonney's father.
 
Shiroyru

Shiroyru

‎
#11
#11
kyejames316 said:
No, Bonney was in the possession and care of the government for years. She has been arrested by Akainu who spoke familiarly to her and then proceeded to arrest her in chains. Shamrock is not neutral on Bonney if he is her father, he would not have let them give her a fake illness and leave her in the middle of nowhere with a low class CP agent if he cared about her. If he wanted her dead he would have killed her while they had her right there available. They are not related.
Click to expand...
Shamrock just doesn’t care about any kid he had with a commoner
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top