Character Discussion Who is Bonney's (biological) father?

Who fathered Bonney?

  • Rosward

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Charlos

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Mjosgard

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Shivercalero

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Killingham

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Sommers

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Ju Peter

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Mars

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Warcury

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Nusjuro

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Pluming

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    29
  • Poll closed .
#22
I think Oda might just not reveal it. One Piece is PG-13.

While rape does exist in the story, as evident by Ginny, I don’t think Oda really wants to touch on this in depth.

imagine some villain acting like:

“Hahaha I raped your mom”

This isn’t GOT or berserk.

Either it will be revealed via SBS(see Franky and Queen) or it just won’t be revealed at all.
 
#23
Saturn said bonney was kuma daughter, showing how obsessed he was with kuma and his family.

he wouldn't experiment on celestial dragon baby. so i am sure there was some delay/birth while ginny was pregnant and kidnapped by saturn. Then bonney was born. where ever saturn took ginny, must be some alter time/like time chamber.
 
#26
he wouldn't experiment on celestial dragon baby. so
You shouldn't think too hard about Saturn's actions because Oda surely didn't. Why didn't he take Bonney's fruit back before kicking her mom and her out? Why didn't he check whether Vegapunk planted a bomb in Kuma or not? Why didn't he use his head popper and his venom more often? Plot convenience that's why.
 
#31
It's not a random like Charlos or something like that
Either not revealed or someone like Shamrock so they can kick his ass as revenge.
Charlos was like 10 at the time Ginny got captured, it's impossible for it to be him
And it could be a different CD, but given how she was being experimented on and was implied to have been captured by an especially strong person, not to mention male Bonney looking just like Shanks, it seems like it's definitely Shamrock.
 
#32
Charlos was like 10 at the time Ginny got captured, it's impossible for it to be him
And it could be a different CD, but given how she was being experimented on and was implied to have been captured by an especially strong person, not to mention male Bonney looking just like Shanks, it seems like it's definitely Shamrock.
It's definitely not some fatso ugly bastard discord mod Carlos lookalike who took a Revo Commander as his wife, it was one of the Holy Knights AT THE VERY LEAST and the chance is really high it was Shamrock.
Adult male Bonney looked like Shanks. This isn't a coincidence.
 
#33
I wouldn't be so sure about it lol, there is still hierarchy within Mary Geoise.
time chamber, we might see one, when that new stick in the mud take over saturn position and obtains saturns other labs and research data.

It's definitely not some fatso ugly bastard discord mod Carlos lookalike who took a Revo Commander as his wife, it was one of the Holy Knights AT THE VERY LEAST and the chance is really high it was Shamrock.
Adult male Bonney looked like Shanks. This isn't a coincidence.
imo she resemble kuma more, more theory of some time manipulation the body/slow down from saturn.. ginny was excited to meet up with kuma, before she got kidnapped. meaning she might been pregnant and wanted to tell kuma. for her excitement.


saturn was the one who gave order to capture ginny because of kuma. imo that celestial wife story is bs.

time manipulation df imo was used on ginny/slow delay the baby.




even saturn told bonney she was kuma daughter as admitted by him. if that where false he would told bonney your not even of his blood since saturn was shown to be honest even with have how evil was. he was logical.
 
#35
Saturn said bonney was kuma daughter, showing how obsessed he was with kuma and his family.

he wouldn't experiment on celestial dragon baby. so i am sure there was some delay/birth while ginny was pregnant and kidnapped by saturn. Then bonney was born. where ever saturn took ginny, must be some alter time/like time chamber.
Tbh no offense but this sounds like copium. We don't know what status babies fathered by CDs and slave women have in Marigeoise. They might inherit their mother's slave status.
 
#36
Tbh no offense but this sounds like copium. We don't know what status babies fathered by CDs and slave women have in Marigeoise. They might inherit their mother's slave status.
saturn experimenting on celestial child even though half blood. i doubt.

saturn has stated bonney is kuma child he never said your foster father etc, even threaten kuma he make bonney a slave. because of kuma blood.

imo that looks like saturn was aware/spying on kuma and ginny. ginny prob trying to trap kuma in marriage after she finally realized she was pregnant why she wanted to meet up with kuma in excitement.


like even when kuma said he give his life away to cure bonney, saturn had a spy den den mushi waiting and ready. imo that point to a traitor. and usually the traitor tells kuma where to go to vega punk, so saturn can watch his plan unfold. or that den den mushi never would been there.

saturn planned it, and had a traitor from kuma side.
 
#39
Bonney Father is a fodder CD.
I think low-ranking members of Revos don't know what Holy Knights look like. Usopp thought only the people with the bubble were Celestial Dragon.

Dragon said a Celestial Dragon took Ginny as his wife, the men with the bubble helmet, not a Holy Knight.

Holy Knights are more brutal, and they would kill their sick wives rather than throw them out on the street
 
Top