General & Others Be Honest Do you want a New Strawhat Member before the The Story Ends?

[LinlinLover]

My first picks would be Yamato and Vivi since they've already asked to be part of the crew and I'm sure they would have entertaining interactions with the rest of the SHs. But if Oda decided to make a new character join I wouldn't be opposed to that either. The more the merrier.

luffy will soon become pirateking, he can't let himself get disrespected by his crew anymore. he needs an enforcer.

And if it turns out the man Gloriosa loved and left Amazon Lily for was Rocks, that would make for a neat parallel

 

[kekaro]

Yes after Haki commentar man (which didnt figure out the conquerors haki, so he is only UPS man now) we need another commentator beside nami to shit on luffy and zoro

 

[NicoRobinIsQueen]

The fish filet from McDonald's got switched from a knight of the sea to a racist ahh fish who hates on Wobin for actually doing stuff. Yeah, Loki and Gunko would be great strawhats, and I don't think oda can nerf them too much in terms of character. But yeah; the duo would be fire, and I can see the chemistry

 

[Finalbeta]

I think Gunko deserves it more than Loki expecially considering her backstory.

Her past was atrocious.

 

[LinlinLover]

The fish filet from McDonald's got switched from a knight of the sea to a racist ahh fish who hates on Wobin for actually doing stuff.

Jinbe just wants to keep his wife safe

 

[NicoRobinIsQueen]

Jinbe just wants to keep his wife safe

Robin slams jinbe. And wife? Trust, the only husband Wobin will have is me (I'm half her age)

 

[HerreraIsBack]

Honestly I didn't even wanted Jinbei. He feels kind of forced. But Loki would be nice. Unlike Carrot or Yamato. Although I think Carrot does fit in the crew

 

[NotTommy]

Vivi's a must, anyone else is a plus (Yamato, Loki). Plus the grand fleet can just increase.

Yamato having Ulti and Page One as allies, on top of the Wano samurai also kinda calls into question a later joining. Oden did bail on Wano for the final voyage though, but it just seems weird for Yamato to do the same when these relationships and connections weren't even pre-established, Oda's actively connecting the character to non-Straw Hats, why, if a joining is still on the table?

I feel like Loki works just fine as a mostly indepedent force that allies with the crew in the final war. I don't see a huge need for him to join.

 

[langitbarat]

Yamato, SH needs firepower to truly worthy of being PK crew.

That, or elevating Sanji to Emperor level, which many people seems to not want to happen.

 

[garciajulieen]

The idea of having more crew member is always nice. But sadly oda just cant handle it. It would have been better if jimbe joined the grandfleet with the sun pirates instead of joining the crew. Chopper should have a lot of potential but now he is just a mascot. And even brook is almost non existent for me.

So no, its already too much. Yamato can just make her own crew and join the grandfleet. Loki can join Hajrudin. I think its better this way

 

[Jailer]

No, he should already focus on the current cast to achieve their dreams

Jinbei haters can suck off

 

[PuckTheGreat]

I think the ship has sailed for Yamato and thank fck for that thought she was an atrocious character.
That said, I wouldn't mind Loki and I do think he has a pretty good chance but I only want him to join if Oda has a proper purpose for him on the crew. Luffy is defo gonna invite him again once he sees his eyes lol

Also strength-wise he doesn't really feel like a character that will be beneath Luffy's wings so prolly doesn’t join.

 

[Juanpiz]

I think the ship has sailed for Yamato and thank fck for that thought she was an atrocious character.
That said, I wouldn't mind Loki and I do think he has a pretty good chance but I only want him to join if Oda has a proper purpose for him on the crew. Luffy is defo gonna invite him again once he sees his eyes lol

Also strength-wise he doesn't really feel like a character that will be beneath Luffy's wings so he prolly not

It has sailed..literally

 

[Yere93]

I'm watching the Wano anime for the first time, and after watching 1015, I need Yamato to join.

It's weird, I hated her in the manga but the anime is a whole other world. I think she has real possibilities with her cover story.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

i actually want some of the current useless fucks to die tbh

especially the fish

 

[Jackteo]

I want Loki in the strawhats

 

[Phantasm]

A new strawhat member is what I want most in the series. My favorite part of each arc is discussion around someone joining. I don't know how much I care about anything else left in the series.

 

[RZ.119]

Yes

dogshit goonerbait character

 

[BoaHancocksHusband]

ONE PERSON


BOA
HANCOCK

Post automatically merged: Jun 28, 2025

Robin slams jinbe. And wife? Trust, the only husband Wobin will have is me (I'm half her age)

NOPE

SHARK D>>>>>>>>>

 

[Bullet]

We already don't get good interactions or moments for half the strawhats so i'd pass on that. Jinbe was already a bad choice and i don't think he's added anything to the crew's dynamic so i don't think we need a new character in there as well.

Vivi could work tho since she's already an honorary strawhat anyway so let's just get her and be done.