General & Others God valley matchup

[warsame zaylai]

1)rocks vs garp and roger

2)whitebeard (right hand men) vs Rayleigh (right hand men )
Shiki vs garling

or

Shiki (right hand men ) vs Rayleigh (right hand men )
whitebeard vs garling
(I'm leaning more into this )

3) big mum vs Saturn

4)silver axe vs gaban

5)kaido vs roger (roger one shotted him )

6) sunbell vs barbell

Idk about captain john and the rest

but these match up are likely

 

[MonsterKaido]

Kaido vs Gaban

 

[warsame zaylai]

Kaido vs Gaban

He would've mentioned gaban in wano but he didnt

likely roger was the one who took him out

 

[Levi]

He would've mentioned gaban in wano but he didnt

likely roger was the one who took him out

If it’s anything more than a one shot on pre df kaido than it’s a L for roger

 

[Yoho]

Garp v Rocks

Roger v WB (the start of their rivalry)

Rayleigh v Shiki

Bogard v Kyo

Gaban v Young Kaido

Big Mom went on a side quest and was attacking Kuma and ivankov

Garling was just fighting whoever he came across

 

[warsame zaylai]

Garp v Rocks

Roger v WB (the start of their rivalry)

Rayleigh v Shiki

Bogard v Kyo

Gaban v Young Kaido

Big Mom went on a side quest and was attacking Kuma and ivankov

Garling was just fighting whoever he came across

Silver axe ?

 

[NicoRobinIsQueen]

Silver axe ?

Silver axe is kyo

 

[Yoho]

Silver axe ?

That's Kyo my bad i forget not everyone reads the scans

 

[Don Diego]

Rocks D. Xebec vs Monkey D. Garp & Gol D. Roger
I'm still not convinced it will be a 2v1. I feel like Roger will ultimately win in a 1v1. However, at this point, I don't have a clear idea of what role Garp would play if he doesn't fight Rocks.

Edward Newgate vs Figarland Garling
Whitebeard will probably take down a few Holy Knights before his clash with Garling begins. I don't think there will be a clear outcome, but during the fight, we'll likely see Shanks' father's advantage over Newgate.


Shiki vs Silvers Rayleigh
Kyou vs Scopper Gaban
Gaban and Ray vs Shiki and Kyou seems logical. It's no coincidence that Oda mentioned the rivalry between Shiki and Silver Axe in this chapter — he's very predictable. Besides, both of them use the same type of weapon as Gaban and Ray

Charlotte Linlin vs Monkey D. Garp
Kaido vs Gol D. Roger
I see these as short clashes. Roger could take down Kaido the same way he did with Oden. Garp might have a quick clash with Linlin. We have to remember that Big Mom likely had her own plans from the very beginning of the God Valley incident.

John vs Bogard
Wang Zhi Vs Monkey D. Garps left-hand man

Gloriosa vs Buckingham Stussy
Glorios will probably be the first one to betray Xebec

Ganzui vs Seagull Guns Nozdon
Don Marlon vs (Bull) Holy Knight
Barbel vs Sunbell
Buckingham Stussy vs Gloriosa
Glorios will probably be the first one to betray Xebec

Streusen vs Bogard
A short clash, while Garp fighting Big Mom.

Gil Bastar vs Petermoo

Rimoshifu Killingham vs Silvers Rayleigh
Shepherd Sommers vs Scopper Gaban

 

[Salah WG]

Wait till you see that Garling also had his own Rayleigh/Gaban,
And that other Characters might have been there, such as Harald, Sengoku, Tsuru, Chinjao, Fisher Tiger, Zeff ... etc
You guys are making Match-Ups only based on few Characters We learned were there,

God's Valley included much more than just Roger Pirate, Rocks Pirates, Garp & Garling,
There were other Holy Knights, there were Gorosei, there were CP-0, there were Countless other Pirates, Marines,
And since this is still Part of Elbaph Flashback, then who knows maybe more Giants were there too,

It's a Huge Battle Royale, the only Match-Up that matters is who Xebec Fought, Rest aren't Fixed.

 

[Welkin]

Honestly outside of Roger, Rocks, and Garp we don’t know anything that happened with anyone else

With that many top tiers it’s impossible to say who fought who. The only thing we know is Gaban met Sommers at God Valley and something occurred between them that made Sommers fear him

Whether that’s seeing him fight or fighting him himself. That could imply that the Roger Pirates actually ended up opposing the Holy Knights but it’s still impossible to say

 

[Halyup]

Honestly outside of Roger, Rocks, and Garp we don’t know anything that happened with anyone else

With that many top tiers it’s impossible to say who fought who. The only thing we know is Gaban met Sommers at God Valley and something occurred between them that made Sommers fear him

Whether that’s seeing him fight or fighting him himself. That could imply that the Roger Pirates actually ended up opposing the Holy Knights but it’s still impossible to say

They fought multiple people
this aint straight 1v1s

imagine AoEs being spammed all over the island

 

[Welkin]

They fought multiple people
this aint straight 1v1s

imagine AoEs being spammed all over the island

I’d imagine it was probably a free for all especially since we know some of the Gorosei were there as well

But there were probably a few individual fights sprinkled throughout the island

 

[gz89]

WB vs Garling
Shiki/Kyo vs Ray/Gaban, stalemate

 

[Halyup]

WB vs Garling
Shiki/Kyo vs Ray/Gaban, stalemate

Axe is not present at GV flashback of kuma
I guess hes the traitor thst stole the treasure of beehive

 

[Don Diego]

Axe is not present at GV flashback of kuma
I guess hes the traitor thst stole the treasure of beehive

Don Marlon and Wang Zhi weren't shown either. That doesn't mean he wasn't there

 

[warsame zaylai]

Rocks vs roger = roger
Harald vs Garp (harald is gonna notice how evil is WG and turn back to rocks ) = garp
whitebard vs garling = ends as a draw
Shiki vs silver axe ( working for WG ) = Shiki (death of silver axe )
Saturn vs kaido = Saturn ( kaido gets captured )
Rayleigh vs BM = Rayleigh wins

gaban/bogard/holy knights alliance vs the rest of rocks pirates (captain john, gill bastar, gloriosa, barbel, don Marlon, wang Zhi, ganzui, Stussy and streusen)

 

[Cruxroux]

Rocks vs roger = roger
Harald vs Garp (harald is gonna notice how evil is WG and turn back to rocks ) = garp
whitebard vs garling = ends as a draw
Shiki vs silver axe ( working for WG ) = Shiki (death of silver axe )
Saturn vs kaido = Saturn ( kaido gets captured )
Rayleigh vs BM = Rayleigh wins

gaban/bogard/holy knights alliance vs the rest of rocks pirates (captain john, gill bastar, gloriosa, barbel, don Marlon, wang Zhi, ganzui, Stussy and streusen)

Half of them doesn't make any sense.

Roger vs Xebec
Rayleigh vs Shiki
Gaban vs silver axe
Garp vs Harald? They have no connection

 

[warsame zaylai]

Half of them doesn't make any sense.

Roger vs Xebec
Rayleigh vs Shiki
Gaban vs silver axe
Garp vs Harald? They have no connection

Shiki is gonna fight silver axe because he was introduced as shiki rival and working for the WG (traitor)
harald is gonna switch side to rocks but imu is going to control him and thats when garp stops him
rocks vs roger (this chapter hinted it )
Rayleigh is either gonna fight one of the elders or BM

 

[Jinjoo]

Harald won't be joining rocks in God valley. If anything he was their on command of gorosei to take out rocks and may have even dealt the killing blow.

Don't forget Harald later on went to holy land and met shanks there. I don't think he would be allowed to enter holy land if he openly joined hands with xebec and he is too old and matured to pull the same thing he pulled back in the day.