Cons of Imgur include lossy image compression that degrades quality, a sometimes biased and toxic community with mob mentality leading to unfair downvotes, reliability issues with content disappearing due to inactive account purging and general unreliability, and a less user-friendly interface and uploader than in the past. Imgur also has less support for NSFW content and may have restrictions and requirements like phone numbers for new accounts.
Technical & Content Issues
Image Quality Degradation:
Imgur's new uploader heavily compresses images, which isn't lossless, and this can result in a significant loss of image quality, making it unsuitable for high-resolution or detailed visuals.
Content Erasure:
Imgur has started deleting "old, unused, and inactive content" not tied to a user account, which could lead to the loss of valuable internet history.
Reliability Concerns:
Some users report that Imgur hosted images are not displaying correctly, leading to uncertainty about the reliability of the platform for image hosting.
NSFW Content Restrictions:
As of May 2023, Imgur no longer hosts "nudity, pornography, & sexually explicit content".
Community & User Experience
Toxicity and Mob Mentality:
The community can be biased and exhibit a "mob mentality," leading to negative and unfair downvoting, even for benign content.
Inconsistent moderation:
Users and staff have reported that the moderation system's policies change constantly, leading to confusion and inconsistent application of rules.
Unprofessional Management:
Some reviews suggest internal management issues, lack of transparency, and unwillingness to accept valid criticism from staff or users.
Demanding Account Requirements:
New accounts may face restrictions, and some users report needing to provide a phone number for registration, potentially leading to unwanted marketing calls.
Historical Context
Shift from Hosting Service: Imgur was originally created to solve the problem of easily sharing images on Reddit, but it has since evolved into a social media platform, which some users view as a negative "enshittification" of its original purpose.