Forum's been cooked since Wano ended. When you've got the more or less the same people being the most active posters in spoiler thread, you know it's a wrap.
Nika truly was the final nail.

It always bugs me that Oda never lets his fictional species be devil fruit or fishman options when Strong World showed us that there are plenty of crazy options that could have still been explored, especially during Onigashima instead of just making Smiles a bunch of ugly comic relief mutants. There's even land-based versions of aquatic animals, so it would allow for even more creative devil fruit options that could fit fishmen and allow them to assume more beastly versions of the animal they're based on or assume weird hybrid forms, like a shark fishman with a forest octopus devil fruit.

And the only Oda-based fishman species is Dillinger, but he makes fuck all sense. He's from North Blue and his species is based on one exclusive to Dressrosa, a place he has never been to until later in his life.
 
Last edited:

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
Here’s a rundown of the 10 characters that generate the most heated, never-ending discussions on WorstGen Forums (a large One Piece–focused community). The list is based on long-standing thread counts, recurring debates, and how often these characters spark “power-scaling wars” and controversial takes:


1. Kaido

Why debated: “Strongest creature” hype, Flame Dragon Torch feats, comparisons to Roger/Whitebeard, and the question of whether Luffy truly beat him 1-on-1.
Typical arguments: “Is Kaido still strongest post-defeat?” vs. “Admirals > Yonko.”


2. Monkey D. Luffy

Why debated: Gear 5’s reality-warping powers, Joy Boy status, and whether he already sits at Pirate King/Top Tier level.
Typical arguments: “Luffy > all Yonko already?” vs. “Still needs endgame growth.”


3. Admirals (Akainu, Kizaru, Aokiji)

Why debated: Admiral vs. Yonko power scaling is the forum’s single most persistent war.
Typical arguments: “Akainu > Kaido,” “Kizaru vs. Gear 5,” “Greenbull feats were underrated.”


4. Blackbeard (Marshall D. Teach)

Why debated: Yami + Gura combos, “endgame final boss” theories, and how his durability stacks up.
Typical arguments: “Teach is already strongest” vs. “He still needs a third fruit.”


5. Shanks

Why debated: His mysterious power level, one-armed supremacy, and the “Yonko portrayal vs. feats” debate.
Typical arguments: “Shanks > Mihawk,” “Shanks vs. Blackbeard outcome,” “Is his CoC the strongest?”


6. Mihawk

Why debated: Title of “World’s Strongest Swordsman,” Zoro’s end goal, and whether he’s above Yonko level.
Typical arguments: “Mihawk > Shanks” vs. “Shanks’ Haki > Mihawk’s sword.”


7. Zoro

Why debated: “Zoro vs. Luffy” internal rivalry, King fight feats, and constant “Admiral-level already?” claims.
Typical arguments: “Zoro > Luffy at Wano,” “Zoro can cut Kaido solo.”


8. Big Mom (Charlotte Linlin)

Why debated: Inconsistencies in her portrayal—terrifying power vs. comedic losses.
Typical arguments: “Big Mom > Kaido,” “Law & Kid only won by plot.”


9. Sanji

Why debated: Power spikes (exoskeleton, Ifrit Jambe), Lunarian genes, and Zoro vs. Sanji matchups.
Typical arguments: “Sanji > Zoro endgame?” vs. “Still YC2 level.”


10. Gol D. Roger & Rocks D. Xebec (tie)

Why debated:


  • Roger: Whether he truly outclasses all Yonko/Admirals or if “prime Whitebeard = Roger.”
  • Rocks: Pure speculation—what his true power was, and whether he was stronger than Kaido/Whitebeard combo.
:kobeha: your chatgpt became a retarded Kaidou wanker. You need to quit making it suck Kaidou off every chance you get, Zoro and Sanji at 7 and 9 😭
 
Top