Anime Discussion Best Seasonal Anime Ranking

[AL sama]

Random reviews from MAL users.

I did try to get reviews for the full season instead of a couple eps but also not too long because of the 34999 character limit per post.

makes sense cause these reviews are cringe as hell

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

makes sense cause these reviews are cringe as hell

Lil bro can't take praises.

 

[Mashiro Blue]

Retagging for those who haven't voted yet

Spoiler

@Rej
@AL sama
@Jaguark101
@DarkWitch
@MonsterKaido
@GrandmasterChef Zonji
@The White Crane
@PeronaNerona
@Luka
@MonsterKaido
@Yoho
@Hyde
@gz89
@Medei
@Ratchet
@Peroroncino
@AverageNa
@CoC: Color of Clowns

 

[Ratchet]

I vote for Umamusame: Cinderella Gray

 

[Rej]

Uma Musume: 4
Tatsuki Fujimoto: 3
Gachiakuta: 2
Spy x Family: 1

@Ratchet you have to distribute 10 points like this, 4 max for one anime, to make it count for waifubro

 

[Mashiro Blue]

For this contest, it is not mandatory to use all points or vote for anime you haven't watched.

Granted saying how many points we'll be giving is important but if it's just one anime then logically the points given would be 4 I think

 

[vikas]

One Piece

 

[Rej]

For this contest, it is not mandatory to use all points or vote for anime you haven't watched.

Granted saying how many points we'll be giving is important but if it's just one anime then logically the points given would be 4 I think

It's an Uma stomp, simple as that. Uma won. Even if 10 more nibbos vote. Uma still wins. Year of the horse. Decade of the horse. It is done. People have to open their eyes. Bow down to the true winner. Uma AotY. They didn't even attempt for it to become AotY and it is still AotY. Fucky Crunchyroll. Uma > Crunchyroll. Nibbos crumbling at the glare of the horse. Uma > JJBA.

 

[Ratchet]

I vote for Umamusame: Cinderella Gray

Thanks guys. I give 4 points!

 

[Mashiro Blue]

Votes

​

Saitoh

1. Touring after the apocalypse. 3 pts
2. This monster wants to eat me. 3 pts
3. May I ask for one final thing? 4 pts


Rej

Uma Musume: 4
Tatsuki Fujimoto: 3
Gachiakuta: 2
Spy x Family: 1


Mashiro Blue

Uma Musume: 4
Spy X Family: 2
A Wild Last Boss has Appeared: 2
Who Made Me a Princess: 2


Warchief Sanji D Goat

SANDA: 3.
Gnosia: 3.
This Monster Wants to Eat Me: 2.
Let This Grieving Soul Retire S2: 2.


Ratchet

Uma Musume: 4

Results

1st Place - Uma Musume Cinderella Gray

(12 points)



2nd Place - This Monster wants to Eat Me

(5 points)



3rd Place - May I ask for One Final Thing?

(4 points)


​

This was pretty cool as a test run. I believe we can go on for now and slowly get more participants. I want to thank everyone who made submissions as well as those who voted.

Now if there's interest in retroactively doing the other seasons of 2025 (only and no more than 2025) pls let me know.

Spoiler

@Rej
@AL sama
@Jaguark101
@DarkWitch
@MonsterKaido
@GrandmasterChef Zonji
@The White Crane
@PeronaNerona
@Luka
@MonsterKaido
@Yoho
@Hyde
@gz89
@Medei
@Ratchet
@Peroroncino
@AverageNa
@CoC: Color of Clowns
@SaitoH

​

 

[Rej]

Votes

​

Saitoh

1. Touring after the apocalypse. 3 pts
2. This monster wants to eat me. 3 pts
3. May I ask for one final thing? 4 pts


Rej

Uma Musume: 4
Tatsuki Fujimoto: 3
Gachiakuta: 2
Spy x Family: 1


Mashiro Blue

Uma Musume: 4
Spy X Family: 2
A Wild Last Boss has Appeared: 2
Who Made Me a Princess: 2


Warchief Sanji D Goat

SANDA: 3.
Gnosia: 3.
This Monster Wants to Eat Me: 2.
Let This Grieving Soul Retire S2: 2.


Ratchet

Uma Musume: 4

Results

1st Place - Uma Musume Cinderella Gray

(12 points)



2nd Place - This Monster wants to Eat Me

(5 points)



3rd Place - May I ask for One Final Thing?

(4 points)


​

This was pretty cool as a test run. I believe we can go on for now and slowly get more participants. I want to thank everyone who made submissions as well as those who voted.

Now if there's interest in retroactively doing the other seasons of 2025 (only and no more than 2025) pls let me know.

Spoiler

@Rej
@AL sama
@Jaguark101
@DarkWitch
@MonsterKaido
@GrandmasterChef Zonji
@The White Crane
@PeronaNerona
@Luka
@MonsterKaido
@Yoho
@Hyde
@gz89
@Medei
@Ratchet
@Peroroncino
@AverageNa
@CoC: Color of Clowns
@SaitoH

​

Uma sweep, nice!

Yeah let's go, let's farm the participants lol