Questions & Mysteries Has anyone killed an immortal before Loki?

#1
Chapter 1170’s Gaban explanation for how CoC affects Immortals is seemingly “With enough CoC attacks, immortals have their Regeneration slowed and feel so much pain that they cannot continue fighting

Gaban seemingly doesn’t say Immortal can be killed. He says that immortals can get knocked out by too much pain and slowed down regeneration

Which kind of makes sense since Sommers is alive yet Sommers fought the Roger pirates seemingly multiple times and got stomped each and every time. Why would Sommers be alive if he could be killed?

Imu’s reaction to Harald’s death is seemingly that it’s extremely rare for this to happen. The only other scenario similar to this is Imu and the WG avoiding Wano simply because of Ryuma same way they avoided Elbaf because of Loki
 
Last edited:
#7
Maybe Whitebeard. There are only eight Holy Knights who have the Depth Covenant.
They want to give Shanks a Depth Covenant, meaning a Holy Knight has been killed or died of old age.
 
#10
No one from haralds era onwards has.
You have to take into consideration that Imu is explaining that immortals dying affects him TO THE GOROSEI

The Gorosei who have been with Imu for hundreds of years. He’s the colaininf to them what happens when an immortal dies

this is such a rare situation that seemingly either all or some of the gorosei require an explanation from Imu


Maybe Whitebeard. There are only eight Holy Knights who have the Depth Covenant.
They want to give Shanks a Depth Covenant, meaning a Holy Knight has been killed or died of old age.
Well we know that Imu is fine killing immortals himself by removing his powers from them. That’s what happened with Saturn

Imu is seemingly separating the idea of him removing his powers from someone and then killing them from this Loki situation where his immortality is straight up defeated
 
Top