Speculations Did Shanks beat Loki in a clean 1 vs 1?

Did Shanks really beat Loki 1 vs 1?


  • Total voters
    73
Loki being stronger doesn't mean he beats mihawk or shanks in a 1v1, I'm talking about his overall base stats.

If Shanks can lock loki up without having to have a difficult fight with him, he should do that, why would he do otherwise when they literally share history together, being in the same room when Loki killed his father.

Shanks felt responsible for Harald's death, and doesn't want Loki to die either. What I'm talking about is overall stats like I already mentioned, could Mihawk outskill loki despite loki having more AP than him? sure, could Shanks have more haki mass to compete with Loki? sure.

When I mentioned why you have certainty, I was talking about from an objective standpoint, you say you're trying to scale loki this way, to not put him above kaido and old gen, sure sure, but your bias reeks for shanks, even if it turns out to be true, which it very well could be.

The scenario I painted was an IF statement in the first place, IF and only if Shanks had to go about it in a roundabout way.

Loki's attack has demonstrated it's affect and the surrounding context behind it shows it's portrayal, you can't even say shanks divine departure does as well on Harald, because we haven't seen it's affect on an immortal ancient giant.

Right now you have to objectively say Loki looks more impressive until otherwise, but you refuse because you're biased.
Dude, I already answered all of that,
I already said Loki have Superior Body & Superior World Threatening Power than Shanks, what more do you want?
But I told you that when Adv. CoC enters the Conversation, all that Superiority becomes Obsolete,

I literally listed so many Characters who are Superior than Shanks as a Being, but can They beat him? My Answer is No,
You're triggered by my first comment where I said that "Shanks can beat Loki in a fair 1v1",
And then you come & talk to me about Stats & whatever, even though I only mentioned Dueling, I never ever said Loki have Inferior Stats than Shanks, I even said that Loki is bigger Threat than Kaidou & WB,

You're just arguing for the sake of argument, you just want to say "I'm Biased" & then write a story around it,
Bias is when I lean towards an idea even though it doesn't apply to the logic I follow, it's when i twist & switch opinions to suit my agenda,

You can check my comment from previous threads about Adv. CoC, I always said that when Adv. CoC is included in a Duel, it makes all Stats Advantages Obsolete (Which includes DFs, Race Superiority, Abyss Contract, Science Boost, Special Weapons ... etc), and I don't apply my Logic only to Shanks, I said countless times that since Adv. CoC does that, then all Adv. CoC Users in their Prime are Equals, so I don't consider Roger or Xebec any different than Shanks, same for Garp or Oden or Rayleigh or Gaban,

My Opinion is still the same, I will not put anyone above Shanks & his Equals, unless I see a Power that Deletes Adv. CoC,
If Loki's DF or Ragnir is shown to Negate Adv. CoC, then I will be the first to put him above Shanks & his Peers.
 
I don't think that Shanks want to beat him. I think Shanks was too lazy to go for a long unneccessary fight. So he went in a good par or better then got his crew take Loki down.

Shanks didnt want Loki pointlessly die against WG. Harald death was already in Shanks mind.

Loki thinks Shanks was a Coward who didnt dare to go againts WG. But Shanks though the other view, that the requirements was still incomplete. (1 of them: Luffy 3b existence)

So i choose: *No, Shanks had help*
But it doesnt mean He couldnt beat him in extreme of high dif. That time (6 years ago) was the same year he became a Yonkou, so i cant put a mid diff. Maybe (maybe) different with the current shanks
 
Where is it stated Destiny's Child Shanks is stronger than WSS Mihawk?
I can show you at least 10 sources saying Mihawk > Shanks

Anyways Mihawk might be the only true God Tier besides Loki if we take away Imu
Shanks ain't all that
There's no sources saying Mihawk > Shanks in the manga, if you mean your loose interpretatiom of statements in the manga, then i can show you at least 10 of those too. But way to go and derail every thread into constantly wishing for Mihawk > Shanks without any proof, and even adding more baseless wishes that Mihawk is the true god tier beside Loki.
 
There's no sources saying Mihawk > Shanks in the manga, if you mean your loose interpretatiom of statements in the manga, then i can show you at least 10 of those too. But way to go and derail every thread into constantly wishing for Mihawk > Shanks without any proof, and even adding more baseless wishes that Mihawk is the true god tier beside Loki.
Shanks = Swordsman
Mihawk = Stronger Swordsman

It will never change
Only thing debatable is difficulty

And currently I am leaning more towards Mihawk winning mid diff than extreme
 

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
Tbh, even if Loki isn't as strong as some say he is, it's a bit hard to believe Shanks from 6 years ago can beat someone that can fight on par with the likes of immortal Harald/Rocks. It's probably not a clear one-on-one, Shanks likely did something crazy and stopped Loki without actually defeating him.
 
Tbh, even if Loki isn't as strong as some say he is, it's a bit hard to believe Shanks from 6 years ago can beat someone that can fight on par with the likes of immortal Harald/Rocks. It's probably not a clear one-on-one, Shanks likely did something crazy and stopped Loki without actually defeating him.
Whitebeard,Kaido,Loki…Nobody can stop him:finally:
 
Tbh, even if Loki isn't as strong as some say he is, it's a bit hard to believe Shanks from 6 years ago can beat someone that can fight on par with the likes of immortal Harald/Rocks. It's probably not a clear one-on-one, Shanks likely did something crazy and stopped Loki without actually defeating him.
Heard a theory that went like
“Shanks:Loki let’s see how strong you are,I don’t think you can break these massive strong-chains,prove me wrong if you can!!
Shanks and Loki discuss about this over a drink and Loki agrees.
Shanks then slaps some sense into him and gives him his vivre card while he’s chained up so that way they reunite some time in the future
It has some Norse mythology accuracy too so it could ironically play out.
 
Heard a theory that went like
“Shanks:Loki let’s see how strong you are,I don’t think you can break these massive strong-chains,prove me wrong if you can!!
Shanks and Loki discuss about this over a drink and Loki agrees.
Shanks then slaps some sense into him and gives him his vivre card while he’s chained up so that way they reunite some time in the future
It has some Norse mythology accuracy too so it could ironically play out.
Heard a theory that went like
"Loki fans took an IQ test and they scored lower than their shoe size"
 
Nobody likes you or takes you seriously,I don’t know why your even still allowed to have takes when every single one is universally disliked.Just self delete your account or stay away from powerscaling debates useless retard
I'm sorry my theories don't live up to your retarded "Loki put the handcuffs on himself because I don't want to accept reality" level of discourse.
 
Tbh, even if Loki isn't as strong as some say he is, it's a bit hard to believe Shanks from 6 years ago can beat someone that can fight on par with the likes of immortal Harald/Rocks. It's probably not a clear one-on-one, Shanks likely did something crazy and stopped Loki without actually defeating him.
Yeah.

Shanks didn't play dirty because It's unlike him; however, he didn't beat Loki either.

Loki is someone campable of fighting Roger + enemies.
 
I'm sorry my theories don't live up to your retarded "Loki put the handcuffs on himself because I don't want to accept reality" level of discourse.
Mind you this wasnt my theory lol.so you should insult the actual person who came up with it,and you’re getting put on ignore I’m not going out my day to argue with a brick wall.
 
Last edited:
Loki = Fenrir
Shanks = Tyr

Loki is the embodiment of what Xebec wanted for Harald to step into lol. A powerhouse with Elbaf‘s legendary fruit, and the strongest nation behind him. Loki is bare minimum stronger than base Harald and his equals. Would make zero sense for him to be weaker when he has the coveted ancient fruit. Some people still think that Shanks beat this guy in a 1-on-1 😂.
 
Top