Summons are part of a shinobi's strength, no different than Kiba's hounds or Shino's insects. Whether Naruto could consistently summon Gamabunta on his first try or not, he has the chakra to spare to try again and Sasuke has no real way of stopping him from doing it.
.
I don't disagree that Ninjas can use summons in fights, but it does seem like it's portrayed that Gamabunta is someone Naruto can only summon when amped by a potential fear of death(when he was falling off the cliff), or when he was amped by a fear of Sakura dying(it was specifically mentioned that he got stronger at that point then he usually does. We've seen him not be able to do so in situations where he could have definitely used it like in the fight against Orochimaru/Kabuto in the Tsunade arc. Tbh, this kind of feels like an inconsistent plot thing, but if we get full on arcs after the Chunin exams where Naruto pulls it off again, it feels fair to say that it isn't a reliable part of his fighting style.
After checking, you probably have a point that Gamabunta was just being Tsundere about not wanting to fight a tailed beasts, but he also doesn't seem like the type to show up in a minor mission or a clash with a rookie Sasuke. Having respect from your summon seems to be part of the process(for example, Kabuto is worried about Manda because he thinks Manda won't listen to him, or armless Orochimaru). Kishi probably thinks of him as Narutos loyal summon only by the pain arc, at which point Naruto was stronger.
It was enough to overpower Neji. The only reason their clash sent them both flying was because of way Kaiten redirects chakra.
What you're missing is that it didn't actually work. Naruto was digging a tunnel as soon as he hit the ground and then finished Neji. If Neji hadn't used Kaiten, he would've got a far worse beating.
.
You have a point here tbh. Naruto could probably overpower base Sasuke in cqc at this point, but with the Curse Mark that he got around the same time Naruto starts to tap into the nine tails chakra, he should be able to keep up, which is ultimately what did happen.
Sasuke's hype was tied to his clan legacy and a Sharingan he hadn't even matured yet.
As for Naruto's talent, I think we can stop pretending Kishimoto's dialogue matched what he showed us.
As if stealing the scroll wasn't impressive enough, Naruto learned Shadow Clones in a matter of hours. He learned the Rasengan in a week. Created the Rasenshuriken in a matter of weeks. It took him a week to master Sage Mode in a week, and he came back with several new jutsu.
Before all of that, he kept pace with Sasuke on tree-walking.
Naruto was disadvantaged in chakra control for most of his life, but he never lacked for cunning or IQ.
Underdog or no, Naruto's talent i. I'd say he is arguably the most gifted shinobi in history. Just imagine where he would have been if he had received proper tutelage from a young age.
I can agree that Naruto is a prodigy himself, but it is clear portrayal, and by the standards of part 1, he isn't necessarily the top dog of the child prodigies. You would have something like:
Haku/Kimmimaro
Gaara/Sasuke(Gaara didn't really train before the retrieval arc, which leads to him getting a good bit stronger, as mentioned by Lee)
Naruto/Neji/
Rock Lee/maybe the sound 4?
And let's keep in mind, Orochimaru lived in Konoha for like 30ish years, and only Sasuke and Itachi were shown impressing him among the Uchiha clan, so it's not the clan alone that made Sasuke special
so yeah, imo Orochimaru is having a bit of cartoonishly high standards, but Imo it's similar to Kaido saying that Luffy is weak at the start of the Chunin exams, it just shows how much room he will have to grow. In Orochimaru's mind, nothing he's seen from Naruto up to that point was impressive, or worth Jiraiya spending his time, even after he beat Neji or Gaara, while knowing he has the nine tails and is minato's son.
We also know that he actually starts seeing Naruto as a potential threat after he gets the Rasengan
so it's not like he isn't being objective based on what he's seen. Which again fits with the idea that Naruto only became stronger then Sasuke after learning the Rasengan.
Kabuto also reiterates the same thing, with him also saying that Sasuke couldn't be taken down by Naruto at that point, and like Orochimaru he watched him fight Neji, and Kabuto isn't as delusional as Orochimaru either.
I feel like when you have 2 statements like this from different characters, we gotta admit that at this point, Sasuke was at least a bit ahead.
Naruto's fruity little suicide pact with Sasuke has always been rooted in sentimentality.
If he wanted blood, this rivalry would look very different.
Fair enough, but it's not like MS Sasuke didn't try challenging all the 5 Kage and ended up killing one, I wouldn't exactly classify him as a fraud thriving due to Naruto's mercy at that point in the manga.