@Flower Generally from role claims that's towny for York, but what's scummy is lack of progression, until the post above, actually, that what was missing.
I'm not saying she has to land on me being town again, it's not about me at all, but when someone is not progressing on their reads at all, then it's suspicious for me.
Like, Town person changes their mind, doubts, then comes back to a read etc. York was extremely scarse with reads, and the main read was me which didn't move at all.
Scum creates a tierlist and moves along with it for better part of the game, Town has shifts everywhere.
***
I agree that protein to townlean Hayumi is diminishing. Was enough for d1, d2 (that post "why you ain't talking to me when I'm here?!" was cool), but he needs to do more stuff, he's becoming a camping background character without development now. Although I think he was saying in sign up thread that his activity will be lower? You have to check. But I think that he knows how to make himself more... likeable in the thread? That's my impression from Cross Community and last game. Here he seems to not play towards that.