[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fair point.

I do get the impression ive generally slipped into POE though, which is fine, good infact.

I want hime to give something spicy
Speaking of spice...

TAG
Reloaded
Ginger
Bitter
Cal
Hayumi
What do you think about Orca's PoE?

It's quite spicy, isn't it?

He thinks I'm scum, and that ginger is scum. He also appears to not like one of the cop-clears.

You're in his PoE too.

Any thoughts on that?

I notice you didn't like it when hime put you in her PoE. You made several posts about it. But when Orca puts you in PoE, you don't bat an eye?
 
I'm not happy that all Orca did this phase was curtly reiterate stuff he said last phase.
I don't like that his Day 3 scum reads were:

TAG
Ginger
Juliet
Bitter
Jan
Cal
And today they are:

TAG
Reloaded
Ginger
Bitter
Cal
Hayumi
Feels like just shoving 2 more players in between days in order to have 6 people he can justify lynching.

But there is absolutely zero effort to actually engage with these people or to try and actually push for any of them. Just a parked vote on me.

I have been his biggest scum read/push since Day 3, and now he's voted Reloaded who wasn't even on his Day 3 list and likely only got pigeon-holed there for convenience.

He's pushed me a little.
Made some noise at ginger.
Ignored Cal, who's been in his list since Day 1 but with zero actual effort to lynch him
Bitter is basically in everyone's PoE except Flower
Hayumi/Reloaded are the replacements for Jan and Juliet

And people are town-reading him why?
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
This "townish SK" thing? But it's a repeat of the read he made like 4 days ago now.
The one ginger mentioned and yeah sure but it still has nuance. I feel like as scum he'd more likely to be offer a blanket read, probably a more favourable one at that given that Polar is going to expect him to have a good read on him, he doesn't really stand to gain anything from his current position. It being an old read doesn't just mean it loses all value. Speaking from my own perspective my reads also haven't changed much, there's little reason to when the flips aren't disproving your directions. So I don't agree that them being rather stale is indicative of much here.
 
Ratchet, Cal has stated that hime is a better player than you, and so should be held to a higher standard.

This seems weirdly at odds with what other players (Jan, Crying) have said about you earlier in the game, that you're a good player with decent range.

Could I get you to weigh in on this assessment?
 
So, this one then?

Bit of a mixed bag really. If you needed a gun to my head read, townish SK lol. I don't have him as town, but not mafia either. Feels a bit in the background and focused on a smaller suspect pile to avoid a bigger wrath so to speak maybe. I think he has been more focused on solving town than finding scum, but does feel genuine
In a game which is now known to possess an Indie, you don't find it at curious that he's drawing attention to another player in a way that suggests he might be scum, but not "real" scum?

Can I ask your opinion on the *other* 142 posts he made that aren't a single nuanced "could be 3p" Day 3 read on one player?
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Ratchet, Cal has stated that hime is a better player than you, and so should be held to a higher standard.

This seems weirdly at odds with what other players (Jan, Crying) have said about you earlier in the game, that you're a good player with decent range.

Could I get you to weigh in on this assessment?
When did Cal say that? That seems unlike him, and I don't recall seeing that at all.

That said I don't take it too badly, hime is a good player who is very smart and analytical, I think the main thing I would have over her at this point is just sheer experience rather than any huge skill margin or something like that.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
So, this one then?



In a game which is now known to possess an Indie, you don't find it at curious that he's drawing attention to another player in a way that suggests he might be scum, but not "real" scum?

Can I ask your opinion on the *other* 142 posts he made that aren't a single nuanced "could be 3p" Day 3 read on one player?
That was his older comment but if that's the origin of it, sure. I was commenting on the read he made today. I don't have much of an opinion of the rest, I preferred him to Polar earlier in the game for reasons I can't remember very well and generally trust each other's read on them. I saw someone say Polar had Orca as town which I'm inclined to sheep.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top