Light game Gym Leader Mafia: Silver

Actually I‘m so fucking stupid.

When there’s somebody who can speed up poison then it’s for the reason to dodge a Heal.

Urek‘s Poison should have confirmed Yoho as Town.

(woke up to get some water, I‘m in bed again soon)
 
Part of me wonders if we can just clear Watson off it? I don’t think the scum team ever uses a direct kill on Urek N1 like this and Watson would have expected you to poison her, so why speed it up just to kill herself??
 
This is true yeah. @Dr. Watson did you ever explain your town reads?
not really, but I can elaborate

Got out my notes

Abigail- I kept Ms. Princess in my 'absolutely never lynch' town pile partially because of her conviction between her D1 read of me. She showed the capability of keeping an evolving thought process that showed that she was solving in a cohesive manner. She has shown her focus and her evaluating earnestly. Her effort fully comes off as town driven with no agenda.

Flower- In regards to Flower herself, her accuracy in her read on me and her willingness to cooperate with Abby gives me major confidence in her position.

Fuji- I know that he (in this case you since you summoned me, but it's for everyone to read, so, gonna use these pronouns) isn't necessarily sold on me being town which is all well and good, whatever to that.
His interactions and demeanor are very much within his town meta. The way he was involved with the Kriss wagon also pings town. Been pretty consistent, too. He's perfectly capable of powerwolfing but the innate trust Flower has in him is also a positive. If I trust in her; I trust in him. Vice versa, really.

The reason the three of you are untouchable is we've developed a strong town core I don't care to have to re-examine at this point in time.

Czuek- Town-read was claim driven when I made the town read list.
 
Bitter is a weird one. He could simply be deflecting to get the heat off of him as a last ditch effort to self-pres or be absolutely wrong about me.

I'm in agreement that a cop result wraps things up with a pretty little bow but it almost feels like a red flag mechanically I can't get past easily. The downside to going purely by mech - which is reasonable - is ignoring the content and context of a player's behavior. In a game this small with a cop that outed themselves in the beginning, isn't this too easy? If it is in fact not easy, wouldn't/shouldn't there be a counter-balance like invest immunity? We know he derps as town; that doesn't mean he can't derp as scum.
I think that we underestimate his ability which can lead to a lot of poor reasoning and shaky logic when examining his slot.

I don't know who I miscleared if it isn't him
 
Yeah I do think I survived because either scum has strong position in town (like Flower or Abi) or he is invest-immune and decided it was better to let me live because of my low activity. And why would he even let me, Flower or Abi survive? I could've faked that I'm only 1x, so invest-immunity fits. But I dunno, didn't read-up because I knew Abi will poison me today
 
Yeah I do think I survived because either scum has strong position in town (like Flower or Abi) or he is invest-immune and decided it was better to let me live because of my low activity. And why would he even let me, Flower or Abi survive? I could've faked that I'm only 1x, so invest-immunity fits. But I dunno, didn't read-up because I knew Abi will poison me today
Scum likely just don’t have a night kill left.
 
And as I said in both scenarios it doesn’t really make sense for Watson to be scum.

1) She kills Urek directly, Abi literally claimed Poisoner and was after her, she‘d just kill her.
2) She speeds up the Poison, again all it does is kill her quicker and make it impossible for her to get healed by Yoho on D2.
 
Top