General & Others Is worst generation a mistake?

[Orojackson Refugee]

Looking back, only few were relevant.

Law is great, with significant fanbase in Japan
Kidd is....well he has 5 fans in this forum
Bonney only shows relevancy after Wano, but since she's linked with Vegapunk and Kuma she might have some supporting roles in the future
Meanwhile.....does Oda still remember Urouge?

What do u think?

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Didn't Lolda admit he added them in last minute because of an editor comment and he excepted to write half of them dying or quitting in the New World but couldn't be bothered?

The issue is the fanbase delusions if anything lol

 

[ZenZu]

The strawhats were a mistake. They have been less relevant than the Worst Generation.

 

[Orojackson Refugee]

 

[Loki D. Terror]

Looking back, only few were relevant.

Law is great, with significant fanbase in Japan
Kidd is....well he has 5 fans in this forum
Bonney only shows relevancy after Wano, but since she's linked with Vegapunk and Kuma she might have some supporting roles in the future
Meanwhile.....does Oda still remember Urouge?

What do u think?

Kidd has lots of fans in general. He ranked in top 20-25 iirc in popularity poll.

I think it depends. Hawkins , L drake , apoo were fails.

 

[kurwa]

It's a mistake because the group makes no sense, like whatsoever
At first it was rookies with bounties over 100mil, which is random but fine
And then randomly Blackbeard was slapped with the supernovas for no reason whatsoever despite not ever been to sabaody at that time, which only raises questions why someone like Marco was not slapped onto the group as well.

Dumb group with dumb concept

 

[BaboonMihawk]

From what I heard, @Pantheos was using the subscription money from this forum to buy internet bots and increase kidd votes

Why u downplay worst generation bro?

Is it because Sanji is not one of them?

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Why u downplay worst generation bro?

Is it because Sanji is not one of them?

He literally one of the biggest Sanji haters here

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Yeah probably but aside from Law he basically got rid of all of them.
He gave the readers a little bit of fan service in between for those who liked them.

 

[Orojackson Refugee]

Why u downplay worst generation bro?

Is it because Sanji is not one of them?

Sanji is my favorite character, please dont make fun of him

 

[Robsonbuster]

I like them as a plot device to make the NW arcs feel more connected to the bigger story as a whole, although some (Law, Kidd, Killer, also Bege in WCI) are much better than others (Apoo, Hawkins).

 

[Jackteo]

I think all of them could've been a great addition to the story with some tweaks. As they are, they represented well enough all possible paths an untrained strawhat crew could've taken and added some color to an otherwise bleak NW pirating world. I'd have killed some of them

Great additions: BB, Capone, Hawkins, Killer (unless he is alive)

Good additions: Bonney, Drake, Law (he should have died on Dressrosa), Kidd (unless he isn't dead)

Waste: Apoo, Urouge

 

[HerreraIsBack]

Nah Oda could have done a lot better with Worst Gen. Bege was great at Whole Cake despite being a shitty arc.

 

[Juanpiz]

It's a mistake because the group makes no sense, like whatsoever
At first it was rookies with bounties over 100mil, which is random but fine
And then randomly Blackbeard was slapped with the supernovas for no reason whatsoever despite not ever been to sabaody at that time, which only raises questions why someone like Marco was not slapped onto the group as well.

Dumb group with dumb concept

It kinda made sense
It wasnt about ages but they got Fame at similar time

 

[Juanpiz]

Nah Oda could have done a lot better with Worst Gen. Bege was great at Whole Cake despite being a shitty arc.

Music guy was Funny too

 

[BoaHancocksHusband]

Kidd has lots of fans in general. He ranked in top 20-25 iirc in popularity poll.

I think it depends. Hawkins , L drake , apoo were fails.

Urouge>>>> Lawkins Poo and L Drake

 

[Robsonbuster]

I think all of them could've been a great addition to the story with some tweaks. As they are, they represented well enough all possible paths an untrained strawhat crew could've taken and added some color to an otherwise bleak NW pirating world. I'd have killed some of them

Great additions: BB, Capone, Hawkins, Killer (unless he is alive)

Good additions: Bonney, Drake, Law (he should have died on Dressrosa), Kidd (unless he isn't dead)

Waste: Apoo, Urouge

What's great about Hawkins? Biggest waste of them all I feel like, absolute joke in wano. Is it because he died? Because knowing Oda, you might be in for a rude awakening lol

 

[Juanpiz]

What's great about Hawkins? Biggest waste of them all I feel like, absolute joke in wano. Is it because he died? Because knowing Oda, you might be in for a rude awakening lol

Design
Calm,Planning personality

 

[Brouhaha]

It's good addition overall. They are inserted here and there throughout the whole story post timeskip

 

[Rednick]

Looking back, only few were relevant.

Law is great, with significant fanbase in Japan
Kidd is....well he has 5 fans in this forum
Bonney only shows relevancy after Wano, but since she's linked with Vegapunk and Kuma she might have some supporting roles in the future
Meanwhile.....does Oda still remember Urouge?

What do u think?

Well leaving teach aside(for obvious reasons)I dont think it was a mistake but i definitely believe they should be fewer. Bege, hawkins and apoo were a mistake for sure. I mean not only they are weak but even their character is boring as hell. Killer is nice, shouldnt be a supernova though. I like his design and fighting style but just by his name you understand how much oda cares about him. Bonney is ok , urouge will play some role in the future and kid and law have been quite relevant so they all pass. Drake is the leader of sword and has much room for improvement so he pass as well.
So yes, they should be 3 less and killer should just be kid's vice captain and not a supernova.
Problem with the "supernovas were created they very last moment" info, is that we dont know in what extent is this true. Like maybe some of them would exist anyway, just not as part of the supernovas. But the notion that 9 different pirate crews arrived at the same time at the same place is so improbable that its basically just poor writing for me.
In the end, doent matter, the only major characters in the final saga will be luffy, teach, zoro, shanks, imu, dragon and maybe loki. All the others will inevitably receive the worgen treatment.