General & Others What if to overcome his G5 time-limit Luffy creates food?

#1
Since Luffy’s fruit is based on imagination will be be able to create food and eat it when his time-limit is approaching? Or better yet just imagine he doesn’t have the stamina issue?
 
#8
Since Luffy’s fruit is based on imagination will be be able to create food and eat it when his time-limit is approaching? Or better yet just imagine he doesn’t have the stamina issue?
It would violate the internal logic of devil fruits and powers in general (even the Nika Nika no Mi). Luffy can create, but what he uses is already "part" of him. The energy that he needs is not. Creating his own food would equate to have an unlimited supply of energy. That will most probably never happen. This would make him more or less invincible.

Also, most of Luffy's limits are most probably created by his own psyche and personnality so Luffy would never allow himself to do that. He could prevent himself from going old maybe, perhaps even go beyond Gear 5 but I don't think he would allow himself to just be more or less invincible. That's against how he sees himself.
 
#9
It would violate the internal logic of devil fruits and powers in general (even the Nika Nika no Mi). Luffy can create, but what he uses is already "part" of him. The energy that he needs is not. Creating his own food would equate to have an unlimited supply of energy. That will most probably never happen. This would make him more or less invincible.

Also, most of Luffy's limits are most probably created by his own psyche and personnality so Luffy would never allow himself to do that. He could prevent himself from going old maybe, perhaps even go beyond Gear 5 but I don't think he would allow himself to just be more or less invincible. That's against how he sees himself.
I mean are the goggles part of him?
 
#10
I mean are the goggles part of him?
Yup. It's part of what he is and think he can do. It's part of his capacity.

Remember this, energy can only be transformed, not created. Gear 5 uses a form of internal power to create its own assets, but it can't magically create more energy than what it already has in store. It would violate the logic of power and energy conservation all together.

I'm not saying that it "can't" happen. We are in One Piece after all.. but this would be a story-ending power. It's unlimited energy.
 
#11
It would violate the internal logic of devil fruits and powers in general (even the Nika Nika no Mi). Luffy can create, but what he uses is already "part" of him. The energy that he needs is not. Creating his own food would equate to have an unlimited supply of energy. That will most probably never happen. This would make him more or less invincible.

Also, most of Luffy's limits are most probably created by his own psyche and personnality so Luffy would never allow himself to do that. He could prevent himself from going old maybe, perhaps even go beyond Gear 5 but I don't think he would allow himself to just be more or less invincible. That's against how he sees himself.
at this point I think "nika" grabbing stuff from his hair might be the same thing as what Imu is doing summoning weapons from inside his abyss/black fire though, which could make it work in weird unexpected ways
 
#12
at this point I think "nika" grabbing stuff from his hair might be the same thing as what Imu is doing summoning weapons from inside his abyss/black fire though, which could make it work in weird unexpected ways
Completely yeah. Imu's and Luffy's power are two sides of the same coin IMO

Their energy storage has a limit, but as long as they have some (and their reserve are HUGE), it can be converted into anything they want until their "stock" is depleted
 
#14
Oda should remove this fake drawback on Luffy. I habe not seen any other character have this idiotic limiter. Why is the food issue even relevant? Instead, make him temporarily unable to use Gear 5 while still capable of fighting in his base form. It’s ridiculous to see his friends in danger while he’s busy stuffing himself with food.
The drawback is mainly because Oda thinks it's funny to draw Luffy as an old starving man, which isn't at all, except maybe for 3 years old children.
 
#15
I’d almost guarantee that the Nika fruit has the same limiter as Killingham’s fruit for something like this

He may be able to replicate the taste of food but it probably doesn’t actually have any nutritional value
 
#16
Luffy is like the ancient weapon used by Imu, he cannot fight in a long duration without eternal supply of food.

What is energy?
There used to have two sources of energy, fire and electricity. That is what people commonly use to power up any kind of constructs.

Oddly, We didn't know how Franky can use beverages to power himself.

But now Lilith introduced the ODC (Omni-Drain Converter) which can converts any source of energy into a different energy. She converts the energy into beverages. I think to myself, this is complete nonsense. I think a little more and realize human's intestines can absorbs the minerals inside the food and converts them into nutrient molecules. So the foods or beverages are technically energy sources for any living being. Since Lilith demonstrate ODC can converts energy into beverages, that means there is a way to converts them into food too. So Luffy can just swallow "The Sun" in the mural and the ODC to have an eternal food source.

Suddenly I think of something, what if the One Piece is an eternal food machine, it's useless for everyone but not for Nika. That will be very ridiculous.
 
#17
Oda should remove this fake drawback on Luffy. I habe not seen any other character have this idiotic limiter. Why is the food issue even relevant? Instead, make him temporarily unable to use Gear 5 while still capable of fighting in his base form. It’s ridiculous to see his friends in danger while he’s busy stuffing himself with food.
They don't turn old but didn't Law and Kidd both get really exhausted from using awakened moves and treated them as make or break gambits? I seem to remember puncture wille taking everything out of Law
 
#20
Imo Luffy’s current g5 is like a semi awakening since the df awakened itself to save luffy. He looks like the moon god instead of the sun god. Once he completely masters g5 which imo is fully awakening and becoming the sun God he will have no time limit or at the very least g5 will last significantly longer. I don't think oda will just make luffy create food and eat it since he hasn't had g5 do it yet when that would be something luffy would have already tried if it worked. I mean luffy would basically never leave g5 if he could create food and just eat it.
 
Top