2nd World One Piece Character Popularity Poll announced!!

[Sir Yasheen]

Oda also tired to give him the "I love my nakama" play with Jack and King to make him more likeable.


Idk, it just didn't work.

The scabbards fight ruined Kaidos character. If that didn’t exist he’d probably be much more popular

 

[Paragorn]

Nostalgia would be like if Mihawk or Arlong were huge. Crocodile is just odas most successful male warlord. The fact that his popularity can rival the power of simps wanting to be stepped on by boa is insane.

Rob Gucci was insane too

 

[Veku]

Don't think its nostalgia necessarily, like croco and buggy dynamic is what carries those CG interactions, even when he come "rescue" him in the flashback

Way more entertaining than cutting back to baldmingo who goes "FUFUFU GONNA BE REALLY FLOODED DOWN HERE IF YOU CATCH MY MEANING."

Sure I do agree, that's more entertaining and intresting than a panel or two every 200 chapters, but even then, Doffy is still top 25...

However, Croco was the first real villain in the first massive saga and good written on top of that, dude basically set the stakes for whatever came after, so imo nostalgia still plays a role.

 

[K!NG HARA$H!MA]

The scabbards fight ruined Kaidos character. If that didn’t exist he’d probably be much more popular

I don't really remember. What made Kaido lost his aura points against Scabbard?


Until his intro in 795 and one shotting Luffy he was doing pretty good in normies world

 

[Paragorn]

 

[K!NG HARA$H!MA]

This guy is getting carried only by his sexual appeal. No joks

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

I wonder how much the last 2/3 chapters affected Loki & Imu or if we haven’t seen that reflected in the polls yet

 

[Veku]

I wonder how much the last 2/3 chapters affected Loki & Imu or if we haven’t seen that reflected in the polls yet

Wouldn't be surprised if Imu makes it into the top 25 before the poll closes and Loki might crack the top 15

 

[kekaro]

I'm curious....how does everyone's favorite characters compare to the top 100 list?

1) Blackbeard #50
2) Sengoku N/A
3) Kizaru #44
4) Fujitora #87
5) Queen N/A
6) Jinbe #30
7) Don Chinjao N/A
8) Garp #38
9) Kuzan #40
10) Whitebeard # 35
11) Lucci #19
12) Brooke #20
13) Doflamingo #24
14) Crocodile #15
15) Jesus Burgess N/A
16) Akainu # 47
17) Smoker # 34
18) Super Sommers N/A
19) Hina N/A
20) Franky #26

1- Sanji #3
2 - Crocodile # 15
3 - Kuzan # 40
4 - Noland # N/A
5 - Kizaru # 44
6 - Enel # 46
7 - Law # 5
8 - Blackbeard #50
9 - Vivi # 32
10 - Wyper # N/A
11 - Kuma # 22
12 - Smoker # 34
13 - Whitebeard # 35
14 - Garp # 38
15 - Lucci # 19
16 - Harald N/A
17 - Loki # 21
18 - Bentham # 33
19 - Super Sommers # N/A
20 - Kinemon # N/A

 

[Paragorn]

No amount of slander is taking this guy from top 25

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

I still never understand why normies didn't rate Kaido that much.

He's strong, strongest title, got cool dragon fruit and decent design.


These alone are more than enough to win over normies



What went wrong?

That's actually crazy Kaido got all these things yet he gets mogged by pre-timeskip villains like Enel who hasn't appeared in over twenty years

 

[Sir Yasheen]

I don't really remember. What made Kaido lost his aura points against Scabbard?


Until his intro in 795 and one shotting Luffy he was doing pretty good in normies world

The fact that he jobbed to Fodders for like 6 chapters then started jerking off oden. Dudes character was dead at that point

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Rob Gucci was insane too

Dude was aura farming in DR and reverie but he was incredibly solid in egghead. Not shocked he made it this high

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

The fact that he jobbed to Fodders for like 6 chapters then started jerking off oden. Dudes character was dead at that point

For me his character was ruined when Oden clapped him, won because of a hostage and didn't give Oden the chance to fight him in a 1 vs 1 without intervention.
He coul be the strongest of the current gen he'd still be fraud to me after this.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

For me his character was ruined when Oden clapped him, won because of a hostage and didn't give Oden the chance to fight him in a 1 vs 1 without intervention.
He coul be the strongest of the current gen he'd still be fraud to me after this.

True. By the time Luffy got to Kaido his aura was already completely gone

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

True. By the time Luffy got to Kaido his aura was already completely gone

To this day I still don't understand why Kaido couldn't simply have defeated Oden because he was simply stronger?
Like if you're going to introduce your villain as the strongest in 1 vs 1 in his freaking introduction chapter, wouldn't it make sense to have his only recorded 1 vs 1 against a top tier to have been a fair win?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

To this day I still don't understand why Kaido couldn't simply have defeated Oden because he was simply stronger?
Like if you're going hype your villain as the strongest in 1 vs 1 in his freaking introduction, wouldn't it make sense to have his only recorded 1 vs 1 against a top tier to have been a fair win?

Cause oda wanted oden to be stronger to show the old gen shit on the current gen

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

Cause oda wanted oden to be stronger to show the old gen shit on the current gen

Well this came as the expense of the portrayal of the villain of the biggest arc in the series, which is not good writing. And we can see that just looking at Kaido ranking

 

[Bogard]

Cavendish at 37 despite only appearing in a single arc

 

[Peppercore]

insane that mihawk cant even make it to the top 30. blocked by jinbei...truly the crew's full guy.