Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

[Donquixote Shivercalero]

This guy was Toriyama’s main editor and basically shaped nearly all of the most memorable moments in DB

@Logiko @ZenZu @Kurozumi Wiwi @TheAncientCenturion

 

[Donquixote Shivercalero]

Tbf it seems like this guy doesn’t like anything at all, honestly.

 

[Rivaille]

It is pretty obvious that there is a lack of editorial direction in the last few years (I would said since WCI). As genius as Oda can be, he still need people to say no and to question his plans.
Iirc he himself complained about the fact that most people don’t share their real opinion to him.

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Tbf it seems like this guy doesn’t like anything at all, honestly.

Well, I don't know Blue Lock or Touch but from what I see dude is spitting facts

 

[Logiko]

Tbf it seems like this guy doesn’t like anything at all, honestly.

In other words, the guy doesn't understand sh*t. It happens in every industry. I think he would actually love this forum

 

[kekaro]

I am a big Fan of elbaf and the jjk Editor
He knows what people want

 

[Dettles]

No the his Editor hates everything new. He even said that Naruto copied too much from DB.

 

[ShinichiMugi]

I strongly disagree. He acts like a boomer.

Modern manga readers are more adult than the past,and likes the more complexity of the One Piece story,compared to Dragon Ball

 

[Donquixote Shivercalero]

No the his Editor hates everything new. He even said that Naruto copied too much from DB.

He said Naruto is shit after pain

 

[Sentinel]

Tbf it seems like this guy doesn’t like anything at all, honestly.

See? Even the biggest haters can't hate on Pain. The greatest anime antagonist.

 

[Logiko]

I strongly disagree. He acts like a boomer.

Modern manga readers are more adult than the past,and likes the more complexity of the One Piece story,compared to Dragon Ball

Sounds like someone who wanted to craft a manga but is bitter that he never managed to do it.

 

[Shiroyru]

Tbf it seems like this guy doesn’t like anything at all, honestly.

Editors should be highly critical by default.

Most of OP’s current problems stem from Oda’s editors being pathetic yes men

 

[Logiko]

Editors should be highly critical by default.

Most of OP’s current problems stem from Oda’s editors being pathetic yes men

No. Most of One Piece's current problems are fans inventions.

 

[Shiroyru]

Sounds like someone who wanted to craft a manga but is bitter that he never managed to do it.

Oda’s editors are such yes men that they refuse to point out blatant plot holes, bro. How is that healthy for the manga?

 

[Logiko]

Oda’s editors are such yes men that they refuse to point out blatant plot holes, bro. How is that healthy for the manga?

Give me 3 plot hole in the last two arcs please.

 

[Donquixote Shivercalero]

Give me 3 plot hole in the last two arcs please.

Fisher Tiger retcon

 

[Shiroyru]

Give me 3 plot hole in the last two arcs please.

1. The Domi Reversi’d Davy clan members being perma killed when they should have just reverted to normal after Xebec killed them
2. Imu not manifesting through any of the Gorosei on Egghead when GV proved he can do that with no problems
3. Holy Knight’s regen. We straight up saw HKs regrowing lost limbs, but now they need to be reattached for some reason. Also Gaban not knowing about their metal hearts despite the Roger Pirates giving the HKs belt to ass many times

 

[Logiko]

Fisher Tiger retcon

1. Not a retcon
2. Not a plothole

Next

 

[kekaro]

no btw. about naruto every other manga being shit

This guys sounds like the embodiment of this meme

 

[Johnny B. Decent]

1. The Domi Reversi’d Davy clan members being perma killed when they should have just reverted to normal after Xebec killed them
2. Imu not manifesting through any of the Gorosei on Egghead when GV proved he can do that with no problems
3. Holy Knight’s regen. We straight up saw HKs regrowing lost limbs, but now they need to be reattached for some reason. Also Gaban not knowing about their metal hearts despite the Roger Pirates giving the HKs belt to ass many times

1. Xebec wasn't holding back and they were normal people compared to the giants. In RPG terms, it's like the spell False Life, it's a health boost atop of what you have.

2. Because that's simple storytelling of not going overboard. Because he did it again this arc and it's not wise to to the same trick in two arcs, back to back.

3. Their regeneration isn't exactly like a Logia. Like Killingham was separated away from his limbs. And for the time being, we should only assume Super Sommers has that heart.

Well, that wasn't too hard.