Questions & Mysteries Do you agree with Dragon Ball Editor, Torishima’s criticism of modern One Piece

#62
I don’t feel like responding to this entire wall of text right now, but most of your arguments here are just “it’s bad writing instead of an outright plot hole”

How does that make things better for Oda?
Read better, in everycase, everything is explainable. Which means that in every cases, it's not Oda who is writing badly, but you guyz who are reading backward. A plot hole is an unexplanable destruction of the lore. As long as an element can be explained it is at worst "unexplained", not a plot hole.

Show me something that is breaking the LOGIC of the story in an unexplainable way
 
#69
You know,you may be right. People keep liking dumb stuff. But,people also like the mysteries of One Piece,that Torishima would not like because for him stories must be kept simple and kids-friendly,with a storyline lasting 6 chapters max. But in this way One Piece would not be the same thing
Actually Oda managed to do both. He has both a simple story that anyone can understand and also one more complex where die-hard fans can spend their time theorizing it. If it was just complex it wouldn't be as great.

For example Attack on Titan, Overload. Those are overly complex ones. They are great but not as great as One Piece that is much simple.
 
#72
How could anyone try to legitimately defend the Domi Reversi retcon?
How could you think “Xebec was just a moron that actually wanted to kill his family” is somehow a better outcome?
None of this is true mate and as I said. Not a retcon. Damaged done before the domi reversi are not magically healed.

These people were already dead.
 
#73
It’s obvious Garling was killing off all the Davy clan members, it’s how he got the God Valley high score.

but yeah everything relating to Imu’s powers is/has been retconned. Regen going from Edo Tensei levels to temu logia
Garling was killing off Davies in the middle of his fight with Xebec? How much harder could he have pushed Xebec if he wasn’t distracted by finishing off the Davies?
 
#75
Headcanon. There’s no evidence that Imu can Domi Reversi corpses, come on now.
Again, you need to understand that a plothole is only a plothole if it breaks the logic of the story in an unexplainable way.

The answer here is not only very simple, but can also be explained through the logic of the story, and by the logic I mean "the function of control". You guys needs to stop trying to find ways to diss on the story and using fallacious knowledge of the craft to do it. Unless you want to waste time dealing with people like me at every turn.

If you really can't stand One Piece anymore, either make a pause or stop reading it. You are only hurting yourself here.
 
#77
Again, you need to understand that a plothole is only a plothole if it breaks the logic of the story in an unexplainable way.

The answer here is not only very simple, but can also be explained through the logic of the story, and by the logic I mean "the function of control". You guys needs to stop trying to find ways to diss on the story and using fallacious knowledge of the craft to do it. Unless you want to waste time dealing with people like me at every turn.

If you really can't stand One Piece anymore, either make a pause or stop reading it. You are only hurting yourself here.
You still haven’t provided any evidence that Domi Reversi can be used on corpses.
 
Top