Controversial which was worse? Luffy being Joyboy or Naruto being the Reincarnation or the Six Sage, Son of the 4th Hokage and Child of Prophecy?

[Dettles]

Which was worse Luffy having the Nika-Nika fruit or Naruto being the Son of the 4th Hokage, Child of Prophecy, and Reaincarnation of the Six Sage?

 

[Album]

Luffy being the eater of nika fruit isn’t bad at all it damages nothing about luffys character and was hinted at for years luffy awakened his df due to his own hard work and personality

 

[Loki D. Terror]

Naruto by far imo. The six paths power felt unearned. Reincarnation thing was BS. Luffy's thing is also not good.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Naruto got no added powers from being a reincarnate though. The Sage of Six Paths gave him & Sasuke his powers to take down Madara and undo Infinite Tsukuyomi.

Being a reincarnate only explained his crush on Sasuke.

 

[soupongo]

Luffy eating the Nika fruit opens up the possibility that he was entitled to the One Piece from chapter 1.....which is kind of annoying? And it opens up a lot of weird questions about why the Nika awakening isn't even hinted for 1000+ chapters.

Naruto being the Asura reincarnation is still probably worse, since it really does come up last minute, and imo the connection with the Uzumaki to Asura through the Senju is like, hilariously forced lol. Also, I think explicit reincarnation when introduced so late is a bit much...

 

[kekaro]

Naruto being Minatos son ruined way more characters than Goofy being joyboy/having nika fruit
no amount "WG is retarded" will cope with that

Not even getting into the last minute higaromo stuff

 

[soupongo]

Naruto being Minatos son ruined way more characters than Goofy being joyboy/having nika fruit

 

[kekaro]

 

[Juanpiz]

Luffy eating the Nika fruit opens up the possibility that he was entitled to the One Piece from chapter 1.....which is kind of annoying? And it opens up a lot of weird questions about why the Nika awakening isn't even hinted for 1000+ chapters.

Naruto being the Asura reincarnation is still probably worse, since it really does come up last minute, and imo the connection with the Uzumaki to Asura through the Senju is like, hilariously forced lol. Also, I think explicit reincarnation when introduced so late is a bit much...

Always has been

 

[Veku]

Oda should've taken a lesson from Akira instead of copy pasting Kishimoto's homework

 

[soupongo]

Kekaro, you tard, Nardo being related to Minato is one of the most obvious "reveals" in fictional history

 

[kekaro]

Kekaro, you tard, Nardo being related to Minato is one of the most obvious "reveals" in fictional history

Thats not what i meant you dumb fatty, im talking inuniverse
God discount yapplier

 

[soupongo]

Thats not what i meant you dumb fatty, im talking inuniverse
God discount yapplier

It's not worse in universe than Luffy eating the Nika fruit, you retard

 

[Kishido]

Both are shit. But that's JP. Nika stuff is at least more fun.

 

[kekaro]

It's not worse in universe than Luffy eating the Nika fruit, you retard

Opinions such as this are why you are fat bum btw.

 

[Blax Blah]

Emeth said Luffy isn't Joyboy

 

[soupongo]

Opinions such as this are why you are fat bum btw.

No arguments?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Naruto and its not close.

 

[kekaro]

No arguments?

I brought as many arguments as you have

 

[soupongo]

I brought as many arguments as you have

I didn't make a claim lmao, all I can really say is that Nardo being related to Minato creates justification for him having the 9 tails sealed in him, and is heavily implied from the very start of the story.