Super Role Madness Game Of Thrones: A Song Of Ice and Fire

[The Orca]

@Flower

What do you see on Dio, cause I think I might agree with that the most

 

[Polar Bear]

One last chuckle - the last day of the big bad bear.

PolarBear is scum because:

1. He is really nice.
Dude just lost a game with perfect reads.
Last time this happened, he joined the next game annoyed.
He wanted to get heard.
He wanted people to know that they should listen to him.

None of this is happening this game.
He is all "shit happens", "good vibes win".
There is no wim to him, no want to change the game.
No confrontation. No life.

He is an empty shell of the cuddly bear we know and begrudgingly accept.

2. Very limited catch-up.
During his catch-up posting, he has no actual deep questions. Some lighthearted banter and a lore question.
Basically no solving. He loves to have fun with friends, but there are normally some questions in between.


3. No list.
PB normally throws out a reads list unprompted within the first 24 hours. Normally during his first catch-up.
Not just 5 reads. No, a full list on every player and it normally includes ~5 people in the deep red.


4. Not a single scumread.
This dude has not given a single scumread. 4 light townreads here and there, but that is it.

Last game he had a list of 4 scumreads after ~15 hours of playtime.
And those changed and evolved. You could see his brain work, and his reads change based on the things he read.

And funnily enough this goes both ways. Not a single person has been vocal about a scumread on pb despite this clear change.


None of this in any way is how town Polar bear has played in any of the last 4 games I have played with him.
He was town in all of them.


And somehow he is still a solid town (not just leaning town or whatever) for

Lord Melchor
Cal
Flower

Vote: Polar Bear

Hmm, love the detail, but I think you are mixing up WG game play vs OLF. In OLF I can go harder and be more solving bc of the style of games and type of games, its why I like them so much more (despite some of the players there). In big role madness games like on WG, I get a bit lost in the sauce bc of size and so many moving parts. Like trying to solve 25+ names on d1 is to daunting of a task for me lol.

(There might be another reason I want to lay a little lower here as well, you'll have to wait to see if that's the case 🤫)

 

[Flower]

Read my fucking post and make up your mind.

Tell me I am wrong or right for whatever reason.

Sheeping Cal is not enough here.

Personally? I think his read on me is enough for a Town read. As scum he tends to just put me as Town and let’s it go.
Then there comes Cal‘s read which is obligatory if he’s scum and he has a good handle on Polar if he’s Town, too.
I think you’re off on him and would appreciate some support with my Dio wagon ty.

 

[Charlie]

Honestly unless you two are Masons I think Cata is just scum.

Is it only based on jan thing? Or is there something else? Doesn't most of the thread have jan as town anyway? Idk, this one question in particular doesn't sound weird at all to me. Unless she wasn't town reading him earlier

 

[Flower]

@Flower

What do you see on Dio, cause I think I might agree with that the most

That player is obviously familiar with this set of players and obviously an OLFer in disguise judging by the /vote format they used and they hardcore struggle to play this game. Feels like they’re afraid to contribute.

 

[Polar Bear]

:doge:

Lol, I'm always here between 11 and 1 my time, I think he was getting a little antsy

 

[Jan]

Hmm, love the detail, but I think you are mixing up WG game play vs OLF. In OLF I can go harder and be more solving bc of the style of games and type of games, its why I like them so much more (despite some of the players there). In big role madness games like on WG, I get a bit lost in the sauce bc of size and so many moving parts. Like trying to solve 25+ names on d1 is to daunting of a task for me lol.

(There might be another reason I want to lay a little lower here as well, you'll have to wait to see if that's the case 🤫)

I checked the wg games too.
Your play is still vastly different from your wg games I have seen.

 

[AL sama]

Then vote me? If your unhappy and people really want a day 1 mislynch then go for it.

I m already voting the person I suspect the mot

mis-lynch is normal for day 1

 

[Jan]

Personally? I think his read on me is enough for a Town read. As scum he tends to just put me as Town and let’s it go.
Then there comes Cal‘s read which is obligatory if he’s scum and he has a good handle on Polar if he’s Town, too.
I think you’re off on him and would appreciate some support with my Dio wagon ty.

With all my love not like this.

Why do you think cals read would be spew and not w/w?

Why do you not care about solving this.
This reminds me of the time I was 3p and pushing your partners and you didn't klnow how toreact and ragedquit 4 minutes later to not fully out yourself.

 

[Polar Bear]

I checked the wg games too.
Your play is still vastly different from your wg games I have seen.

I don't think so, could have been work last night, you should check out my scum games. If you do, you can't possibly maintain that. It has me a little curious here.

 

[Flower]

With all my love not like this.

Why do you think cals read would be spew and not w/w?

Why do you not care about solving this.
This reminds me of the time I was 3p and pushing your partners and you didn't klnow how toreact and ragedquit 4 minutes later to not fully out yourself.

Because I can’t change how I fucking feel.

 

[Jan]

I don't think so, could have been work last night, you should check out my scum games. If you do, you can't possibly maintain that. It has me a little curious here.

Never seen you as scum. You have only been town in the last 6 months.

And I mostly trust my reads on games I can judge. If oyu want to present a couple of scumgames I can give them a skim.

Who are your scumreads right now?
Why have you not given a single scumread?

 

[AL sama]

Okay now before I eat some dinner

I would pick Zemmi, but not unless she gets back here or not.

Would add Jag but he does not want to and I respect that.

Vote small council
The Orca
Yoho
Sakazouki
Al Sama
Tayenne


Are my votes right now.

I wish I was more confident on the bottom 2 tbh. But my heart says yes.

I like that you aren't confident about me

 

[Polar Bear]

Looks like those last 10 pages will have to be skimmed later. Playing live for now

 

[Jan]

I like that you aren't confident about me

I am not confident, but I liked your response when I was pressing you a bit.

Plus, I had to add someone with Zemmi being mia. :D

 

[Jan]

If you know PB tell me why he is town.

Tell me where my read is wrong.

Tell me.

Or join me.

 

[Flower]

And honestly? Getting shit from everyone this game so far isn’t getting me in a really good mood to solve.

 

[Polar Bear]

Never seen you as scum. You have only been town in the last 6 months.

And I mostly trust my reads on games I can judge. If oyu want to present a couple of scumgames I can give them a skim.

Who are your scumreads right now?
Why have you not given a single scumread?

I've barely posted. Can't post scum reads when I'm not here.

Probably should ask @Flower which games I've been scum here, here memory is pretty spot on with that. I'll try and find a few when I have time if she can't tell you a few off the top of her head lol

My reads are coming. Updating based on my limited catchup

 

[Polar Bear]

If you know PB tell me why he is town.

Tell me where my read is wrong.

Tell me.

Or join me.

Oh I can tell you easily, but I'm curious what others here will say

 

[Jan]

Oh I can tell you easily, but I'm curious what others here will say

Oh yeah. If I am wrong, forcing ppl to commit is good for both of us.

I don't think I am.