Super Role Madness Game Of Thrones: A Song Of Ice and Fire
- Thread starter Fujishiro
- Start date
- Tags reloaded is fooken scum
@Fujishiro we need some clarification on dio please
Some of my early take-aways :
Flower - I think there was some sub-optimal role in your opinion. Floating that you had immunity to a powerful scum role wasn't ideal play in my books because it just tells them not to waste those abilities on you. I do believe in your claim however and that you are town.
Zemmi - The drama that happened earlier in the thread seemed genuine at least. It seemed like a blow-up between two frustrated towns who weren't seeing eye-to-eye. I wouldn't think a scum Zemmi would react so strongly to being threatened by town, but I've only played one game with her where she was town. Seems to be interested in working towards the solve.
Yoho - Nothing strong here, but his reads aren't aligned with my own and I haven't liked all of his pushes. Could be nothing, but I'm skeptical of him.
Polar Bear - Jan's made a strong case on him, I didn't have any strong thoughts on him prior to Jan's push, but he's worth looking into. I at least feel better that if he's scum than Jan becomes a much stronger town read.
Mr. Reloaded - I don't like that he's come with zero substance after nearly 100 pages of discussion. Only thing I'll credit him on is that I feel a mafia would do a bit more effort into pretending to look productive while he was just open and honest about having zero reads, but that oblivious style play can only carry them so far before the blade turns on them.
Charlie - It seems they also just randomly dumped their role sheet in the thread with no pressure, and it's a bizarre one. Sounds like an overly specific role, but not one that I feel the need to worry about.
Dio - I don't like anything about their performance really. The troll vote at the start, dipping from the thread, coming back with a list of reads that had zero reasoning attached, and then dipping out again. I don't think it's a bad idea to axe them, but I feel we can gleam more information out of other lynches.
Worst - I like what I've seen from Worst so far because his opinions align well with my own.
Tayenne - I haven't liked Tayenne's play so far, and he's said off-putting things like how he's giving you the benefit of the doubt and easing up on you because you claimed an important character instead of a side-character. Which seems like nonsense, I don't think Fuji is so inexperienced as a host that he wouldn't give scum any prominent characters in their fake claims.
Jan - Jan looks dedicated to the solve, been saying the right things, and has been productive pursuing leads. The only thing that gives me slight pause is that he is playing a more aggressive game than last time I played with him. Our last game together he was town and I believed they were being too hands off on pursuing their reads, but this game they are much more active in pushing for their top suspect. Usually I perceive that as a positive, I have them town lean, but I am noting the difference.
Lord Melkor - My one game with Melkor he was the independent, outed himself early, and when approached with scrutiny he became more flustered and avoidant. Behavior isn't identical here, but it's a similar pattern of him turtling up and shying away from the confrontation, so I don't think he looks great. The role he claimed seemed NAI and didn't sound like one that town would sorely miss either.
Yo Tan Wa - I don't like them. They've posted rubbish so far.
Flower - I think there was some sub-optimal role in your opinion. Floating that you had immunity to a powerful scum role wasn't ideal play in my books because it just tells them not to waste those abilities on you. I do believe in your claim however and that you are town.
Zemmi - The drama that happened earlier in the thread seemed genuine at least. It seemed like a blow-up between two frustrated towns who weren't seeing eye-to-eye. I wouldn't think a scum Zemmi would react so strongly to being threatened by town, but I've only played one game with her where she was town. Seems to be interested in working towards the solve.
Yoho - Nothing strong here, but his reads aren't aligned with my own and I haven't liked all of his pushes. Could be nothing, but I'm skeptical of him.
Polar Bear - Jan's made a strong case on him, I didn't have any strong thoughts on him prior to Jan's push, but he's worth looking into. I at least feel better that if he's scum than Jan becomes a much stronger town read.
Mr. Reloaded - I don't like that he's come with zero substance after nearly 100 pages of discussion. Only thing I'll credit him on is that I feel a mafia would do a bit more effort into pretending to look productive while he was just open and honest about having zero reads, but that oblivious style play can only carry them so far before the blade turns on them.
Charlie - It seems they also just randomly dumped their role sheet in the thread with no pressure, and it's a bizarre one. Sounds like an overly specific role, but not one that I feel the need to worry about.
Dio - I don't like anything about their performance really. The troll vote at the start, dipping from the thread, coming back with a list of reads that had zero reasoning attached, and then dipping out again. I don't think it's a bad idea to axe them, but I feel we can gleam more information out of other lynches.
Worst - I like what I've seen from Worst so far because his opinions align well with my own.
Tayenne - I haven't liked Tayenne's play so far, and he's said off-putting things like how he's giving you the benefit of the doubt and easing up on you because you claimed an important character instead of a side-character. Which seems like nonsense, I don't think Fuji is so inexperienced as a host that he wouldn't give scum any prominent characters in their fake claims.
Jan - Jan looks dedicated to the solve, been saying the right things, and has been productive pursuing leads. The only thing that gives me slight pause is that he is playing a more aggressive game than last time I played with him. Our last game together he was town and I believed they were being too hands off on pursuing their reads, but this game they are much more active in pushing for their top suspect. Usually I perceive that as a positive, I have them town lean, but I am noting the difference.
Lord Melkor - My one game with Melkor he was the independent, outed himself early, and when approached with scrutiny he became more flustered and avoidant. Behavior isn't identical here, but it's a similar pattern of him turtling up and shying away from the confrontation, so I don't think he looks great. The role he claimed seemed NAI and didn't sound like one that town would sorely miss either.
Yo Tan Wa - I don't like them. They've posted rubbish so far.
I am not familar at all with the mechanic of fake claims tbh, like never played with that. Usually I just know that everyone gets a role and ye then mafia usually thinks themselves of some role they can fake claim instead of their real one. How does it actually work with Fuji? Does he gives mafia 2 roles basically a real one and the fake claim one?
Vote Count 7 Of Day 1
Dio: 4
LM: 4
Polar Bear/Reloaded/Alwaysmind/Sakazouki/Flower/Jan/Worst: 1
--------
Dio: Zemmi > Alwaysmind > Melkor
Al: Reloaded > Flower
Saka: Reloaded > Dio
Flower: Melkor > Michelle >Dio > Bitter > Dio > Dio > Polar Bear> LM
LM: Orca > Dio
Reloaded: Yoho> Yoho> Dio
Tayenne: Polar Bear > Sakazouki > Polar Bear
Jan: Melkor > Polar Bear > LM
Yoho: Reloaded
Michelle: Worst
Worst: Charlie> Tayenne> LM
Cal: Jan
Orca: Dio
Votes may not show their true value
Small Council Votes:
Zemmi: 9
Flower: 7
Worst: 5
Tayenne: 6
Jan: 6
Saka: 4
Al: 4
Orca: 3
Michelle: 3
Jaguar: 2
Polar: 2
Yoho: 2
Charlie/Cal/Melkor/Galaxy: 1
----------
Fower: Tayenne+ Jan+ Zemmi+ Flower+ Saka
Zemmi: Zemmi + Jan + Flower + Saka + Worst
Bitter: Jan > Zemmi
Jaguar: Jan> Zemmi > Worst
Cal: Cal + Zemmi + Flower
Saka: Worst + Tayenne + Saka + Zemmi + Al
Jan: Tayenne+ Jaguar> Orca+ Yoho + Saka+ Tayenne+ Al
Yoho: Jan> Zemmi + Worst + Jan + Polar + Jag
LM: Jaguar + Flower+ Zemmi+ Polar + Saka
Reloaded: Jaguar > Flower
Galaxy: Galaxy
York: Yoho + Orca + Worst + Flower
Orca: Orca
Worst: Worst
Tayenne: Flower+ Tayenne
Ginger: Yoho
Michelle: Tayenne
Al: Al+ Charlie+ Zemmi+ Michelle + Jan
Michelle: Tayenne+ Jan + Michelle + Zemmi + Al