Questions & Mysteries Which nerf is worse? WB, Garp, Luffy

[Erkan12]

Which nerf is worse?

Can Luffy heal from it with G5 or will he eat foods to heal it so will it nerf him less than WB or Garp?

 

[Heart pirate]

Luffy probably heals after eating, oda a moron like that. Between the other 2 WB. Mostly cause he’s already weakened by sickness, otherwise equal.

 

[CoC: Color of Clowns]

Which nerf is worse?

Can Luffy heal from it with G5 or will he eat foods to heal it so will it nerf him less than WB or Garp?

I think Newgate cause he was so old/had cancer. Garp still fought well after his stab, but I think Whitebeard's stab really hurt him going forward.

My only question is if Imu's Sword Void actually drains life force out of people, since it was draining the trees life force.

I'm still of the mindset the rubber tree resin theory has some weight to it.

If Void just... sucks life energy directly, there's a good chance Luffy goes OUT of Gear 5 next chapter immediately.

 

[Lanthins]

I'd say Whitebeard's is worse because the guy was already sick and on top of that old? Garp was just old and not sick and still destroyed prime Kuzan, and Luffy, well, Luffy got pierced by a sword with an abnormal ability, but Luffy's young and still, though considering it's a sword with an abnormal passive and Luffy's weak against cuts, it could even be WB >= Luffy > Garp.

 

[GeneralP123]

I'd say Whitebeard's is worse because the guy was already sick and on top of that old? Garp was just old and not sick and still destroyed prime Kuzan, and Luffy, well, Luffy got pierced by a sword with an abnormal ability, but Luffy's young and still, though considering it's a sword with an abnormal passive and Luffy's weak against cuts, it could even be WB >= Luffy > Garp.

I agree, Imu's stab is definitely the strongest attack here, but Luffy should bounce back without too many issues cuz he was stabbed while in his hax zoan form.

 

[Konstantis]

Which nerf is worse?

Can Luffy heal from it with G5 or will he eat foods to heal it so will it nerf him less than WB or Garp?

WDM by nerfed Luffy? He was eating like crazy and stated that he can beat right now anyone? He is buffed.

 

[Zoinks52]

WDM by nerfed Luffy? He was eating like crazy and stated that he can beat right now anyone? He is buffed.

I think he means Luffy after he got gutted like a fish by Imu.

Which is probably a decent nerf, having a big demon sword all up in your bits can't be very pleasant.

That said we can't really tell until next chapter given how Luffy has ridiculous recovery due to eating.

 

[Psychiatrist]

Whitebeard is worst. He was suffering from terminal illness cancer along with Heart disease.

Regarding Luffy he will probably recover next panel itself via his toon powers, eat through it, or get instant 50 percent JoyBoy power.

 

[kekaro]

That last one is not a nerf, thats getting hit in your 1vs1 fight

 

[Erkan12]

Lerkan mental nerf when reading OP.

Mentally ZKK damaged Loiroy get jealous again and crying about it:
"Whenever I make a good thread, ZKKfans get jealous and post out of topic things in it lmao"
https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/members/erkan12.69/#profile-post-119447

I think he means Luffy after he got gutted like a fish by Imu.

Which is probably a decent nerf, having a big demon sword all up in your bits can't be very pleasant.

That said we can't really tell until next chapter given how Luffy has ridiculous recovery due to eating.

WDM by nerfed Luffy? He was eating like crazy and stated that he can beat right now anyone? He is buffed.

Yes he answered.

 

[Erkan12]

Luffy probably heals after eating, oda a moron like that. Between the other 2 WB. Mostly cause he’s already weakened by sickness, otherwise equal.

If Luffy heals then it's not even close, then WB's and Garp's are worse.

Regarding Luffy he will probably recover next panel itself via his toon powers, eat through it, or get instant 50 percent JoyBoy power.

I doubt it will be that easy to recover but he should heal at some level for sure since there is no one who can fight Imu in the next chapters.

 

[Loki D. Terror]

WB > Garp obviously.

That last attack we don't know what happens next.

 

[mly90]

No bigger nerf than this

Out of the options you listed I would pick wb who was already on life support before even coming to marineford

 

[kurwa]

all of them are equally "nerfed"

same damage, just a stab

 

[Robin swan]

If luffy is still in g5 he'll probably just keep fighting. Luffy can heal the easiest while we had the best endurance. We went through a entire war after his stab so I wouldn't say he was perfect much if at all. Depending on how luffy bounces back he can either be second or last. Garp took a noticeable dive even though he was still a beast. Wb barely even acknowledged his stab. Luffy if he's still in g5 will probably treat it like wb did because g5 doesn't really reflect the damage luffy body is actually in at least up to this point. G5 basically always let's luffy fight as if he's fresh even if he's on deaths door.