Super Role Madness Game Of Thrones: A Song Of Ice and Fire

[Mr. Reloaded]

now I wish potato waited with his duel and did it with sakazouki instead

He should have duel'd Alwaysmind or something lol

 

[Flower]

pretty confident the lad is town

Okay but these reactions still suck ngl.

 

[Tayenne]

pretty confident the lad is town

I'm a girl btw lmao you keep saying I am a guy

 

[Charlie]

Leaning town:
LM
Michelle
Flower
Al
YTW
Potato
Orca
Reloaded

Not sure
Worst
Tayenne

Leaning scum:
Ginger
Galaxy
Jag
Bittersweet
Jan


Jan lied about not trying to roleblock LM if he says he visited him
Accidentally two people tried to roleblock LM last night. @Mr. Reloaded claimed he roleblocked LM, if Jan was town he would instantly jump reloaded and start a wagon, because he actually roleblocked LM too, but was redirected to another player which is Flower

Vote lynch Jan
Players:

1- @Flower
2- @Yoho
3- @Zemmi Replaced by @Sallucion
4- @Jaguark101
5- @York
6- @Polar Bear
7- @bittersweet
8- @Mr. Reloaded
9- @Alwaysmind
10- @Charlie
11- @Hayumi Replaced by @GalaxyLevelShanks
12- @Dio Replaced by @Orwellian
13- @The Orca
14- @Ratchet Replaced by @Crowned Witch
15- @EkkoLoJinx Replaced by @Worst
16- @gingerbread
17- @AL sama
18- @Michelle
19- @Tayenne
20- @Jan
21- @Lord Melkor
22- @Yo Tan Wa
23- @Elder Lee Hung Replaced by @Great Potato
24- @SakazOuki
25- @RippedCal

Can you elaborate? What's the claim here

 

[SakazOuki]

now I wish potato waited with his duel and did it with sakazouki instead

I thought forum had policy against 10 year olds joining?
Unless you're faking being this depressed townie, which would be funnier lowkey lol

 

[Worst]

I'm a girl btw lmao you keep saying I am a guy

I meant to say the ladY

 

[Lord Melkor]

pretty confident the lad is town

It is usually considered bastard to give scum alignment cop fake claim from the host, i think Fuji would be careful about it though i do not know entire setup.

 

[Worst]

Okay but these reactions still suck ngl.

Well i've been told WG's way of mafia is a lot different than other people so it makes sense that the young and inexperienced Tayenne is caught by all of these new emotions and doesn't know how to properly react like a lady

 

[Lord Melkor]

Vote Lynch Polar Bear

 

[Tayenne]

Okay add Tayenne to my scum pile for these reactions. Just looks like instigating.

the fact that you think it is me instigating and not sakazouki with how rude he is lmao

 

[Worst]

It is usually considered bastard to give scum alignment cop fake claim from the host, i think Fuji would be careful about it though i do not know entire setup.

Who says he has to use the fake claim the host gives him ? When i rolled scum once i had a fake claim and made another one that didn't had something to do with the one the host gave me.....tbh i got in a lot of troubles for that

 

[Flower]

Target two players at night and learn if they have compatible win conditions.​

[1-Shot] ​

Non refillable.​

Okay, Jan is actually just hard clear nvm. I thought Yoho‘s Parity Cop was multiple shots for some reason.

 

[Jan]

I checked your list while catching up, but have to doublecheck.

It was broadly fine.Will give it a moment to read into.

@Jan

So this was my last read list




Tayenne ---> town --> my initial scum read was based on the fact that i never played with the guy and i felt his posts were somewhat artificial and not actually providing information but as the game progressed i started to look at him with different eyes, and i think his effort is genuine and analysis are turning out to be helpful for town.
Charlie ---> town --> I'm familiar with Charlie's scum play this time he definetly rolled town as he is questioning things ( like my claim for example ) with more conviction while as scum he just tries to be as kawaii as possible and question but without coming back to stuff too much
Jan ---> town --> I say the strongest town read i have as he is providing proper analysis on all the players / questioning things and think it's the most balanced when it comes to game solving threadplay.
Flowa ---> town --> she's a bit all over the place but i think scum Flowa would be a lot more heated when accused of not being town, she also questions and monitor things properly
Potato guy ---> town --> not much activity but his few posts are full of good content like he's actually trying to game solve
Sakazouki ---> town lean --> he was town read in my first reads as he felt balanced between messing around and actually engaging with pople but i feel his activity and engagement kinda dropped a little bit we're only in d2 ofc so his activity might rise up again still looking good to me for now but will monitor
Cal ---> town --> his activity also dropped a little bit but his early interactions were definetly a strong indication of him being town, i don't think scum would go look for smoke and be super aggro in the thread very early ofc everyone has his playstyle but i like the way he approached things
GalaxyLevelShanks ---> town --> i admit this is mostly from previous game experience it was his first game and we were in the indie chat and this is is second game, but based on what i could observe behind the scenes he's definetly town as scum he would look much better as he would ask indications to his teammates before posting weird things ( referring to his posts where he said to lynch him first instead of flower )
Jag ---> town --> his scum play is mostly made of fluff and trying to give weak contribution mostly when pressured this time he's more actively trying to game solve and overall a nice threadplay here and there everything considering
Ginger ---> from town to town lean --> a bit stronger town feeling than Sakazouki he also dropped a bit in activity but his hearly posts are strong town oriented mindset trying to evaluate intent rather than just surface level actions

AL ---> indie --> there's no way this slot is town but it def looks town aligned, he has a mix of " i wanna contribute to help town but at the same time i ain't gonna bother too much " vibe

Zemmi ---> scum --> i said i was town leaning Zemmi but it was just a distraction this was my main scum read i would've pushed for her instead of LM but i wanted to catch her with the hands in the cookie jar
LM ---> absolute scoundrel --> as explained before i think his threadplay matches his previous scum ones where i have been about 90% right about every time, asks open ended questions that don't lead anywhere --> tries to avoid confrontation --> pops up with some weak excuse when situation demands i am confident this slot is cooked
Michelle ---> scum --> weak reasons to suspect me initially just dropped a vote and dipped out, kept going after me still with weak conviction, now says i've been the one responsible for Dio's lynch despite me tunneling LM most of the time and never even mentioning Dio once, asked for the posts where i have supposedly pushed for Dio's lynch and refuses to do so showing she also doesn't read my posts which is weird cuz i assume you wanna keep a lot of focus on your main scum read and wanna make it seem each time like i'm " changing narartive " when confronting which makes me wonder even more if she's reading my posts or not....
Polar ---> scum --> his healer claim seems convenient given all the poisons going around, seems fabricated and convenient since he was next in line in many people's read list he also voted for Dio's lynch right before voting was closed to the public and overall not liking the contents of his posts
bittersweet ---> scum lean --> he is decently active but i feel his posts are kinda neutral and don't seem to bring any particular value for town


CW ---> to monitor --> threadplay feels somewhat cautious need to wait for more interactions not saying it's bad or anything but need more
York ---> nullish --> tries to shot not necessarily a good reason to scum read his posts are pretty meh and lack any sort of content but i recall scum york more proactive, potentially could also be indie scum aligned but no clear indication now
AM ---> null --> this slot i haven't touched at all
YTW ---> null / townish lean --> scum YTW would put just a little more effort for this team but will need to see a little more
Orca ---> need to monitor more --> his posts aren't bad but i don't see anything that makes me town read him


I'm not sure if i'm missing someone but this are the notes i've been taking so far

I will do some colour marking in your post to make it easier to comprehend.

I agree with green reads.
I strongly disagree with orange.

Zemmi is weird. Either you have tmi out of your ass, or these are the musings of a madman.

I understand the reason for your michelle read, and we should pressure her to explain what happened.
I think she is town, but crossing your I's and dotting your t's is important.

I don't even want to think about LM right now.
I have trouble reading bitter who claims to be my little squire boy.

I can see your Cal read if I squint a bit. I am worried giving him too much cred while doing nothing makes him an easy blind spot as scum.

I mostly agree with potato read, but I have to go back and read him later.
I remember a good catch-up post and some fine vibing posts today.
The porblem with the catch-up to me was that it didn't include new/personal reads from what I rememeber. Very easy to fake as scum.

Al is either town or indie. I have no reason to think he is not town tbh.
Kinda like the Shanks read.


My problem with your list is mostly that in the world that has melkor as town you could easily be on a team with cal and/or ginger.

I like your shanks and charlie reads tbh. I have been afraid to give Charlie too much cred, but I mostly agree with your read.

 

[Jan]

The unwitting clowns are the problem. I wear my nose with pride and bring joy and levity to all

And I respect and love you for it.

 

[Flower]

the fact that you think it is me instigating and not sakazouki with how rude he is lmao

The issue is that Townies can make bad decisions or have wild or suboptimal action choices. It‘s a normal thing you have to factor into games and your approach to the game whenever you’re Town. All I see with Saka is that his action sorta matches his world view and I think it’s sadly just a Town action. So calling him Jester for it just doesn’t feel good lmao.

 

[Jan]

If scum know you can check people's alignments then that's on you big boy


I bet you followed my instruction of taking a deep breath

But hey keep pretending like you had this epic plan lmao
You had no need to mention anything about Melkor, no one had to know you can check alignments, definitely no one had to know you were Ned Stark but I guess you completely lost your composure, clown show indeed xD

I am claimed. my character does not matter at that point.

I added character claim because it was funny to me. That claim does not add or remove anything.

Anyway.

 

[Worst]

Zemmi is weird. Either you have tmi out of your ass, or these are the musings of a madman.

My problem with your list is mostly that in the world that has melkor as town you could easily be on a team with cal and/or ginger.

Is it bc i town read them or u see some other connection ?

 

[Charlie]

Oh wait, jag said york shot Polar? Thought she shot worst

 

[Jan]

Okay add Tayenne to my scum pile for these reactions. Just looks like instigating.

It is funny that your reactionary reads are and will always be your worst reads.
And they are still the ones you push the most.

 

[Tayenne]

The issue is that Townies can make bad decisions or have wild or suboptimal action choices. It‘s a normal thing you have to factor into games and your approach to the game whenever you’re Town. All I see with Saka is that his action sorta matches his world view and I think it’s sadly just a Town action. So calling him Jester for it just doesn’t feel good lmao.

no I see his initial reveal as ye a townie mistake that can happen, but just how he afterwards taunted jan instead of apologizing or something just seemed really weird