I'm not suspicious because you I think that was a legitimate effort to lynch Flower; I'm suspicious because you appeared to use that joke vote as a smokescreen to shift your vote from Melkor to Dio out of nowhere after Jan explicitly called for moving votes away from Dio to get that Polar lynch going.
Super Role Madness Game Of Thrones: A Song Of Ice and Fire
- Thread starter Fujishiro
- Start date
- Tags reloaded is fooken scum
Now, I did not mention Charlie in my reads list because I thought he deserved his own post, because I believe there is something incredibly damning that I came across looking back at his post.
Near the end of the Day Phase, Charlie basically throws a life-raft out to Polar Bear.
He has a very mysterious ability where he can save somebody from a lynch, but it only works if that lynch happens to be a specific innocent member of town and he can not confirm the role, if that lynch is stopped then it is proof that they are innocent.
He then begins hard angling for Polar to claim his character, saying that if he's his target then he can both save him and clear him for town.
Jan makes a post calling the role suspicious as it can easily be used as a lifeline for two scum to save each other. After which Polar and Charlie instantly dissolve this angle and back off of it.
Then the phase ends and the lynch is canceled.
Now imagine this as a version of events.
-Charlie is mafia and has an ability that can end a day phase without a lynch, naturally he wants to use this in case one of his scum-mates is in trouble, but he needs the convincing cover story that will make them both look good.
-Charlie sees Polar Bear is the near certain lynch and sends in his ability to have Fujishiro activate.
-Charlie begins working the angle in the thread where he can position it as Polar Bear is the town child he saved
-Jan notices and casts a ton of suspicion on the claimed ability, making him realize he will only make both of them look scummy, so he backs off the case.
-His activated lynch cancel still goes through and we are left without a lynch taking place
Then coincidentally the next phase after the cancelled lynch, Charlie is here to inform us that he is now a vanilla because his target died, so we don't have to worry about his role again, it's not a problem anymore.
Everything about this looks horrific.
1. It requires Fuji to have added a high-risk move like a lynch cancel into the game, but then eliminates the entire risk factor involved in the role as it can only be used on a town player and then exonerates them. The entire balance towards giving a role like this to town is that they might accidentally use it to save a scum, but that's not even an option here. Making such a role hyper-specific to only one other individual player doesn't line up with any hosting practice I've witnessed before either.
2. It means that there are two lynch cancels in the game which would be an insanely bold move of Fuji when it's a very controversial role to even include one of them, and that Charlie then just happened to revert back to vanilla immediately after the scum lynch cancel used their ability.
I still don't like Orca, but I'm not of the mind that Charlie is probably almost certainly a scum here with the story he's strung and that he's the safest option to lynch.
Near the end of the Day Phase, Charlie basically throws a life-raft out to Polar Bear.
He has a very mysterious ability where he can save somebody from a lynch, but it only works if that lynch happens to be a specific innocent member of town and he can not confirm the role, if that lynch is stopped then it is proof that they are innocent.
He then begins hard angling for Polar to claim his character, saying that if he's his target then he can both save him and clear him for town.
Jan makes a post calling the role suspicious as it can easily be used as a lifeline for two scum to save each other. After which Polar and Charlie instantly dissolve this angle and back off of it.
Then the phase ends and the lynch is canceled.
-Charlie is mafia and has an ability that can end a day phase without a lynch, naturally he wants to use this in case one of his scum-mates is in trouble, but he needs the convincing cover story that will make them both look good.
-Charlie sees Polar Bear is the near certain lynch and sends in his ability to have Fujishiro activate.
-Charlie begins working the angle in the thread where he can position it as Polar Bear is the town child he saved
-Jan notices and casts a ton of suspicion on the claimed ability, making him realize he will only make both of them look scummy, so he backs off the case.
-His activated lynch cancel still goes through and we are left without a lynch taking place
Then coincidentally the next phase after the cancelled lynch, Charlie is here to inform us that he is now a vanilla because his target died, so we don't have to worry about his role again, it's not a problem anymore.
Everything about this looks horrific.
1. It requires Fuji to have added a high-risk move like a lynch cancel into the game, but then eliminates the entire risk factor involved in the role as it can only be used on a town player and then exonerates them. The entire balance towards giving a role like this to town is that they might accidentally use it to save a scum, but that's not even an option here. Making such a role hyper-specific to only one other individual player doesn't line up with any hosting practice I've witnessed before either.
2. It means that there are two lynch cancels in the game which would be an insanely bold move of Fuji when it's a very controversial role to even include one of them, and that Charlie then just happened to revert back to vanilla immediately after the scum lynch cancel used their ability.
I still don't like Orca, but I'm not of the mind that Charlie is probably almost certainly a scum here with the story he's strung and that he's the safest option to lynch.
I'm aware that you said it, and I'm also aware that it sounds like complete nonsense.
Well, I'm not against flipping Orca since I'm pretty sure you are a scum team right now.
Funny you mention him because you seem rather allergic to that wagon.
You argued that there's no point in being part of it because he had too many votes already, so you tried to build a secondary wagon. Then when Melkor and Orca tied in the vote tally and it became clear that a vote on Orca could decide the tie-break, then instead of going for him you started pointing the finger at AL, Melkor, and I. Saying that us voting Polar D2 was somehow incriminating, yet forgetting that I nearly got Polar killed D1 back when he wasn't under threat of lynch while you were snoozing and failed to provide a vote at all.
I like that you're already paving the road for the Orca scum flip, but if you've landed on the conclusion that Orca and I are a mafia duo then I'd like to see some action and initiative on your part. Go ahead and place your vote on him, I will even join you.
Well, I'm not against flipping Orca since I'm pretty sure you are a scum team right now.
Funny you mention him because you seem rather allergic to that wagon.
You argued that there's no point in being part of it because he had too many votes already, so you tried to build a secondary wagon. Then when Melkor and Orca tied in the vote tally and it became clear that a vote on Orca could decide the tie-break, then instead of going for him you started pointing the finger at AL, Melkor, and I. Saying that us voting Polar D2 was somehow incriminating, yet forgetting that I nearly got Polar killed D1 back when he wasn't under threat of lynch while you were snoozing and failed to provide a vote at all.
I like that you're already paving the road for the Orca scum flip, but if you've landed on the conclusion that Orca and I are a mafia duo then I'd like to see some action and initiative on your part. Go ahead and place your vote on him, I will even join you.
