If I were to give an updated read-list :
Jan - A claimed cop who nearly got Polar lynched D1, that's rather surefire town to me.
Tayenne - I looked too deeply into certain things with him early on in the game, but he's been looking good so far and was one of the main people behind the near Polar lynch in D1.
Worst - I haven't loved everything about of his play if I'm being honest, but the fact that he's been tied to what should be scum bus-drive with Polar Bear should clear him of being on the same faction. I guess there is the possibility that Zemmi was the bus-driver and chose those targets and Worst lied about the Tracker result, but would Sallucion who had zero posts and probably hadn't had a chance to catch up to the thread have made that play? I don't find it likely, if Worst is hostile then it's probably as an independent which isn't our biggest priority right now.
Michelle- Mainly I don't envision a world where her and Orca are on the same team since this isn't the most ideal scenario to begin bussing and her frustration with his accusations feels genuine. I feel better about Michelle than I do about Orca here. That they evidently got jailed and it didn't stop the kills isn't a bad look either, even if not clearing.
Crowned Witch - I believe they've been having strong takes more often than not throughout the thread, they have been on the same page with a lot of my own thoughts this page. I'm not as sold on voting Melkor over his failed shot when we have both an alleged roleblock and jailer both confessing to targeting him the first night, but I don't think that reasoning is necessarily bad either.
gingerbread - Mostly just because he looks like he appears to be putting more authentic effort into the solve than most of the players here. Action wise he hasn't done anything to solidify himself as town, but for the moment he' looking better than some of the other options.
Lord Melkor - I want to give him town credit because of how lax the game-thread was D1 when he was on the chopping block versus how quickly certain individuals began moving once the momentum turned against Polar. The failed results aren't a great look, he'll probably kick the bucket sooner rather than later with Worst representing half the night lynch, so I feel he shouldn't be the focus.
AL Sama - A bit of a mixed bag for me right now, they've done some things that I disliked and some things that I liked. Had the right call on Polar Bear, but getting swept up by a flood feels very dog ate my homework of an excuse since he could have changed course to Polar in the same post that he said that was the direction that town should go. I don't want to come off as an ass if he actually did have to swim through a flood at end of day though. I agree with his reasoning on the Orca lynch, but I don't love that his pool beyond that has Jan, Tayenne, and the indie in there. If Orca turns out to be town then AL might drop to the red for me, if Orca is scum then I feel strong town reading him.
bittersweet - Hasn't been a very strong game so far in terms of who he has pushed for. He spent most of D1 digging into Flower and shading her for claiming duel immune, and then spent D2 contesting the Polar lynch and trying to get something going against Orca instead. His read list is also a bit funny with him viewing both Worst and Melkor as scum when it seems evident to me that they would not be on a team together. I don't think he's a priority for the time being though since his role almost sounds too creative to be made up and he boxes himself into a corner with it for now.
Mr. Reloaded - Pretty much the only thing I've gotten from his game is that he claims to have role-blocked Melkor, and that he voted out Dio but doesn't want us to look into the people voting out Dio because he deserved it. Kind of a hollow game so far, not much to work with, but nothing that makes him look good. From what I can see they failed to place a vote yesterday, though that might make him look better honestly because scum would probably want to vote Polar Bear for town-cred if they were planning to cancel the lynch regardless.
Alwaysmind - Completely useless, has only talked about FIFA. Only contribution was voting Polar right before the end of D2 where his lynch got canceled, and then voting Melkor with no reasons provided.
SakazOuki - He is asking a lot of questions, some of them have already been answered in the thread, but I don't have a clear idea of his own direction and why he is choosing Melkor. The only other thing I've really gotten from him is being part of the Dio wagon, nothing to sell me on him as a poster.
RippedCal - Feels like a lazy game so far and I don't think they've had a single push that I've agreed with so far. Nothing about their play has given me good vibes.
GalaxyLevelShanks - Has just been openly parroting players with the excuse that he's a rookie so they are just trusting the masses to give good direction to him, but then also managed to not be part of the Polar wagon.
The Orca - I didn't like his behavior and aversion to the Polar lynch near the end of D1, subtly pivoting to Dio. Nor did I like his shading of Flower or Jan or giving positive town reads to YTW for troll-posting.
Yo Tan Wa - I kind of regret that I didn't handle this with my duel. They claimed they are independent and that does track with their troll-posting this game. They aren't pretending to be pro-town, but they are playing too on the nose for scum. Perhaps the night-lynch can rip this band-aid off for us, so that we don't have to waste a day phase.
