Theory Second Star to the Right and Straight on Til' Morning

[Impact]

This is a quote from the story of Peter Pan and it is my explanation for how to get to Laugh Tale.
- I consider Laugh Tale another name for Nakrowa which means Island of Dreams or simply Dreamland.

Basically, you need to be an absolute idiot to get there. This is because, similarly to Neverland, which is also a Dream Island, it is impossible to get there with traditional navigation.

To get to Neverland, a person has to have a childlike belief. For example, adults cannot fly because they believe in physics, but children are open to the idea that they can just lift off the ground and go airborne. This same logic applies to the navigation to Laugh Tale, and why only someone like Roger or Luffy can get there.

Dreamland by itself is just a Dream Island, and it is surrounded by a sea that is affected by it. The islands in One Piece influence the waves surrounding them indicating the sea itself has been altered. As such, it is impossible to find that sea because it is a Dream Sea and requires a person to believe in it before they can find it.

 

[Cruxroux]

Then what's the point of Ponelglyph whose entire purpose is to give the navigation details about going to Laugh Tale?

 

[Impact]

Then what's the point of Ponelglyph whose entire purpose is to give the navigation details about going to Laugh Tale?

Just finding the general area doesn't necessarily mean you'll actually find the island.
- Think of it like a Nen Space. Within the aura of the Nen User, the space is visible, and they can interact with it, but to an outside observer the Nen Space itself is invisible.

 

[Cruxroux]

Just finding the general area doesn't necessarily mean you'll actually find the island.
- Think of it like a Nen Space. Within the aura of the Nen User, the space is visible, and they can interact with it, but to an outside observer the Nen Space itself is invisible.

Except that's not how log pose works.
You need to set them in a way that it points to certain island.
Stampede though Not canon literally was about Log pose (eternal pose) to Laugh Tale.
Which again confirms it as a real material island rather in some dream world.

 

[Impact]

Except that's not how log pose works.
You need to set them in a way that it points to certain island.
Stampede though Not canon literally was about Log pose (eternal pose) to Laugh Tale.
Which again confirms it as a real material island rather in some dream world.

I am going to stop replying to you because I believe you're using a bad-faith argument.

Although your argument suggests there is a direct route to Laugh Tale, Roger's own log pose went haywire when it attempted to find a new destination. Furthermore, when log poses malfunction it is often attributed to climate and magnetic distortion.

 

[Cruxroux]

I am going to stop replying to you because I believe you're using a bad-faith argument.

Yea that's why they need all the red ponelgyphs to set the co ordinate of final island. Which is laught tale.

It's funny to me how if anyone debunks your "theory" or denies it, they are using bad faith arguments lol.

 

[Impact]

Yea that's why they need all the red ponelgyphs to set the co ordinate of final island. Which is laught tale.

It's funny to me how if anyone debunks your "theory" or denies it, they are using bad faith arguments lol.

It's funny to me how you have 12,000 posts in 2 years. You seem chat addicted.

 

[Cruxroux]

It's funny to me how you have 12,000 posts in 2 years. You seem chat addicted.

Is that the best argument you can come up with?
Concession accepted. Close the thread.

"Bad faith argument" the irony.

 

[Impact]

Is that the best argument you can come up with?
Concession accepted. Close the thread.

"Bad faith argument" the irony.

You just came to force your opinion on theorists. Nobody here has to care what you think.

Your argument has disadvantages. You're using material logic to try to refute immaterial logic, but immaterial logic defies material logic by its nature.

 

[Cruxroux]

Nobody here has to care what you think.

Exactly lmao.
Nobody cares what your retarded dreamworld has to say either way.

Thing which has been clearly stated as an real island, you need log pose to navigate and 4 red ponelglyphs. But no let's go to Dreamworld.

 

[Impact]

Exactly lmao.
Nobody cares what your retarded dreamworld has to say either way.

Thing which has been clearly stated as an real island, you need log pose to navigate and 4 red ponelglyphs. But no let's go to Dreamworld.

If it's not a big deal, then you shouldn't be getting so crazy about it.

You respond very emotionally.

Do you have issues regulating your emotions?

 

[Cruxroux]

If it's not a big deal, then you shouldn't be getting so crazy about it.

Really, am I crazy one?

" Claims something "
" someone debunks it "
" You have bad faith argument "

Stubborn to refuse you're wrong is actually insane.

 

[Impact]

Really, am I crazy one?

" Claims something "
" someone debunks it "
" You have bad faith argument "

Stubborn to refuse you're wrong is actually insane.

You're attacking a theory which can be right or wrong.

It doesn't require you to "debunk" anything. You're claiming it's wrong based off of non-canon material, too.

 

[Cruxroux]

You're attacking a theory which can be right or wrong.

It doesn't require you to "debunk" anything. You're claiming it's wrong based off of non-canon material, too.

Even without non canon material.

Your own panels proves your own take otherwise.

 

[Impact]

Even without non canon material.

Your own panels proves your own take otherwise.

I think you have emotional problems, and it's compromising your ability to talk to other people.

I would like you to stop talking to me because I don't think you're in a good place in your life.

 

[Cruxroux]

I think you have emotional problems, and it's compromising your ability to talk to other people.

I would like you to stop talking to me because I don't think you're in a good place in your life.

I love it when the best counter argument y'all got is attacking them personally.

 

[Impact]

I love it when the best counter argument y'all got is attacking them personally.

If I helped you feel like you won, would that make it better?

I'll help you feel like a winner if that's what's going on here, I don't honestly have any stake in this lol

Note: What he was referring to was a log pose that the Roger Pirates had left behind (non-canonical) after they had reached Laugh Tale. They were unable to use a standard log pose to find it previously, and the method of their arrival is not clear. These are facts. What is not a fact is that they used a traditional means of navigation to reach the island. This is an assumption.