Super Role Madness The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
- Thread starter Fujishiro
- Start date
let's say Alissa is town (which is my read on her) and Ekko is mafia. What he gain from that?
I think this kind of obvious nitpicky things are coming more from town than mafia. Time will tell, but since my read upset a few people I think it will be interesting to reread these interactions later in the game after he flips.
I think this kind of obvious nitpicky things are coming more from town than mafia. Time will tell, but since my read upset a few people I think it will be interesting to reread these interactions later in the game after he flips.
So You and I both think Alyssa is town.
Ekko is not out of his scum range but he is actively solving from the get go which is a good sight.
Yoho’s dwindling activity is worrisome.
I would normally never tolerate a d1 claim, I find it very uncalled for and desperate, but given that it’s Naomi we are talking about and that she and flower have shown these D1 claim tendencies before, I’m unsure of what to make of it.
Unlike Charlie, who softly defended naomi’s behavior, Flower has somewhat distanced herself from Naomi, only saying that she is not scum, which I take it as her meta read on her and not mech based, this could be nothing, could be something.
I’m more interested in hearing from the other low posters … Orca, and the newcomers (sorry if you guys are not new but it’s been so long since I have seen new names in mafia games)
Ekko is not out of his scum range but he is actively solving from the get go which is a good sight.
Yoho’s dwindling activity is worrisome.
I would normally never tolerate a d1 claim, I find it very uncalled for and desperate, but given that it’s Naomi we are talking about and that she and flower have shown these D1 claim tendencies before, I’m unsure of what to make of it.
Unlike Charlie, who softly defended naomi’s behavior, Flower has somewhat distanced herself from Naomi, only saying that she is not scum, which I take it as her meta read on her and not mech based, this could be nothing, could be something.
I’m more interested in hearing from the other low posters … Orca, and the newcomers (sorry if you guys are not new but it’s been so long since I have seen new names in mafia games)
let me give you early gth list :o no nulls, if there's scum, it's more likely "nothing to make you gth town" than actual scum read though, it is going to be mostly gut feeling for all
Ali v2 - town
Naomi - town
The Orca - scum
Polar Bear - town
Charlie - innocent child tier, unlynchable town
Flower - town
Xlaw - scum
Yoho - town
bittersweet - town
bradland - scum
Lord Melkor - town
KWEH - town
Alyssa the Lamb - scum
freckles - scum
Ratchet - town
AceMarvel - scum
Michelle - town
Yoshi - town
jinri - scum
EkkoLoJinx - town
And I just realised these are mostly just inactives, so let me start again but not gth this time:
These people I think are solid towns and I'll be happy to sheep whatever wagon they pick D1:
- Michelle
- KWEH
- Flower
- Ratchet
These people seem alright for now:
- Ali v2
- Yoho
- bittersweet
- Lord Melkor
- Ekkolojinx
These are actual GTH towns aka town side of null (not above because they're somewhat unsettling for now, which is not detrimental, but still):
- Naomi (unsettling thing being claim out of f nowhere)
- Yoshi (downpaying himself bit too much for my liking)
- Polar Bear (having only town reads for now, i assume will change soon)
Who?
- The Orca
- Xlaw
Leaving these people:
bradland - borderline "who" category, but has made some posts and nothing came from them so i put him lower
Alyssa the Lamb - i'm not familiar with Alyssa (same for freckless and Ace for that matter), but i do agree with kweh that other than Naomi thing, she's kinda just narrating what's happening, saying what she'll do later
freckles - idk, i just get feeling that they're playing "innocent" too much, i mean apologizing, downpaying themself and all (tbh, i could say sth like this about Yoshi too, but I've saw Yoshi doing that as town too)
AceMarvel - might change later, it's mix of above, only read so far being town yoho (shared by like everyone) and all
jinri - showed up, asked who's usually town core and dipped xd from my distant memory, jinri would be the one to lead town, no?
I wasn't playing town of salem game. Last game I've played with Flower (on WG) was Jojo I believe, which is what I'm reffering to. Where we both were town. In game on OLF she's been town as well. Right now I have Flower at "I fvckin hope she's town". And I want to stay optimistic, so for now she's town.
I guess. I mean afaik my character is straight up "good person". Not a monster I mean. It's powerful af to be able to clear someone D1 though. I do wonder how it works with fake claims. Like, would you get scum role or fake claim. You probably can't ask that, but can you ask whether it would be possible for you to learn flavour that's scum? Or would it be asking the same thing, idk. Either way, i don't think KWEH is scum so it doesn't matter for now.
You mean "actions" she's taking in her threadplay, or ability wise? Is that a claim/hint/whatever?
Bitter and KWEH? Or did you mix them up?
It is, but she's been flavour solving recently in Jojo (as town) and little bit in SW game on OLF (as town as well). So like, while scummy in general, it's not really something she doesn't do as town.
Tbh when I saw it I was like "are you giving us your fake claim, Naomi?" xd Was Naomi janitored like, anywhere recently? Where does this fear come from? Other than that I think she's alright but it did not make sense for me whatsoever. Like, from town perspective. Let's imagine there's SK looking for Geralt or Ciri or Yennefer specifically. You're just saying them to look somewhere else.
Ali v2 - town
Naomi - town
The Orca - scum
Polar Bear - town
Charlie - innocent child tier, unlynchable town
Flower - town
Xlaw - scum
Yoho - town
bittersweet - town
bradland - scum
Lord Melkor - town
KWEH - town
Alyssa the Lamb - scum
freckles - scum
Ratchet - town
AceMarvel - scum
Michelle - town
Yoshi - town
jinri - scum
EkkoLoJinx - town
And I just realised these are mostly just inactives, so let me start again but not gth this time:
These people I think are solid towns and I'll be happy to sheep whatever wagon they pick D1:
- Michelle
- KWEH
- Flower
- Ratchet
These people seem alright for now:
- Ali v2
- Yoho
- bittersweet
- Lord Melkor
- Ekkolojinx
These are actual GTH towns aka town side of null (not above because they're somewhat unsettling for now, which is not detrimental, but still):
- Naomi (unsettling thing being claim out of f nowhere)
- Yoshi (downpaying himself bit too much for my liking)
- Polar Bear (having only town reads for now, i assume will change soon)
Who?
- The Orca
- Xlaw
Leaving these people:
bradland - borderline "who" category, but has made some posts and nothing came from them so i put him lower
Alyssa the Lamb - i'm not familiar with Alyssa (same for freckless and Ace for that matter), but i do agree with kweh that other than Naomi thing, she's kinda just narrating what's happening, saying what she'll do later
freckles - idk, i just get feeling that they're playing "innocent" too much, i mean apologizing, downpaying themself and all (tbh, i could say sth like this about Yoshi too, but I've saw Yoshi doing that as town too)
AceMarvel - might change later, it's mix of above, only read so far being town yoho (shared by like everyone) and all
jinri - showed up, asked who's usually town core and dipped xd from my distant memory, jinri would be the one to lead town, no?
I wasn't playing town of salem game. Last game I've played with Flower (on WG) was Jojo I believe, which is what I'm reffering to. Where we both were town. In game on OLF she's been town as well. Right now I have Flower at "I fvckin hope she's town". And I want to stay optimistic, so for now she's town.
I guess. I mean afaik my character is straight up "good person". Not a monster I mean. It's powerful af to be able to clear someone D1 though. I do wonder how it works with fake claims. Like, would you get scum role or fake claim. You probably can't ask that, but can you ask whether it would be possible for you to learn flavour that's scum? Or would it be asking the same thing, idk. Either way, i don't think KWEH is scum so it doesn't matter for now.
You mean "actions" she's taking in her threadplay, or ability wise? Is that a claim/hint/whatever?
Bitter and KWEH? Or did you mix them up?
It is, but she's been flavour solving recently in Jojo (as town) and little bit in SW game on OLF (as town as well). So like, while scummy in general, it's not really something she doesn't do as town.
Tbh when I saw it I was like "are you giving us your fake claim, Naomi?" xd Was Naomi janitored like, anywhere recently? Where does this fear come from? Other than that I think she's alright but it did not make sense for me whatsoever. Like, from town perspective. Let's imagine there's SK looking for Geralt or Ciri or Yennefer specifically. You're just saying them to look somewhere else.
1- @Ali v2
2- @Naomi
3- @The Orca
4- @Polar Bear
5- @Charlie
6- @Flower
7- @Xlaw
8- @Yoho
9- @bittersweet
10- @bradland
11- @Lord Melkor
12- @KWEH
13- @Alyssa the Lamb
14- @freckles
15- @Ratchet
16- @AceMarvel
17- @Michelle
18- @Yoshi
19- @jinri
20- @EkkoLoJinx
2- @Naomi
3- @The Orca
4- @Polar Bear
5- @Charlie
6- @Flower
7- @Xlaw
8- @Yoho
9- @bittersweet
10- @bradland
11- @Lord Melkor
12- @KWEH
13- @Alyssa the Lamb
14- @freckles
15- @Ratchet
16- @AceMarvel
17- @Michelle
18- @Yoshi
19- @jinri
20- @EkkoLoJinx
