Super Role Madness The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

[Lord Melkor]

Well melkor would have to be trying to deep pocket me in the day phase. For only to rb me at night 1. I don't see anything scummy in his day 1 thread. he was asking questions and had michelle as town and me.

If he does not flip red, i am just gonna see scum taking advantage of melkor bad luck circumstance but again he not even replying in thread and vanishes..

You know human beings sleep and are not obliged to play forum game 24 hours per day?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Who was target N1?

Ace.

He claimed a protective role day 1 and I think as new to the site he would be hesistant to do it as scum. It sounded like someone not familiar with the conventions (that you do not claim such roles day 1 unless you are about to be lynched)?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Did you read the post just below it?

What is your current POE by the way?

 

[Lord Melkor]

i missed some posts, what's about this speculation?

I am town and Alyssa suddenly is duelling me out of nowhere. I was trying to get to the bottom why my result on Naomi did not make sense.

 

[Lord Melkor]

my poe for any non discorders:

melkor
jinri
ace
michelle
yoho
zemmi

Why Michelle?

 

[Charlie]

Why Michelle?

I asked him and he responded with basically "larlie made a long post" xd

 

[Charlie]

Anyone was there on disc when duel happened? Did everyone want Melkor? Or like 1-2 people

 

[Charlie]

@Fujishiro can we get the countdown?

 

[Charlie]

@bittersweet what are you planning to Ask about?

 

[Michelle]

idk what happened on discord, it seems Ekko claimed something but idk what

 

[Michelle]

Spoiler

Mech:
- KWEH has some kind of post restriction ability, used in on Flower who broke it and so far she's fine (he asked her to put german words in her posts, she's german)
- Flower used some kind of positive action on KWEH, i mean asking him to do sth and in return getting something good? anyhow, she learned his flavour i think and is sure KWEH is town
- Flower asked to not be protected since she can take care of herself
- some wish granting thing/player/mechanic approached some people (Alyssa and Flower for sure), Alyssa used it to get neighbour chat with ???, idk what Flower did
- Naomi claimed her flavour out of nowhere, because she was "scared of being janitored", it was some secondary witcher dude, the one who died to tree in live action
- bittersweet can ask host questions about setup, asked basically if results of investigations can be messed with and they can

I think that's it?

In thread, I'd say Flower, Kweh and Michelle are main talking people. Most of people town read them. Early on Yoho "slipped" that his wincon is weird, but apparently he's been talking about town wincon and like, it is. So Yoho is town read by most too. Then Naomi caught some heat, mostly for that weird ass claim I think. Leading wagon rn is Freckles. Started as some push for them to talk I thought but now people are jumping on it left and right for no reason it seems. As for what's happening right now, looks like Orca is spiralling somewhat. We'll see.

I summoned Krogo into the game.

naaaah

flower knows kweh's flavour, that's separate

alyssa said she has neighbour thing from wish granter (?), we speculate it might be genie indie (gaunter o'dimm)

ali said based on mech of some sort he likes alyssa more

so like, put 2 and 2 together

i thought it could maaaybe be cult, but that would be bastard and there are no bastard elements in the game

so they're in neighbour chat, doesn't mean alyssa is town, but i assume based on sth that happened there, ali thinks so

Gotta fix these game times lol

I'm gonna be in bed come night tomorrow so


I'm the witcher

Ill go with

Brad
Ali
Alyssa
Bitter
Xlaw
Jinri

I’m satisfied with my vote on you for now.
could be wrong but you are my top PoE
Ratchet and polar are close seconds.

polar is kinda obv town

hang on let me see whose all in the playerlist and take a stab at a sort

not really too invested in the game atm but this is my early thoughts on the players:

seems okay for now
3- The Orca
4- Polar Bear
5- Charlie
9- bittersweet
12- KWEH

leaning favorable atm but can be playing me if im wrong on some of the poe
1- Ali v2
2- Naomi
8- Yoho
11- Lord Melkor
15- Ratchet
17- Michelle
18- Yoshi

3p/confirmed non-town
6- Flower

poe/likely not all wolves but good place to start
7- Xlaw
10- bradland/Zemmi
13- Alyssa the Lamb
14- freckles
16- AceMarvel
19- jinri

this is not a good reason and just make you look worse.

still it let us know who in game.

how does flavor claiming ruin it? this is not bastard set up

im scum, i like to keep townies in poe

what about you?

Unfortunately town:
- Charlie - explanation being tmi i have in my PM

Friendly towny corpse:
- Freckles - sorry for votting you again

Pretty sure just town:
- Zemmi - came out with mech unprompted, ready to get called a liar by 4 people, no reason for scum to do so.
- KWEH - distant read from D1 based on that PR thing, wish sounds alright too
- Michelle - census, voice of reason and all that, night chat not including themself is something i don't think scum would have since like, what if we came to consensus that we need to yeet Michelle at night.
- Mr Reloaded - solely based on Yoho's xero

Limbo:
- Naomi - hopefully Melkor flips scum because if do, she should be cleared
- Ace - if Melkor is town, should be scum
- Alyssa the Lamb - if Melkor is scum, should be town

Idk what to do with these people:
- Ratchet i mean i thought he's being scummy af at night but i liked his exchange with Naomi today. Idk. I maybe i'm just tripping and that's town. I'm not paranoid enough to assume he's gf if xlaw flips town. Maybe should put him at limbo, idk.
- The Orca - i think is alright? Idk. Polar seemed to believe he's town but he always says that. He's watcher for sure, so there's that. @The Orca what's the reasoning behind watching Naomi out of all people? You thought she's going to be faction killed?
- Ali v2 - started as town, trending down recently.

Dead:
Lord Melkor - i mean contradicting mech is one, two that Ace claimed almost the same utility. So protection+bulletproof.

Indie:
Flower - duh

Come on girl give us nothing:
- Jinri - well, yeah

Maaaaaybe not scum, but gth i'd say so:
Xlaw - like said earlier, acting unusual in thread, has me, ace and Ratchet as town core even though he hasn't interacted with any of us (Ratchet i guess makes sensie given the claim) weird shet happening around claim, 1-shot COP? Why 1? Would like to hear rest of the claim. You already claimed cop yennefer anyway.

Would be really surprised if not scum:
- bittersweet - inconsistency with census mostly but also nothing amazing in thread from my memory
- Ekkolojinx - has multiple scum reads yet would rather focus on indie, had me as town read and when i suspected him he immidately omgused me o:

1- @Ali v2
3- @The Orca
18- @Yoshi

i had these in multiquotes, I will post them to have them if needed

Charlie thanks for making me laugh with the president comment

 

[Michelle]

I am town and Alyssa suddenly is duelling me out of nowhere. I was trying to get to the bottom why my result on Naomi did not make sense.

i am sorry if you are town, this happened when I was asleep

 

[Charlie]

If it's been just Ekko (and i assume Naomi) wanting to yeet Melkor asap and he flips town, wouldn't be surprised if Alyssa and Ekko are aligned scum o:

If Melkor is town, Ace kinda has to be scum at this point.

Sucks for Melkor for sure but it's really informative lynch i feel like

 

[Charlie]

eh, Vote Lynch Bittersweet for now

 

[Lord Melkor]

i am sorry if you are town, this happened when I was asleep

Thanks.

We have to lynch scum since i am town and i not sure town can recover with losing 2 town today. Whom do you want to lynch?

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

If it's been just Ekko (and i assume Naomi) wanting to yeet Melkor asap and he flips town, wouldn't be surprised if Alyssa and Ekko are aligned scum o:

If Melkor is town, Ace kinda has to be scum at this point.

Sucks for Melkor for sure but it's really informative lynch i feel like

dont think melkor is town but if he is orca prob scum

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

i had these in multiquotes, I will post them to have them if needed

Charlie thanks for making me laugh with the president comment

mulit quote = michelle scum tell?

 

[Lord Melkor]

dont think melkor is town but if he is orca prob scum

Looks like people want to go for your head today, whom do you want to lynch?

 

[Lord Melkor]

I am town unfortunately. I am not sure about Alyssa now, had her as solid town day 1.

@EkkoLoJinx @Chuck @Flower you are usually good at mech, any idea how my results could make sense without Naomi lying?

@Zemmi actually should be also good at this because she is a host.

 

[Ali v2]

Oh well


No bitter? You were pretty adamant about lynching him last dp. What changed?

I think you are mistaking me for someone else, I had orca, ratchet and polar, and voted polar.