From my PoV:
Ali - Have generally found to be townie, but it hasn't been updated enough and he has slipped on down. Can be scum. That's 1.
The Orca - Was in conflict with melkor. Should be town.
Charlie - Has generally been townie, am not a fan of his pivot from jinri if jinri is scum. I would say lean townie, but not completely off the table to be scum.
Flower - she is probably some form of indie. The problem is scum killed Ekko who had his sights only on flower, which tells me that Flower surviving is what scum want. I fully believe that she is co-operating with scum in some fashion, but if we focus primarily on their number, she should not be a part of them.
Xlaw - His cop claim makes sense for night 1, also his usage night 2 while frustrating isn't impossible to reconcile. Knowing that I myself am town, I struggle to see the motivation for him to fake claim cop to prop me up. Not only that, we have Kweh vouching that he did in fact target me, which means for it to be fake, they would have to commit a benign action on me to fully sell the fake. It's a lot of effort for minimal reward. As such, I don't subscribe to the notion. Should be town.
Yoho - I'm forgetting who replaced him. I'll have to come back to this one. I think the slot can be scum. That's #2.
I remembered, it was reloaded. Dont have enough to townread this slot.
Zemmi - I'm concerned that I'm not finding her easy to find. I think a lot of her defence has been to argue against the moral value of what she's accused by, which generally rings alarm bells for me because it feels like she subsmconciously concedes the accusation that she's scum but wants to maintain that her motives were not dishonourable or appeals to emotion. It's likely that one of her or Ali are scum. Can be scum, but shared that scum slot with Ali.
Kweh - Unfortunately we only have flower vouching. I don't know if I entirely buy his action but overall I haven't had any real issue with his content. I want a claim here eventually but I think he probably is just town.
Alyssa- duelled Melkor, is likely just town. Nothing else needed to be said.
Ace - Kind of don't have much to read them from. Could be scum.
Michelle - Leaning town overall I think, dont have hard evidence for it but have generally liked her posting.
Yoshi/Jan - Have gone back and forth on this slot. Part of what Yoshi plays like does look very naive and towny. But part is just too sheepy. I think Jan's argument on Ekko potntially lying is egregious but I can't say it's impossible to reconcile as town. Overall, with how the thread treats the slot, I'm going to say, gun to head, town, but a blind spot that needs checking.
‐---------------------
That, I believe, covers everyone. If I had to pick, right now, I would say jinri, Zemmi, Reloaded, Ace. If not exactly them, I would say Ali, Jan and *maybe* Charlie next. But that's generally where my head is at.
