General & Others Mihawk is the pinacle of One Piece's piracy

#1
Who do you think the pinacle of piracy is? Nika if he ever was one? JoyBoy the official (?) first pirate? Gol D. Roger (the D stand for no child support payer)? Monkey D. Luffy?

Well I don't know enough about Nika and JoyBoy to talk about them but I sure know enough about Roger, Luffy and many others you may think that deserve this position.

First of all what is piracy?

"Piracy means committing robbery at sea or illegally copying and sharing protected digital media. "

That means we are all pirates in the modern world. But in One Piece piracy goes beyond that. Strawhats for example didn't got their bounties over robbery. In One Piece the piracy definition is more like "an absolute pursuit of freedom and defiance against the oppressive World Government."

Now who does that better than Mihawk?

Roger? Because he went to Laugh Tale and discovered the truth? For 800 years the World Governament gave 0 fucks about Red Poneglyphs and I'm not so sure they give any fuck about it till now. Roger wasn't after freedom or going against WG. He obligated himself into a quest he couldn't fulfill because he was born a boomer and even obligated his own son to continue it for him. So Roger was far from being free and Ace even less.

What about Luffy that every anime poser call the pinacle of freedom? His whole life was him trying to be someone else. He wanted to be Shanks then he changed to be Roger. He needs to become Pirate King to feel free. He is pretty much similar to Roger.

And you can find similar things about bunch of other pirates. Buggy by either being after treasures or wanting Shanks to become the next King. Crocodile and his power pursuit to revenge agaisnt Whitebeard. Doflamingo almost literally lived in a cage he made himself. Teach needed a certain DF to finally do what he wanted and what he wanted also doesn't makes him free.

Now Mihawk? Mihawk just do as he pleases. No goal. No quest. No nothing. He used to hunt marines on his own. Wouldn't be a surprise if Shichibukai system only exist to make Mihawk stop hunting marines. Pretty sure he was the one who suggested this feature into Cross Guild application system. He pursuited weak pirates just to kill his boredom. And he was rich as fuck. Had a huge mansion on an isolated area surrounded by nature and near the beach. Had at his own disposable the finnest wines Grand Line could grant you.

Pretty much every single pirate is trapped himself into a goal or quest but Mihawk is the only one really free to do whatever he pleases including being aligned to the Governament or against it as he was before become a Shichibukai and now that the system was abolished.
 
#2
Mihawk is almost nothing in relation to piracy.
Mihawk is the pinnacle of swordsmanship.

Pieces of shit like Caribou and Caribou, and the BBPs are near the pinnacle of piracy. They go wherever the fuck they want, steal, betray, murder, and move on.

The pre-ts BB would be the epitome of piracy by our world's standard.
As he stands post-ts, with him mainly chilling in Beehive and fancying himself an illegitimate king, he's less pirate and more a crime lord.
 
#5
I did.


Mihawk reached the top and decided to chill.
He's not after freedom and he wasn't in defiance of the WG.
To clarify by RL World your post makes sense. But on One Piece World is what is being debated on my thread.

Someone who pursues freedom is not truly free. Slaves pursues freedom.

Mihawk used to hunt marines did you forgot? He had a bounty before become a Shichibukai. No unknown is made Shichibukai. And he is now part of an organization of one of the Yonko that puts bounties into Marines and potentially WG employees, who knows? He may be even more agaisnt WG than Revolutionaries 20 years to take down the WG plan.
 
#7
He may be even more agaisnt WG than Revolutionaries 20 years to take down the WG plan.
Sure.
But for Mihawk to represent the pinnacle of piracy atp, I would expect him to free-ball it on Kuraigana and take any fight that comes his way. That would be the pinnacle of being a free pirate in the OP world. Instead, he chose to join an organization. It is an organization that opposes the WG and even plans to replace it, sure. But that's less Mihawk's doing and more Croc's. That doesn't speak to Mihawk's being a good pirate, but to Croc's being a good schemer.
 
#8
Pirate is a Sea Thief, meaning an Outsider who wants your Valuables.
So how can a Pirate tell another Pirate that He is better? By saying that He stole more Loot & got away with it, as simple as that.

How do people know that you stole more? Either by knowing which Place you looted, or by number of places you looted (Quality or Quantity),
For example, scoring Wano when it was known as Land of Gold, or scoring Elbaph & claiming that Adam Tree, or scoring Shandora, or scoring God's Valley, or scoring Emerald City ... etc is a Legendary Feat that you can use to claim you're better than others, to claim that you're capable of looting any place,

Roger Pirates didn't just loot God's Valley, and went to other Legendary Islands, They actually committed Piracy all over the world, from our perspective we know that it's because Roger was searching for Poneglyphs, but from OPVerse Perspective, He was seen as a Pirate who can commit his crimes "Everywhere", and He always gets away with it,

They weren't just making International News, They were making Local News everywhere, so it didn't become a question of who the world believes is best among all those Top Players they hear about in the News, it becomes a collection of countless places all saying that Roger is best or most dangerous pirate who crossed their seas,

Eventually everyone agreed that Roger Pirates are crew who looted entire world (From Roger's & our Perspective, They did that through Poneglyphs & One Piece), but from OPVerse Perspective, They think One Piece is the collection of everything Roger Pirates looted from every single area in the World, hence Roger is considered "Pirate King" & Peak Piracy,

Roger is basically who Chinjao would have being considered to be if He continued to gather Treasures from entire world for many years without any Marine or Garp stopping him. Now, people don't await for someone else to repeat that Journey, cuz They believe Roger already gathered everything that is possible to in such Journey, so the New Goal became "Find where Roger hid his Loot cuz They are certain He didn't spend it".
 
#9
Sure.
But for Mihawk to represent the pinnacle of piracy atp, I would expect him to free-ball it on Kuraigana and take any fight that comes his way. That would be the pinnacle of being a free pirate in the OP world. Instead, he chose to join an organization. It is an organization that opposes the WG and even plans to replace it, sure. But that's less Mihawk's doing and more Croc's. That doesn't speak to Mihawk's being a good pirate, but to Croc's being a good schemer.
That's the problem. You need to free yourself. You want Mihawk to do things. He gives 0 fucks about what you want. Marines came after him. He did beat them all. But they keep sending more and more. He doesn't want that so he joins an organization. That's freedom.
 
Top