Questions & Mysteries The theory that Monkey D Dragon is the man with the burn scar is the only one that still holds water

[Urouge]

That is why it makes much more sense for Monkey D Dragon to be the man with the burn scar.

We’ve already seen his mysterious power in action, in Loguetown, when lightning struck Luffy, followed by rain and gusts of wind that swept everything away.

But we never got an explanation of how, or with what powers.

And given that Dragon seems to manipulate the weather, specifically wind

It fit perfectly with whirlpools at sea, formed of water like rain and moved by the wind

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Same way the arlong pirates did it.

I'm not going to say anything. Just read this part until you get it. I know you can understand what's wrong with it.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

I'm not going to say anything. Just read this part until you get it. I know you can understand what's wrong with it.

You think Gaban can’t manipulate sea currents using his strength that move and devour Mountains?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Yes, that's what I'm explaining

I just said that

We see the power without explanation ➞ Then we see an explanation of how it works

In Elbaf, we were already given an explanation of how Gaban wields his axes when he was introduced as the mountaineater.

So it wouldn't make any sense to show us mysterious whirlpools if we already know how they're made.

But oda showed the mysteries whirlpools first in Lafittes explanation.

 

[Urouge]

But oda showed the mysteries whirlpools first in Lafittes explanation.

That aligns with what I'm saying, I don't see how that's a contradictory argument

I mean, that's what I'm saying, yes

 

[Sir Yasheen]

That aligns with what I'm saying, I don't see how that's a contradictory argument

I mean, that's what I'm saying, yes

You’re saying oda wouldn’t show the cause before the effect? But I’m saying we’ve already see the effect, the whirlpools, before we met Gaban. So I don’t get your point

 

[Urouge]

You’re saying oda wouldn’t show the cause before the effect? But I’m saying we’ve already see the effect, the whirlpools, before we met Gaban. So I don’t get your point

Yes, but we saw it as a silhouette, not the real thing

You're not going to mention whirlpools only to never put them into action against the enemies of the man with the burn scar

We will see it in action in real life at some point

 

[Urouge]

It always comes back to the same thing, I think we've covered all the arguments

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Yes, but we saw it as a silhouette, not the real thing

You're not going to mention whirlpools only to never put them into action against the enemies of the man with the burn scar

We will see it in action in real life at some point

Yes. When the straw hats leave the island we’ll probably see it like Hakoku from Dory and Brogy pre timeskip.

 

[Berry Rich]

My Current Theory

• Ex-Marine Silver Rat (Ginnezumi) is Burn Scar (Hinokizu)
• Character design based off an actor playing Nezumi Kozo
• Davy Back fight will make a return
• The Burn Scar was because of Orange Dragon
• Fishmen in crew that cause whirlpools with Fishmen Jujutsu

Monkey D. Dragon is not active enough in the sea to be Burn Scar. And what reason does he have to hide the a Road Poneglyph?

 

[ArturCantSpeakJapanese]

his ship isnt black