@TheAncientCenturion
tag the forum
I think there would be a revolt if I tagged the forum for Naruto threads
simple answers since I’m on mobile;
One Piece physical stats outpace Naruto’s until Hashirama and god tiers so any Shichibukai can beat any Akatsuki, save perhaps Itachi.
One Piece characters have some great design concepts and makes the unusual or ugly work real well. But for the Shichibukai I really only think;
Doflamingo
Crocodile
Law
have good designs. We got used to Kuma, Boa and even Moriah but imo those are very niche.
The Akatsuki are more as sets with minor differences, but the cloak looks amazing, their different forms of being monsters is almost always visually delightful. The only ugly Akatsuki is Zetsu, and ugly I mean both poorly designed and a blight on the eyes.
so I give it to Naruto here.
Writing as a group (Who is better integrated into the story as a concept)
Akatsuki are better integrated because they serve as the major antagonists for 200 chapters (not counting anything post Pain as “Akatsuki”) & were heavily foreshadowed at the end of part 1 when Orochimaru was still the dominating figure.
Shichibukai aren’t done poorly but they share their space with regular antagonists that would be filler villains in Naruto, then the navy, then the Yonko. So their roles are a lot more complex and nuanced with half of them turning to be allies and likely all will be on team Straw Hat by the end.
but the Akatsuki actively drive the story, the Shichibukai have their arcs and major roles in other arcs but play a much more minor part.
- Writing for each individual
Moria’s got a good backstory despite how I do not care about his character.
Crocodile is the best written antagonist in the verse
Doflamingo comes up short of Crocodile as a villain but he has a much more fleshed out backstory that ties into the plot of his arc, which makes him even more engaging as a character.
Jinbe has a fleshed out story but his is just okay & as a character he’s just kind of dull.
Boa, I feel the same way towards. There’s room to go into it but nothing really to say or do there. She’s most interesting when Luffy isn’t around.
Kuma is a pretty top tier written character even if I think his backstory was too much torture porn.
In the inverse, Itachi, Sasori, Kisame, Nagato & Konan are the only real Akatsuki to have developed backstories and competing personalities and generally being well written. I think Sasori is a great example of a character whose design 100% conveys his character before you even fully understand it.
But as mostly antagonists who last an arc or two, most will come up shy here. I think the Shichibukai have better written characters cause Oda gives us a much fuller picture of them, but the Akatsuki like Deidara or Hidan are still great for their personalities and actions, despite having the screen time more comparable to arc villains like Enel or Katakuri.