Role Madness Hunter x Hunter Mafia

MURDEROUS SPREE (:D) vs Nat

Thats not a town meta
Thought melkor leaned scum and Nat's entrance hasnt done much to sway that tbh ima go there

vote Nat
"No content"

Melkor had 77 posts and most of them qualified with his scum meta
Can we get votes on Nat shes talking pure shite
Vote for nat with me let's get spicy
Stop pretending you dont know the phase is over
She is confirmed scum already mate
 
So I've read the guy, it's not many pages, I recommend you do the same. It's a difficult read for me in terms of allegiance. He did some, hmm, unnecessary stuff for scum? Although I see scenarios where this would be tactical or resembles his scum play?

Going in depth:

1. The guy now claims that he suggested lynching Flower, yeah, he did, briefly in one post, without even moving forward with this push, despite proving he can be more decisive with his Naomi and Nat pushes.

Notabene: he even went to tell Flower that she is fake claiming a role.

If you have someone you're convinced are lying about their role, why still go for Nat in that volume?

The problem is, he is, like overstating his accomplishments in the thread, while anyone can just ISO him and say this ain't exactly true. I feel like scum tries to have more integrity? RippedCal seems like a Bobek-like player, who plays not that great as town, but has so much town entitlement, that he overamplifies his role in events.

2. Nat murderous spree.

Would he overextend so much to murder Nat, when, if Nat is town, it was a comfortable lynch for scumteam, because it was happening between two townies?

Why put so much into this basket (from scum!Cal perspective), when he could have been like "yeah lynch Nat, but I won't cry if Yoho" .

Counterarguments:
- with Nat town, scumteam wanted to get rid of her sooner than later, because she's less lynchable than Yoho; we have semi confirmation of this in Flower's prelynch switch up, so this could have explained why scum!Cal did this?
- CFDs by scum!Cal like this are precedented. I recall, when I was scumming with him, he was able to push for random town CFDs, even if we had already other town staged for lim - it's beneficial for scumteam because they get a "wildcard" mislim, which does not really move the game forward, but increases town paranoia.



After such text, you might expect a definite answer from me what is Cal's color, but I struggle to give one, as I can see scenarios where he did stuff as town. Overall, couple of damning things, but in my gut feeling I'm not as convinced he's scum as I was for e. g. Havana.

The unpairing that Crying was yelling about is not major IMO.

@RippedCal - a question directly to you - why you haven't made an attempt to lynch Flower, while you straight up accused her that she's lying about her role? Why the Nat spree instead? What's your current view on Nat?
 
Let's shake this day a little bit, we need a cw
You are trying to take credit for wanting a counterwagon that turned into a lynch after you "went to the gym" and you have no reason for lol
I can see orca

ISOing havana rn
Have you shared the results
Eugh it's a dirty read but Flower exposing Havana alt is probably fully unpairing.
Was it?
Again voting Nat to win the duel looks like the best to me.
And people jumpig to give her as target are looking bad now to me.

Which means Saber and Cryo and who else?
This seems like a rough post trying to find something to push
also i don’t think we can Sus ppl for having different views than us cuz it could be us who are wrong and stupid and they might not be
Biggest thing i have found is try to put yourself in their mind. Does their reason make sense and tracks. If you can easily poke holes in it or its just crazy to you...points toward being from scum
This doesn't seem like anyone would follow it

Why paranoia?
I was suspecting Melkor for a weird take on my slot very early but also that could be himself being paranoid on me.

Yeah, but why they used it though?

Cooperative about what exactly?
Did you ask stuff and I didn't answer or what?

Am I wild? I think I have a very logical suspicion.

We already had more lynch bs than we deserved

Why is this exactly what Orca said??

Same. It is how it is.
You remain with your buddy Orca, enjoy!
You know, my town read on you doesn't mean I will accept anything you post or follow your read canceling my own

Or he is a perfect example of town who gave up. How do you make the difference?

Yeah that's why I wanted more wagons at Eod 1 to save my mate Yoho.
Err.. Wait!! My mate Yoho I didn't want dead D2 as well, we are outed, Yoho and I.


Another one!
Please enlighten me how you reached this conclusion.
Also I am going to the gym, idk if I can be here for Eod.
@The Orca take this perfect opportunity to mislynch me, maybe you won't have another one.

Probably not switching the vote, especially for the duel. I will think at it during the gym classes.

Ping me if there may be a viable cw I am joining almost any to save Jan today. Too big of a wagon, thread feels like the lynch is decided, dead air dead villager, this is the general feeling I have and the reason I want the save for
I have a joke to make but ill refrain
For reference, who is up for lynching havana instead of Jan?
I don’t think so.
you know what? Fuck it, let’s CFD him
Vote havanaclub
Pretty sure this was the main reason Havana was lynched
Vote him, my saber
vote lynch havana
Vote Havana,

Kindly claim before I go to the bed
These 3 look good
Votes are locked​
Saber had 5 votes, one of them Ginger who claimed DV

one more here, 6

one less here, 5 again


+2, 7 votes

and now starts the CFD on Jinri

one minus on Saber, 6

Saber didn't sslf vote so this doesn't affect his wagon
Jinri at 2

one less om Saber, 5
Jinri 3

when everyone wants to CFD Jinri, Orca is avoiding the main wagons.

one less on Yoho, 5
Jinry 4

Saber 4 (5 with the DW)
Jinri 5



whoever voted Jinri at Eod should be cleared. There's no way mafia follows a CFD on their mate like that.

so town core never rescind is Ali/Saber/Michelle/Cryo
and the honourary town our SK who killed mafia and gave us a chance!

Saber could self press on Yoho with ease if scum, so yeah, he's town.

oh wait, for Ali and his simp Orca I bussed hard every single flipped scum.. oh well..
You haven't posted any reason for like any of them lol. Also don't confuse voting off as not being a part of. I voted off Saber and voted mafia. Which allowed for the Jinri vote to win out I guess. My switch was vital.

When you resort to name calling you have lost the argument

 
So I've read the guy, it's not many pages, I recommend you do the same. It's a difficult read for me in terms of allegiance. He did some, hmm, unnecessary stuff for scum? Although I see scenarios where this would be tactical or resembles his scum play?

Going in depth:

1. The guy now claims that he suggested lynching Flower, yeah, he did, briefly in one post, without even moving forward with this push, despite proving he can be more decisive with his Naomi and Nat pushes.

Notabene: he even went to tell Flower that she is fake claiming a role.

If you have someone you're convinced are lying about their role, why still go for Nat in that volume?

The problem is, he is, like overstating his accomplishments in the thread, while anyone can just ISO him and say this ain't exactly true. I feel like scum tries to have more integrity? RippedCal seems like a Bobek-like player, who plays not that great as town, but has so much town entitlement, that he overamplifies his role in events.

2. Nat murderous spree.

Would he overextend so much to murder Nat, when, if Nat is town, it was a comfortable lynch for scumteam, because it was happening between two townies?

Why put so much into this basket (from scum!Cal perspective), when he could have been like "yeah lynch Nat, but I won't cry if Yoho" .

Counterarguments:
- with Nat town, scumteam wanted to get rid of her sooner than later, because she's less lynchable than Yoho; we have semi confirmation of this in Flower's prelynch switch up, so this could have explained why scum!Cal did this?
- CFDs by scum!Cal like this are precedented. I recall, when I was scumming with him, he was able to push for random town CFDs, even if we had already other town staged for lim - it's beneficial for scumteam because they get a "wildcard" mislim, which does not really move the game forward, but increases town paranoia.



After such text, you might expect a definite answer from me what is Cal's color, but I struggle to give one, as I can see scenarios where he did stuff as town. Overall, couple of damning things, but in my gut feeling I'm not as convinced he's scum as I was for e. g. Havana.

The unpairing that Crying was yelling about is not major IMO.

@RippedCal - a question directly to you - why you haven't made an attempt to lynch Flower, while you straight up accused her that she's lying about her role? Why the Nat spree instead? What's your current view on Nat?
Here is a thought, would Cal play differently on a team with Flower? His overall play has been lacking and I think that kind of points to town on this site for him
 
i think mafia at this moment just tries to keep status without making waves. They're maybe town read and they fake activity.
Orca and Cal can be both scum if I am looking at their play. Most commentary mode and no real solve.

Jan had to go first but if he isn't mafia then these 2 should be scrutinized more.
 
i'll tell you this, gym saved my life, I am rarely skipping gym for mafia, so I can say almost never
Of course you can be disrespectful like you always are and accuse me of lying but I have no reason to do that and your focus on my RL activity is lame and useless in solving the game.
i am going to the gym regardless alignment which is obvious if you have the curiosity to look at other games.
You don't have to answer at this one also I am asking @Polar Bear to take note.
Maybe we won't play again more than Al's game but the way you always come at me with this is not only deceiving people, is also deadly boring for me and you should stop.
 
I think you're reading too much into who voted for Havana yesterday, because I believe Jan will flip scum too, so it's no difference for scum who'd go down tbh.

There was no possibility for third option yesterday.
Nah I was mostly reading into who voted Jinri that's the moment when things started to go south for scum.

I want Jan's flip before speculating for Havana's votes
 
Top