Role Madness Hunter x Hunter Mafia

Ali v2

No regret, yet, every regret.
‎
So I've read the guy, it's not many pages, I recommend you do the same. It's a difficult read for me in terms of allegiance. He did some, hmm, unnecessary stuff for scum? Although I see scenarios where this would be tactical or resembles his scum play?

Going in depth:

1. The guy now claims that he suggested lynching Flower, yeah, he did, briefly in one post, without even moving forward with this push, despite proving he can be more decisive with his Naomi and Nat pushes.

Notabene: he even went to tell Flower that she is fake claiming a role.

If you have someone you're convinced are lying about their role, why still go for Nat in that volume?

The problem is, he is, like overstating his accomplishments in the thread, while anyone can just ISO him and say this ain't exactly true. I feel like scum tries to have more integrity? RippedCal seems like a Bobek-like player, who plays not that great as town, but has so much town entitlement, that he overamplifies his role in events.

2. Nat murderous spree.

Would he overextend so much to murder Nat, when, if Nat is town, it was a comfortable lynch for scumteam, because it was happening between two townies?

Why put so much into this basket (from scum!Cal perspective), when he could have been like "yeah lynch Nat, but I won't cry if Yoho" .

Counterarguments:
- with Nat town, scumteam wanted to get rid of her sooner than later, because she's less lynchable than Yoho; we have semi confirmation of this in Flower's prelynch switch up, so this could have explained why scum!Cal did this?
- CFDs by scum!Cal like this are precedented. I recall, when I was scumming with him, he was able to push for random town CFDs, even if we had already other town staged for lim - it's beneficial for scumteam because they get a "wildcard" mislim, which does not really move the game forward, but increases town paranoia.



After such text, you might expect a definite answer from me what is Cal's color, but I struggle to give one, as I can see scenarios where he did stuff as town. Overall, couple of damning things, but in my gut feeling I'm not as convinced he's scum as I was for e. g. Havana.

The unpairing that Crying was yelling about is not major IMO.

@RippedCal - a question directly to you - why you haven't made an attempt to lynch Flower, while you straight up accused her that she's lying about her role? Why the Nat spree instead? What's your current view on Nat?
I had fun reading this, Like listening to Bethoven. Very nicely done, GB.



Can you do pull ups?
I can do air walk pull ups, ever since I saw it, all I wanted to do was that, I injured my shoulder years ago trying to strengthen it for the pull up
 

Ali v2

No regret, yet, every regret.
‎
@Michelle
The reason I sus you is because you seem to tunnel on a single slot that has proved time and time again that they are town, the tunnel itself is fine, however, being so invested in the tunnel that you fail to look elsewhere (or maybe that’s the entire plan behind the tunnel) is a tactic I find scummy and shouldn’t be allowed.
You simply can’t play the game in D4 like you played it in D1, game is pretty much solved.
 
@Michelle
The reason I sus you is because you seem to tunnel on a single slot that has proved time and time again that they are town, the tunnel itself is fine, however, being so invested in the tunnel that you fail to look elsewhere (or maybe that’s the entire plan behind the tunnel) is a tactic I find scummy and shouldn’t be allowed.
You simply can’t play the game in D4 like you played it in D1, game is pretty much solved.
I think Orca is completely outed by the reasons I posted, partner equity with Flower and lack of solve of the game. He missed the main wagons when we lynched Jinry and Havana, focused on vanity tunnels.
His only play is a tunnel on me without any intention to solve and you pat his head and he's pocketing you.
It's like you have a double standard in your judgement, I said it already.
The Orca: Jan > Michelle
I said it's bad to lynch an inactive and we received a more active Havana flip instead. If Jan flips town like I think, then it's the second town flip I wanted to avoid
If he flips scum, it's way more beneficial to kill Havana in the yesterday game state.
I don't need to play D4 like D1. I don't need to make more effort than vibing with the town reads and look at how everyone is positioned in the lynch wagons when we have so many scum flips already.
I think my solve of EOD1 wagons is accurate and you, Cryo and Saber are always town.
More than this, Ginger proposing the Havana cw is a very good point in his favour, that means 4 super towny players who I see as solved
If I am wrong in the above reads, please tell me why and how.

If Jan flips town we have to solve
Nao
Ekko
xlaw
Bitter
Nat
Cal
Orca
And between them I can see only Cal and Orca as bad.

If Jan flips scum, I will analize the wagons again.

Idk how my posts makes you say I fail to look elsewhere than Orca, have you read my posts??
 


VC7 D2

Nat - 6
Yoho - 5
Ekkolojinx - 1
Saber - 1

Naomi: Ekkolojinx > Ekkolojinx
Ali v2: Flower > unvote > Ekkolojinx > Nat
Flower: Ali v2 > Yoho > Ekkolojinx > Gingerbread > Yoho > Ekkolojinx > Yoho > Nat
RippedCal: Naomi > Nat
Ekkolojinx: Naomi > Jan > Nat > Yoho
Bittersweet: The Orca > Ekkolojinx > Yoho
The Orca: Michelle > Flower > Nat
Crying bc no Cryo: Yoho
Michelle: Ekkolojinx > Nat
Saber: Ekkolojinx > Nat
gingerbread: Yoho
Nat: Saber
Jan: Ekkolojinx
Xlaw: Yoho

Votes are locked.​


@Yoho / Morel has been lynched



Day 2 ends
Night 2 begins
You have 20 hours to send me your actions

@jinri / ??? has come back to the game.
​

GB
Ekko
Havana
Jan
Nat
Cal

Everyone else feels like towny enough ig to not want them immediately out

Ekko and Nat have stepped up socially today and Cal has possibly some flower spew and Jan has some activity excuses with irl so

I guess GB and Havana are the ones i suspect most but I know there’s more than just 2 wolves left right?
1- Yoho
2- bittersweet - not w/w with Flower, but I have to check votes
3- Flower
4- Naomi - same
5- Ali v2 - town, there's no need to encourage CFDs if scum
6- York
7- Saber - town most probably
8- Xlaw - probably town as well
9- Crying bc no Cryo - good enough
10- EkkoLoJinx - same, somehow I disliked the unvote on the duel
11- jinri rep by Relo
12- gingerbread - yes, this is town!
13- Ratchet
14- The Orca - the lie about what Fuji said and the way Flower ignored his push shows for me possible partner equity with Flower
15- Polar Bear
16- Alwaysmind Replaced by Jan we have to lynch the slot since he's not playing
17- havanaclub
18- Michelle
19- RippedCal - good vibe, I need to check votes
20- Lord Melkor Replaced by Nat - if Jan flips town we have to start here ig

Now if it's multiball, one team is out ig, and if not we have to find 2 more?
If there's a second team, almost no one is really clear ig

I need to add the roles for a full analysis but it's too late.
I would appreciate help
that fuji job for the grave yard.


flipped

town
polar bear Zepile learn amount of shot used
Ratchet Binolt learn ability used

Yoho Morel RB

scum

Flower Chrollo Lucilfer steals 1shot/bp/janitor/god father
reloaded Uvogin duel/strongman/rb
havanaclub Shalnark redirect



York hisoke sk/watcher



alive

Jan Pakunoda mention by ali, that scum faction

The Orca
saber kurapika
Nat
ekko
michell
bitter-gon
ginger
naomi hanzo
crying
xlaw

did i miss someone?
ripped cal claim the father of the kid, silva
Eod 2 wagons also have to be solved if we have Jan as town and any of Orca and Cal is a miskill

Do we know when Bitter claimed the missing shot?

If that Pakunoda guy is also scum with Flower then we have one single team which is positive.
 
So I've read the guy, it's not many pages, I recommend you do the same. It's a difficult read for me in terms of allegiance. He did some, hmm, unnecessary stuff for scum? Although I see scenarios where this would be tactical or resembles his scum play?

Going in depth:

1. The guy now claims that he suggested lynching Flower, yeah, he did, briefly in one post, without even moving forward with this push, despite proving he can be more decisive with his Naomi and Nat pushes.

Notabene: he even went to tell Flower that she is fake claiming a role.

If you have someone you're convinced are lying about their role, why still go for Nat in that volume?

The problem is, he is, like overstating his accomplishments in the thread, while anyone can just ISO him and say this ain't exactly true. I feel like scum tries to have more integrity? RippedCal seems like a Bobek-like player, who plays not that great as town, but has so much town entitlement, that he overamplifies his role in events.

2. Nat murderous spree.

Would he overextend so much to murder Nat, when, if Nat is town, it was a comfortable lynch for scumteam, because it was happening between two townies?

Why put so much into this basket (from scum!Cal perspective), when he could have been like "yeah lynch Nat, but I won't cry if Yoho" .

Counterarguments:
- with Nat town, scumteam wanted to get rid of her sooner than later, because she's less lynchable than Yoho; we have semi confirmation of this in Flower's prelynch switch up, so this could have explained why scum!Cal did this?
- CFDs by scum!Cal like this are precedented. I recall, when I was scumming with him, he was able to push for random town CFDs, even if we had already other town staged for lim - it's beneficial for scumteam because they get a "wildcard" mislim, which does not really move the game forward, but increases town paranoia.



After such text, you might expect a definite answer from me what is Cal's color, but I struggle to give one, as I can see scenarios where he did stuff as town. Overall, couple of damning things, but in my gut feeling I'm not as convinced he's scum as I was for e. g. Havana.

The unpairing that Crying was yelling about is not major IMO.

@RippedCal - a question directly to you - why you haven't made an attempt to lynch Flower, while you straight up accused her that she's lying about her role? Why the Nat spree instead? What's your current view on Nat?
You just quoted every post that proves i cant be aligned with flower if you can't get there still its a skill issue
 
i'll tell you this, gym saved my life, I am rarely skipping gym for mafia, so I can say almost never
Of course you can be disrespectful like you always are and accuse me of lying but I have no reason to do that and your focus on my RL activity is lame and useless in solving the game.
i am going to the gym regardless alignment which is obvious if you have the curiosity to look at other games.
You don't have to answer at this one also I am asking @Polar Bear to take note.
Maybe we won't play again more than Al's game but the way you always come at me with this is not only deceiving people, is also deadly boring for me and you should stop.
See you don't understand the nuances of the game then or the little things that can show up as possible alignment indictive. I truly believe you love going to the gym and you are amazing for it. 100% you are awesome. Maybe I could be more like you in that regard one day. Total respect for what you do and everyone should maybe be a little more like you. I am not disrespecting you or the gym in anyway. I believe everytime you say it you are probably going to the gym. This is a game of deception and lies though. That's what it is. You developed a pattern where you would post more about going to the gym and using it as a crutch when you were mafia. Like you wanted us to know you didn't have time to play. It became a scum tell. At this point its less so because you know that and more of an inside joke to acknowledge it. I've never been disrespectful to you or the gym. Sorry you thought that but it isn't true and everyone knows that. The comment above was solely pointing out you weren't around when the lynch actually happened by your own words of you going to the gym. Which is significant because it means you had little to do with the actual lynch. Then the problem is expounded when you hyperfocus on that then actually looking for scum and posting reads and other details about other players. Tunneling on this instead of playing the game which is a classic scum trait. I'm playing the game. No disrespect of any kind is meant by it. But we have had this same conversation essentially multiple times. I think you know that, but if you didnt...you are an awesome individual and I love that you love going to the gym. Be proud that you do. Total respect for that and I think it was Jan who mentioned losing weight earlier. Absolutely love that
 
Don't take offense to it Michelle. I've had the same criticisms about my ability to be active during some of the past games because of being in the field for work. I just stopped getting upset about it because it didn't change anyone's mind and just made them suspect me more and made playing the game less fun.

Go to the gym, pop in when you can and make the minimum activity requirements.

Life comes first, no one will judge you for it.
 
See you don't understand the nuances of the game then or the little things that can show up as possible alignment indictive. I truly believe you love going to the gym and you are amazing for it. 100% you are awesome. Maybe I could be more like you in that regard one day. Total respect for what you do and everyone should maybe be a little more like you. I am not disrespecting you or the gym in anyway. I believe everytime you say it you are probably going to the gym. This is a game of deception and lies though. That's what it is. You developed a pattern where you would post more about going to the gym and using it as a crutch when you were mafia. Like you wanted us to know you didn't have time to play. It became a scum tell. At this point its less so because you know that and more of an inside joke to acknowledge it. I've never been disrespectful to you or the gym. Sorry you thought that but it isn't true and everyone knows that. The comment above was solely pointing out you weren't around when the lynch actually happened by your own words of you going to the gym. Which is significant because it means you had little to do with the actual lynch. Then the problem is expounded when you hyperfocus on that then actually looking for scum and posting reads and other details about other players. Tunneling on this instead of playing the game which is a classic scum trait. I'm playing the game. No disrespect of any kind is meant by it. But we have had this same conversation essentially multiple times. I think you know that, but if you didnt...you are an awesome individual and I love that you love going to the gym. Be proud that you do. Total respect for that and I think it was Jan who mentioned losing weight earlier. Absolutely love that
are we sure this is orca on the account?
 
you don't understand the nuances of the game then or the little things that can show up as possible alignment indictiv
the game is never that simple, you reduce it at tells who are not AI.
it's not like if someone starts a scum game by claiming scum the next game when they claim scum they are actual scum.
if it's a joke I can understand it but if you are town and are seriously taking such things and only these into consideration then you are far from solving.
i am mentioning I am afk for a reason, I don't think this should be AI in any way.
i even pinged you when I said it, jokingly, because I want you to see it and judge for yourself. But you failed to notice my play entierely.

You posted Fuji said you are the King Michelle reader. I don't think that ever happened.
For me this looks like a lie. If you can prove it I will reconsider bit a small lie like this who can change the other's perception is manipulative and wrong used if you are town. My read on you solidified after that post. A fake claim can exist and should exist from town to fool scum, but what you said is not something I can accept.

You say you solve. You pushed Flower without convictionm, tunnel me and gave as theory how SK targeted Flower N1 and N2. If your contribution is bigger please tell me, because I don't remember.
 


@bittersweet / Gon has been killed​



Gon Freecss

Target a player and protect them for the night.[3-Shots]

Wincon: Eliminate all threats to the town.
​
@Crying bc no Cryo / Satotz has been killed
​


Satotz

Target a player and learn if they used a killing action that night.[3-Shots]

Wincon: Eliminate all threats to the town.
​
@The Orca / Knov has been killed​



Knov

Target a player and jail them for the night.[3-Shots]

Wincon: Eliminate all threats to the town.
​

Night 3 ends
Day 4 begins
You have 48 hours to discuss



 
Vote Counts:

VC1 D1

VC2 D1

VC3 D1

VC4 D1

VC5 D1

VC6 D1

VC7 D1

VC8 D1

VC9 D1

VC10 D1

VC1 D2

VC2 D2

VC3 D2

VC4 D2

VC5 D2

VC6 D2

VC1 D3

VC2 D3

VC3 D3

Graveyard:

@jinri / ??? Game Removed Day 1
@Ratchet / Binolt Killed Night 1
@Polar Bear/ Zepile Killed Night 1
@Yoho / Morel Lynched Day 2
@Flower / Chrollo Lucilfer Killed Night 2
@York / Hisoka Morow Killed Night 2
@havanaclub / Shalnark Lynched Day 3
@Mr. Reloaded Uvogin Lost Duel Day 3
@bittersweet / Gon killed Night 3
@Crying bc no Cryo / Satotz Killed Night 3
@The Orca / Knov Killed Night 3​
Graveyard was updated.
 
Top