Chapter Discussion One Piece Chapter 1199 - The Things People Pass Down

Rate this chapter


  • Total voters
    111

Rej

Holy Simp
‎
amazing chapter. mostly set up and shifting things.

I am now convinced that Oda is building up the Lili, Imu, Nika flashback and with that Vivi arriving to Elbaf after this. we also need Big News Morgans to report this stuff. holy moly Oda going full gas in this one.

everyone who dislikes it is most likely an illiterate bum and I hope for you that you don't quote me.
 

Devilbat

Just chill and let chill
‎
amazing chapter. mostly set up and shifting things.

I am now convinced that Oda is building up the Lili, Imu, Nika flashback and with that Vivi arriving to Elbaf after this. we also need Big News Morgans to report this stuff. holy moly Oda going full gas in this one.

everyone who dislikes it is most likely an illiterate bum and I hope for you that you don't quote me.
Fire avi!

As for the chapter, I am actually looking forward to the flashback and wouldn't mind Vivi reunion. As a setup chapter, it's absolutely fine.

What I don't necessarily like is the overused trope of shounen MC being possessed by something that makes them out of control. It has nothing to do with literacy, just not my cup of tea.
 
Seeing Luffy lose control is fun because I've always wondered how Luffy would destroy FishManIsland without it being 'collateral damage'

It's tragic that Usopp's entire speech is actually rendered useless now and how whenever he opens his mouth it makes the situation worse, Usopp talked about having them fight head on and Imu decided to show up and then he decided to talk about Luffy still being Luffy then he loses all body autonomy to his devilfruit.

Usopp has yet to have any arc worthy moments in Elbaf so far and I'm afraid he's not going to get any with how much everyone else gets more screentime. Guess we gotta wait another 4 years
:zosleepy:
 
Fire avi!

As for the chapter, I am actually looking forward to the flashback and wouldn't mind Vivi reunion. As a setup chapter, it's absolutely fine.

What I don't necessarily like is the overused trope of shounen MC being possessed by something that makes them out of control. It has nothing to do with literacy, just not my cup of tea.
that is fair.

I just see some people here act like it's a snoozefest which imho isn't. there is too much going and oda def sets stuff up so he can create some sort of firework chapters where everything gets resolved in one go, which is totally fine.

disliking shounen tropes is totally fine too. I think it is what it is...many stories would be probably better if they had less tropes or overuseage of them.

also thanks lol Gabby-chan is some real daughter material lol
 

CoC: Color of Clowns

"Their blood will not sate us. Crush their Souls."
‎
Seeing Luffy lose control is fun because I've always wondered how Luffy would destroy FishManIsland without it being 'collateral damage'

It's tragic that Usopp's entire speech is actually rendered useless now and how whenever he opens his mouth it makes the situation worse, Usopp talked about having them fight head on and Imu decided to show up and then he decided to talk about Luffy still being Luffy then he loses all body autonomy to his devilfruit.

Usopp has yet to have any arc worthy moments in Elbaf so far and I'm afraid he's not going to get any with how much everyone else gets more screentime. Guess we gotta wait another 4 years
:zosleepy:
I've had Sogeking returning to fight Imu.

But, Luffy vs Usopp is one of my favorite fights in the series.

Nika vs Sogeking??? It's possible. Still waiting for Bonney to Distort some Futures.
 

CoC: Color of Clowns

"Their blood will not sate us. Crush their Souls."
‎
Sigh... I can't believe I'm doing this...

But I'm going to defend the God's Knights/Zoro and Sanji, here.



After getting an Omen, Sommers literally just FLIES off to the ship. This dude was ZOOMING.

The reason Zoro and Sanji haven't killed Sommers and Killingham is very simple: they have a giant speed boost active.



We can see a small panel of Killingham's head moving out of the way in the middle of this page from 1199.

Sommers and Killingham are both fast as fuck. Hitting their hearts IS NOT easy, and they are soldiers who have been trained by the most powerful being in the current verse since most likely childhood. It's going to take Zoro and Sanji time before they get the money-shot.

I still maintain Sommers will die and Killingham will live, but, it's Oda, who the hell knows?

I doubt the Roger Pirates never aimed for the heart while fighting the Gods' Knights. The Gods' Knights dodged.

Look at this speed-feat from Killingham:



Those are incredibly fast reflexes against serious Sanji.

In terms of raw strength/speed, Omen-buffed Sommers and Killingham are probably two of the fastest characters we've seen in the series. They just ran into two absolute monsters in Zoro and Sanji.
 

CoC: Color of Clowns

"Their blood will not sate us. Crush their Souls."
‎
C'mon, flashback would get us some lore. Interestingly enough, all flashbacks in Elbaph were good imo, Xebec is rightfully a legend and I also liked Brook's story. So Lili's story could be really good too!



I am not watching the anime....as much as I love manga, I often struggle with anime and its over the top shouting. Was watching Demon Slayer, damn Zenitsu was my least favorite character simply due to his volume. When I switched to manga to finish the story, it was so quiet :sweat:

Narratively, I think there's more weight to saving kids rather than failing to save them. But I still can see Oda giving Limu a win.
Real talk? I actually REALLY want Jarul's flashback, 400 years ago is an interesting time, and I'm deadset that Noland went to Elbaph, and Noland was active when? 400 Years ago.

Noland was famous for what? Botany, and, for helping cure... Tree Fever. Elbaph is built on what? Giant Tree. So, I think Noland is famous in Elbaph, and has a statue somewhere on/in the Adam Tree, for curing Yggdrasil of the same Tree Fever Jaya was suffering from. I also like this theory because the Giants are honorable warriors who often lose their senses when it comes to superstition/religion, just like the Shandians.

I'm just terrified Oda will drop another flashback in the middle of the combat. Brook flashback should have happened before Imu showed up, IMO, not in the middle of Imu/Loki.

Lili's backstory should be very interesting, I'm excited. Interested to see how it might foreshadow Vivi's future in the series.

Ah, yeah, the shouting can be a huge turn off. I generally just laugh through it. I remember the first few episodes of Black Clover. YIKES. And One Piece is really bad when it comes to people randomly screaming their asses off.

I think the kids are getting saved because Oda doesn't like fully repeating history and the CDs succeeded in kidnapping the Giant Children during the Void Century. But, Nika's arrival really throws a... monkey wrench into things! Ahem. Cough.

I also can argue that Oda wants to give Imu a win here, like you said. Introducing the Big Bad and having no real consequences come from it in terms of characters we know seems weak. I still think Jarul/Saul are doomed here, and I'm 50/50 on whether or not Kuma dies.

Nico Robin has caused Imu so many problems, the moment Imu sees Saul, I think he's just screwed. I think Imu wants to interrogate Robin, though.



While Saturn's dumb ass tried to kill her in Egghead, CP0 had CLEAR orders to capture Robin. The simplest explanation?

The WG still doesn't have a dedicated Poneglyph Reader. Which, IMO, is potentially also a Pudding plot (wonderful Avi, by the way).

I could see Judge rejoining the WG and being ordered to kidnap Pudding for her Third Eye.

I will not be satisfied until Sanji beats Judge's ass on panel. I've made a lot of theories about how Sanji will be able to fight women use his CoC to knock them out without physically touching them. I could see Judge using Pudding as a shield, and Sanji kicking through Pudding without hurting her using CoC - the equivalent of "kicking nothing" to "cutting nothing", like the scene in Jojo where the guy punches the frog, but the impact goes straight through the frog and doesn't harm it.




Redo of this scene, where Judge uses his own men as human shields.

Still hoping for Bonney to go on a Distortion Future spree and turn Jarul back to his prime, along with Gyaban, and turn Colon into his prime, too.
 
Im all for simple forms in manga rather than over the top transformations. But man, this new Nika form is just hot garbage design wise. It just looks so lazy like a kid drew it… which even if that was the point it’s still bad.
Reckon it's coz this is prolly a one tiime ting and Luffy's gonna get a new cuul transformation once he has full control over his zoan fruit.
Other than that nothing else really computes.
 
Sigh... I can't believe I'm doing this...

But I'm going to defend the God's Knights/Zoro and Sanji, here.



After getting an Omen, Sommers literally just FLIES off to the ship. This dude was ZOOMING.

The reason Zoro and Sanji haven't killed Sommers and Killingham is very simple: they have a giant speed boost active.



We can see a small panel of Killingham's head moving out of the way in the middle of this page from 1199.

Sommers and Killingham are both fast as fuck. Hitting their hearts IS NOT easy, and they are soldiers who have been trained by the most powerful being in the current verse since most likely childhood. It's going to take Zoro and Sanji time before they get the money-shot.

I still maintain Sommers will die and Killingham will live, but, it's Oda, who the hell knows?

I doubt the Roger Pirates never aimed for the heart while fighting the Gods' Knights. The Gods' Knights dodged.

Look at this speed-feat from Killingham:



Those are incredibly fast reflexes against serious Sanji.

In terms of raw strength/speed, Omen-buffed Sommers and Killingham are probably two of the fastest characters we've seen in the series. They just ran into two absolute monsters in Zoro and Sanji.
Seeing that Sommers and Imu panel jumping made me worry into thinking you were writing that Imu and Sommers have the same speed based on that panel. It's something I read somewhere on the internet and it makes me considering the basic comprehension of guys like that.

Yes, hitting a little part of Sommers/Killingham body is not easy considering they completely gave up on fighting and fully focused on escaping.
 

CoC: Color of Clowns

"Their blood will not sate us. Crush their Souls."
‎
Seeing that Sommers and Imu panel jumping made me worry into thinking you were writing that Imu and Sommers have the same speed based on that panel. It's something I read somewhere on the internet and it makes me considering the basic comprehension of guys like that.

Yes, hitting a little part of Sommers/Killingham body is not easy considering they completely gave up on fighting and fully focused on escaping.
Nah, Gear 5 is the fastest shit we had seen in this manga except possibly Kizaru (which is another reason I still have Kaido ranked so high, what a fucking busted character stat-sheet, holy shit) before Imu, and Imu was speed-blitzing Gear 5 in his 1st form.

Sommers is probably a decent bit slower than Killingham, since Killingham has a Mythical Zoan that has a 4 legged form, and horses are generally fast as heck. That was honestly another hint that Sommers wasn't a Sanji fight, the speed tiers.

Imu was going slow when he launched because he wanted to either thaw out or kill Gunko, here:



We see Imu surveying the land and picking his targets, while Sommers already had a dedicated mission in kidnapping the Giant Kids.

Then, next page, we get him attacking Ragnir's Ice with Gunko inside.



Sommers was shitting his pants because his boss showed up and going as fast as he could, Imu was just cruising at a comfortable speed.

Imu is currently the fastest character in the verse, IMO.

Sommers can't flee Zoro, and Zoro is slow as fuck compared to Sanji. Therefore, we know Killingham is much faster than Sommers, and Imu is just on a totally different level compared to both.

I think overall the fastest God's Knight is Gunko, though, and I wouldn't be surprised if she was faster without Omen than Sommers and Killingham are with Omen.

Gyaban was keeping up with the Imu that outsped Gear 5 Luffy, and Gunko speed crept him easily.



Gyaban is confirmed to have Future Sight in this same interaction when he surrenders after seeing the future where Colon more or less dies.

Gunko VASTLY outsped the guy with Future Sight who was outspeeding Gear 5 Luffy against Imu, Gunko/Shuri is RIDICULOUSLY fast, probably above even current Sanji, and possibly above Gear 5 Luffy.

Gunko with Omen would honestly be pretty nutty, still waiting to see if Imu gives her one, since he bestowed the Omens before she got out of the ice, and now she's actually facing down Brook.
 
Top