Worstgen

EmperorKinyagi
EmperorKinyagi
Elder Lee Hung
Elder Lee Hung
I still maintain that Isshin is FROM’s all time best boss.
EmperorKinyagi
EmperorKinyagi
I like the inner variant of owl father more but Isshin is in the highest tier for sure
TheKnightOfTheSea
TheKnightOfTheSea
The final dlc boss is absolutely amazing. My personal favorite boss including Fromsoft games
TheKnightOfTheSea
TheKnightOfTheSea
I'm an Owl>Isshin truther as well
Elder Lee Hung
Elder Lee Hung
I do love Owl Father but Isshin edges him slightly. Both are high S tier bosses for me.
mmd
mmd
The final boss of the DLC was more like Radahn
TheKnightOfTheSea
TheKnightOfTheSea
he's pretty much better Radahn in almost every singleway
EmperorKinyagi
EmperorKinyagi
In SOTE the final boss feels random and everything else feels mostly planned. In overture the final boss is extremely built up and everything along the way feels random lol. It’s like the exact opposite presentation
Elder Lee Hung
Elder Lee Hung
Elden Ring is shit in every way, no amount of cope will ever change that the final boss should have been Miquella and Godwyn
EmperorKinyagi
EmperorKinyagi
I think the only thing PCR has on Arlecchino is music @TheKnightOfTheSea
SOTE > Overture just for the price ($40 for 11 main bosses vs $30 for 4 main bosses) but Arlecchino is probably the best boss out of both
EmperorKinyagi
EmperorKinyagi
Id probably have overture over most fromsoft DLCs if it was 15-20$ tbh
mmd
mmd
In terms of the balance of the bosses and the reasonableness of their power levels, Sekiro is still the best for me. But Elden Ring is a bigger and better work than Lies of p for me.
EmperorKinyagi
EmperorKinyagi
Old Hunters is definitely the best out of any soulslike DLC. I can’t think of any other game that is carried by its DLC the way Bloodborne is
mmd
mmd
I've never played Bloodborne, but the second DLC for Dark Souls 3 is still challenging for me.
EmperorKinyagi
EmperorKinyagi
If I were ranking fromsoft DLCs with overture it probably goes something like
1. Old Hunters
2. Ringed City
3. SOTE
4. Overture
5. Artorias of the Abyss
6. DS2 DLCs (iron king is the best)
7. Ashes of Ariandel

None of them are bad though, the main thing affecting my ranking is the price. I feel like if I spent full price on AoA I would feel scammed
mmd
mmd
The Lies DLC was interesting to me because of the soundtrack and the final Boss
And for my peers, the Pinocchio story was a nice nostalgic treat.
TheKnightOfTheSea
TheKnightOfTheSea
I agree with the ost take @EmperorKinyagi

Consort Radahn genuinely has one of the only 5 good osts in ER. Lies of P has mid boss soundtrscks but stuff like Feel are great
EmperorKinyagi
EmperorKinyagi
Most SOTE OSTs are great imo
Nightreign OSTs are fire too
base game is a mixed bag
TheKnightOfTheSea
TheKnightOfTheSea
I prefer Overture over Rigged City. I also felt like Overture's length was pretty long. Also it didn't feel random to me. Every area tells the story of Carlo, his family, Romeo and Lea
Top