General & Others Alabasta seems closer to Wano than Dressrosa which seems more similar to Skypeia

#1
I’ve seen a lot of “Dressrosa is new world Alabasta” talk mainly when comparing Doffy and Crocodile; but the two arcs don’t seem that similar to me.

Alabasta is more similar to Wano while Dressrosa is more similar to Skypeia

Let’s look at the arcs side by side.

Alabasta and Wano:

1. The final arc in a multi arc saga

2. An arc where luffy fought and lost to the main villains on 3 different occasions each (and where Luffy couldn’t even hurt the enemy)

3. The villains ultimate plan being connected to the obtaining the ancient weapon

4. The connection to the Pluton

5. Both countries have a flying guardian and a dog guardian: Falcon -> Dragon and Jackel -> Yamato

6. Both villains had plans to destroy the main capital of the country before leaving the country but was stopped by the flying guardian getting the bomb safely out of harms way

7. The saga starting when the Straw Hats discover the missing member of the countries royal family in earlier arcs and saga ending with Luffy inviting them to join the crew whenever they feel ready

Dressrosa and Skypeia:

1. Both islands being made up of two separate pieces of land, one holding a mythological species: Fairies and Angels

2. Doffy and Enel sharing the same false god persona (Kami and a Celestial Dragon)

3. The false gods gaining the crown by forcibly removing the previous leader who ends up fighting the new leader in the shadows (Ricky and the Sky Knight)

4. The fact that both islands are introduced as slices of heaven but the more you dive in the darker the island gets

5. Wyper sacrificing himself to defeat Enel only for Enel to remassage his heart with his devil fruit is a direct parallel to Law sacrificing himself to kill Doffy only for Doffy to sew his organs together with his devil fruit

6. Both villains looking to completely destroy the islands and everyone living there when they no longer needed it (Birdcage and Kingdom Come)


And there are more connections for the arcs I mentioned, which seem more clear than dresrosa and alabasta which it seems like people just compare because Doffy and Croc are both warlords.
 
#11
It's more about the Villains imo than the Arcs

Don Krieg ---> Demaro Black
Arlong ---> Hody Jones
Crocodile ---> Doflamingo

Enel ---> Kaidou
Foxy ---> Imu
Lucci ---> ......... (Xebec)
Moria ---> Final Villain

Actually, if you check Moria, you notice that he had Absalom (Budget King of Beasts), he had Perona (Budget Undefeatable Queen) & Hogback (Budget Double-Faced Villain who was presumed Dead) & that's exactly how Conclusion of One Piece is shaped up

SHs faced True King of Beasts (Kaidou) who is like Final Saga's Absalom & then they will face True World Queen (Imu) who is like Final Saga's Perona & then they will face True Double-Faced Villain (Rocks D. Xebec) who is like Final Saga's Hogback (Basically someone who faked his Death & is Double-Faced, as hinted by Big Mom who insisted that Xebec cannot be fully Trusted)

Kaidou is Teased Post-Dressrosa War
Imu is Teased Post-WCI War
Meaning Villain after Imu (Xebec) will be Teased Post-Wano War (Most likely Kid is gonna give us Xebec Teaser)

After these, SHs will finally face Final Villain who also has a Trio under him
His Commander gonna be "Vander Decken"
His Hax Queen gonna be "Bakkin"
His Evil Scientist gonna be "Willie Gallon"

Basically, they are Four Mysterious Figures just like in Thriller Bark
 
#12
Alabasta is more similar to Wano than Dressrosa indeed, just like you already pointed @Sir Yasheen
Kaido ~ Crocodile
King ~ Mr. 1, Zoro had trouble hurting the opponent in both fights
Kaido and King also have similar relationship with Crocodile and Daz Bones.
Queen ~ Mr. 2

But Dressrosa is more similar to Little Garden than Skypea imo:
1. Doflamingo ~ Mr. 3, both are mini villains who work under Kaido / Crocodile. They both can also make a clone of themselves
2. Sanji didn't get a fight in both arc
3. There are giants in both arc
 
#18
I’ve seen a lot of “Dressrosa is new world Alabasta” talk mainly when comparing Doffy and Crocodile; but the two arcs don’t seem that similar to me.

Alabasta is more similar to Wano while Dressrosa is more similar to Skypeia

Let’s look at the arcs side by side.

Alabasta and Wano:

1. The final arc in a multi arc saga

2. An arc where luffy fought and lost to the main villains on 3 different occasions each (and where Luffy couldn’t even hurt the enemy)

3. The villains ultimate plan being connected to the obtaining the ancient weapon

4. The connection to the Pluton

5. Both countries have a flying guardian and a dog guardian: Falcon -> Dragon and Jackel -> Yamato

6. Both villains had plans to destroy the main capital of the country before leaving the country but was stopped by the flying guardian getting the bomb safely out of harms way

7. The saga starting when the Straw Hats discover the missing member of the countries royal family in earlier arcs and saga ending with Luffy inviting them to join the crew whenever they feel ready

Dressrosa and Skypeia:

1. Both islands being made up of two separate pieces of land, one holding a mythological species: Fairies and Angels

2. Doffy and Enel sharing the same false god persona (Kami and a Celestial Dragon)

3. The false gods gaining the crown by forcibly removing the previous leader who ends up fighting the new leader in the shadows (Ricky and the Sky Knight)

4. The fact that both islands are introduced as slices of heaven but the more you dive in the darker the island gets

5. Wyper sacrificing himself to defeat Enel only for Enel to remassage his heart with his devil fruit is a direct parallel to Law sacrificing himself to kill Doffy only for Doffy to sew his organs together with his devil fruit

6. Both villains looking to completely destroy the islands and everyone living there when they no longer needed it (Birdcage and Kingdom Come)


And there are more connections for the arcs I mentioned, which seem more clear than dresrosa and alabasta which it seems like people just compare because Doffy and Croc are both warlords.
Good points. The only difference of course being that Alabasta is one of the best stories One Piece has to offer whereas Wano is an Eldritch Abomination that should be erased from existence. :cheers:
 
Top