Asta Replaces Touma as Main Character

Astaro · Jul 2, 2023

Asta takes over the role of Kamijou Touma for the role of the Main Character of Toaru Majutsu No Index and any of the spin-offs Touma has a role in.

For the purpose of this thread:

-Asta is his current self
-His Anti-Magic works on everything Imagine Breaker does besides Magic such as Esper powers.
- Any villain motivations that include Imagine Breaker are replaced with Asta’s Grimoire / Demon Liebe

With that, how far does he go in the first series, New Testament, and Genesis Testament

Nightlord101 · Jul 3, 2023

Astaro said:

Asta takes over the role of Kamijou Touma for the role of the Main Character of Toaru Majutsu No Index and any of the spin-offs Touma has a role in.

For the purpose of this thread:

-Asta is his current self
-His Anti-Magic works on everything Imagine Breaker does besides Magic such as Esper powers.
- Any villain motivations that include Imagine Breaker are replaced with Asta’s Grimoire / Demon Liebe

With that, how far does he go in the first series, New Testament, and Genesis Testament

Any magic user or esper who faced asta would be face planted so fast in the ground cause his Physical strength is insane

Astaro · Jul 3, 2023

Nightlord101 said:

Pretty much why I made this thread. Replace one MC with the power to negate Magic with a touch with one from another series

Question is how far does he go?

Nightlord101 · Jul 5, 2023

Astaro said:

Probably defeating two of the elemental saints no problem

But aqua the back and fiamma the right I see them giving asta a lot of trouble

Astaro · Jul 7, 2023

Nightlord101 said:

Fiamma isn’t a Saint but I get you. He also needs to deal with Kanzaki in the beginning volume though unlike Stiyl, she doesn’t need to be beaten, just reasoned with.

I see Asta getting pretty far. Acqua of the Back will be the first true challenge he faces (since his powers work on Accelerator for this thread who fought Touma as a scrub)

And if he gets past that, the English Civil War Arc following right after will definitely be another huge road block for Asta thought even there he’s better equipped than Touma for it