Versus Battle Attack on Titan vs One Piece
- Thread starter Light D Lamperouge
- Start date
AoT went downhill for me after the basement chapter. After that it started building asspulls on top of asspulls. The ending arc was just terrible, but I won't even count that cause we haven't seen OP's ending yet.
Main characters and side characters go to OP easily. It has more variety of both, while in AoT I only enjoy a handful.
Art, imagery, paneling - AoT is hella ugly, would never read that again. Watch the anime, yes, but the manga is terrible.
Story arcs and themes - again OP with more variety. It's written to be more lighthearted but it covers more themes than AoT does.
Main characters and side characters go to OP easily. It has more variety of both, while in AoT I only enjoy a handful.
Art, imagery, paneling - AoT is hella ugly, would never read that again. Watch the anime, yes, but the manga is terrible.
Story arcs and themes - again OP with more variety. It's written to be more lighthearted but it covers more themes than AoT does.
AOT is my fav manga and OP is a manga I wished I never started lol so I am going to pick AOT.
-Plot: Not debateable, easily AOT. One Piece has been going on 1000+ chapters and we still don't know what the main plot is.
-Main characters: Gag characters that are static vs characters that actually go through dilemmas and hardships? Easily AOT.
-Side characters: Erwin, enough said.
-Villains: There really isn't any villain in AOT so OP.
-Character designs: OP.
-Power system: I much prefer AOT fights over OP fights.
-Story arcs: AOT because Oda keeps using the same formula every arc.
-Incorporation of themes:
-Art: OP. Oda is the better artist.
-Imagery: I forgot what imagery means.
-Panelling: AOT. Oda clogs up his panels with too much stuff.
-Originality: AOT. Oda "plagiarizes" a lot of ancient greek writing where Wano's backstory was basically Plato's Atlas which he already used in Skypeia.
-World building: AOT.
-Characterization: AOT.
-Enjoyment: AOT.
-Plot: Not debateable, easily AOT. One Piece has been going on 1000+ chapters and we still don't know what the main plot is.
-Main characters: Gag characters that are static vs characters that actually go through dilemmas and hardships? Easily AOT.
-Side characters: Erwin, enough said.
-Villains: There really isn't any villain in AOT so OP.
-Character designs: OP.
-Power system: I much prefer AOT fights over OP fights.
-Story arcs: AOT because Oda keeps using the same formula every arc.
-Incorporation of themes:
-Art: OP. Oda is the better artist.
-Imagery: I forgot what imagery means.
-Panelling: AOT. Oda clogs up his panels with too much stuff.
-Originality: AOT. Oda "plagiarizes" a lot of ancient greek writing where Wano's backstory was basically Plato's Atlas which he already used in Skypeia.
-World building: AOT.
-Characterization: AOT.
-Enjoyment: AOT.
Shit on Titan is a bitchass loser with that ending. Game of Thrones was a bitchass loser with their ending and I doubt OP would be shit in the ending. Nobody knows what the ending might be and no one can predict. You could not say regarding Shitgeki no Losjin since the final arc shits on all the earlier ones like Nartoshit. I didn't even understand the ending tbh forget about making sense out of it. One Piece first arc is better than Shit no Fuckjin entirely.
Attack on Titan is by far a better series with a very overhated ending. It's not perfect by any means but I think it's good and is personally a satisfying conclusion for myself.
-Plot: AOT by FAR
-Main characters: AOT by FAR
-Side characters: AOT has far less quantity, but much higher quality with practically no blemishes (cough cough Red Scabbards, etc.)
-Villains: Zeke/Eren shit on any One Piece villain
-Character designs: One Piece
-Power system: One Piece
-Story arcs: Return to Shiganshina, Marley, and War for Paradis shit on like every One Piece arc combined
-Incorporation of themes: AOT, Eren is a perfect embodiment of his "freedom"
-Art: Subjective as hell, I prefer AOT though due to me never fucking struggling to figure out whats going on on a page.
-Imagery: One PIece
-Panelling: AOT. See art.
-Originality: AOT. One Piece follows a lot of general shonen formulas, which not to say Oda ripped anyone off, but when running alongside things like Naruto etc, AOT is far more abstract and a far more unique angle at being a shonen.
-World building: Probably One Piece.
-Characterization: AOT. This is probably the biggest mismatch
-Enjoyment: AOT. Not a single dull moment in the series. Consistently engaging and elite.
Post automatically merged:
-Plot: AOT by FAR
-Main characters: AOT by FAR
-Side characters: AOT has far less quantity, but much higher quality with practically no blemishes (cough cough Red Scabbards, etc.)
-Villains: Zeke/Eren shit on any One Piece villain
-Character designs: One Piece
-Power system: One Piece
-Story arcs: Return to Shiganshina, Marley, and War for Paradis shit on like every One Piece arc combined
-Incorporation of themes: AOT, Eren is a perfect embodiment of his "freedom"
-Art: Subjective as hell, I prefer AOT though due to me never fucking struggling to figure out whats going on on a page.
-Imagery: One PIece
-Panelling: AOT. See art.
-Originality: AOT. One Piece follows a lot of general shonen formulas, which not to say Oda ripped anyone off, but when running alongside things like Naruto etc, AOT is far more abstract and a far more unique angle at being a shonen.
-World building: Probably One Piece.
-Characterization: AOT. This is probably the biggest mismatch
-Enjoyment: AOT. Not a single dull moment in the series. Consistently engaging and elite.
-Plot ---> AoT
-Main characters ---> AoT
-Side characters ---> OP
-Villains ---> AoT
-Character designs ---> AoT
-Power system ---> OP
-Story arcs ---> AoT
-Incorporation of themes ---> AoT
-Art ---> AoT
-Imagery ---> AoT
-Panelling ---> AoT
-Originality ---> AoT
-World building ---> OP
-Characterization ---> AoT
-Enjoyment ---> AoT
One piece hasn't been that good for half of its run, while AoT only goes downill during the last arc.
-Main characters ---> AoT
-Side characters ---> OP
-Villains ---> AoT
-Character designs ---> AoT
-Power system ---> OP
-Story arcs ---> AoT
-Incorporation of themes ---> AoT
-Art ---> AoT
-Imagery ---> AoT
-Panelling ---> AoT
-Originality ---> AoT
-World building ---> OP
-Characterization ---> AoT
-Enjoyment ---> AoT
One piece hasn't been that good for half of its run, while AoT only goes downill during the last arc.
AoT was amazing until alliance shit and then it had one of the worst endings in any media. Even probably worse than GoT.
The ending literally shat on established characters and plot. Now rewatching/rereading every previous good moment feels like shit because knowing where the plot goes down and how shit characters becomes and that all of this was meaningless.
Meanwhile one piece is just there. Nothing special just white bread of manga/anime. It not meant to be written good nor it has any deep characters. Its only strength is an active community and active discussions.
AoT is like eating and enjoying chocolate ice cream, just for the chef to come and tell you that it's frozen shit with bunch of sweet toppings to mask the flavor.
While One Piece is just eating a white bread.
It all depends on whether you can forget that you just ate shit and believe that it was worth it because you enjoyed eating it.
Or that if you enjoy eating white bread.
The ending literally shat on established characters and plot. Now rewatching/rereading every previous good moment feels like shit because knowing where the plot goes down and how shit characters becomes and that all of this was meaningless.
Meanwhile one piece is just there. Nothing special just white bread of manga/anime. It not meant to be written good nor it has any deep characters. Its only strength is an active community and active discussions.
AoT is like eating and enjoying chocolate ice cream, just for the chef to come and tell you that it's frozen shit with bunch of sweet toppings to mask the flavor.
While One Piece is just eating a white bread.
It all depends on whether you can forget that you just ate shit and believe that it was worth it because you enjoyed eating it.
Or that if you enjoy eating white bread.
Last edited:
AoT was amazing until alliance shit and then it had one of the worst endings in any media. Even probably worse than GoT.
The ending literally shat on established characters and plot. Now rewatching/rereading every previous good moment feels like shit because knowing where the plot goes down and how shit characters becomes and that all of this was meaningless.
Meanwhile one piece is just there. Nothing special just white bread of manga/anime. It not meant to be written good nor it has any deep characters. Its only strength is an active community and active discussions.
AoT is like eating and enjoying chocolate ice cream, just for the chef to come and tell you that it's frozen shit with bunch of sweet toppings to mask the flavor.
While One Piece is just eating a white bread.
It all depends on whether you can forget that you just ate shit and believe that it was worth it because you enjoyed eating it.
Or that if you enjoy eating white bread.
The ending literally shat on established characters and plot. Now rewatching/rereading every previous good moment feels like shit because knowing where the plot goes down and how shit characters becomes and that all of this was meaningless.
Meanwhile one piece is just there. Nothing special just white bread of manga/anime. It not meant to be written good nor it has any deep characters. Its only strength is an active community and active discussions.
AoT is like eating and enjoying chocolate ice cream, just for the chef to come and tell you that it's frozen shit with bunch of sweet toppings to mask the flavor.
While One Piece is just eating a white bread.
It all depends on whether you can forget that you just ate shit and believe that it was worth it because you enjoyed eating it.
Or that if you enjoy eating white bread.
It really was gonna go down as the greatest manga to ever do it, Isayama sold in the final hour, hurts.
AoT was amazing until alliance shit and then it had one of the worst endings in any media. Even probably worse than GoT.
The ending literally shat on established characters and plot. Now rewatching/rereading every previous good moment feels like shit because knowing where the plot goes down and how shit characters becomes and that all of this was meaningless.
Meanwhile one piece is just there. Nothing special just white bread of manga/anime. It not meant to be written good nor it has any deep characters. Its only strength is an active community and active discussions.
AoT is like eating and enjoying chocolate ice cream, just for the chef to come and tell you that it's frozen shit with bunch of sweet toppings to mask the flavor.
While One Piece is just eating a white bread.
It all depends on whether you can forget that you just ate shit and believe that it was worth it because you enjoyed eating it.
Or that if you enjoy eating white bread.
The ending literally shat on established characters and plot. Now rewatching/rereading every previous good moment feels like shit because knowing where the plot goes down and how shit characters becomes and that all of this was meaningless.
Meanwhile one piece is just there. Nothing special just white bread of manga/anime. It not meant to be written good nor it has any deep characters. Its only strength is an active community and active discussions.
AoT is like eating and enjoying chocolate ice cream, just for the chef to come and tell you that it's frozen shit with bunch of sweet toppings to mask the flavor.
While One Piece is just eating a white bread.
It all depends on whether you can forget that you just ate shit and believe that it was worth it because you enjoyed eating it.
Or that if you enjoy eating white bread.
Like GOT had 4 amazing first seasons.
i prefer 9/10 for 3/4 of the story and then 2/10 than 5/10 all along