IMPORTANT: THIS TIME THERE WILL BE NO FIGHTS. YOU WILL SIMPLY VOTE FOR YOUR TOP 4 CHOICES HERE. PLEASE TRY TO USE UP ALL 4 VOTES. THANKS.
THE BRACKET
Eren Yeager – Attack on Titan
VS
Kaiki Deishuu – Monogatari
VS
The Death Devil – Chainsaw Man
VS
Hisoka Morow – Hunter x Hunter
VS
King Bradley – Fullmetal Alchemist
VS
Garou – One Punch Man
VS
Uchiha Itachi – Naruto
VS
Chrollo Lucilfer – Hunter x Hunter
THE BRACKET
Eren Yeager – Attack on Titan
Eren Yeager’s transformation from righteous hero to ambiguous antagonist exemplifies the tragedy of an idealist crushed by the weight of history. His passionate fury against Titans begins as survival instinct, but evolves into a grim vision: freedom at any cost. That unyielding drive makes him sympathetic and terrifying, as he becomes willing to sacrifice innocents—blurring moral clarity and compelling the audience to question what heroism really means.
Eren’s growth becomes a metaphor for the corruption of purpose. His hard-earned strength—physical and ideological—leads him down a path where liberation becomes annihilation. By shedding the innocence of youth and claiming god-like power, Eren forces viewers to examine the price of agency: is self-determination worth global devastation? His decline from the embodying hope to catalyzing genocide makes him feel disturbingly real.
Ultimately, Eren remains the axis of the story’s tragic grandeur. His choices fracture alliances and give birth to heated debates about war, memory, and hate. He’s not just a villain—he’s a mirror that reflects humanity’s endless dance with cycles of freedom, vengeance, and unintended atrocity.
Eren’s growth becomes a metaphor for the corruption of purpose. His hard-earned strength—physical and ideological—leads him down a path where liberation becomes annihilation. By shedding the innocence of youth and claiming god-like power, Eren forces viewers to examine the price of agency: is self-determination worth global devastation? His decline from the embodying hope to catalyzing genocide makes him feel disturbingly real.
Ultimately, Eren remains the axis of the story’s tragic grandeur. His choices fracture alliances and give birth to heated debates about war, memory, and hate. He’s not just a villain—he’s a mirror that reflects humanity’s endless dance with cycles of freedom, vengeance, and unintended atrocity.
VS
Kaiki Deishuu – Monogatari
Kaiki stands apart in the Monogatari world as the cynical con man who respects logic more than superstition. He’s not malevolent for its own sake—his scams against apparitions are almost altruistic, fundraising for shrine upkeep or exposing fraud. Yet he works with cold calculation, always thinking two steps ahead of his opponents and never letting sentiment cloud his judgment.
What cements him as exceptional is his purity of perspective: Kaiki sees illusions for what they are and refuses to unsee them. He's the yin to Araragi’s idealist yang. Their ideological clash—faith versus pragmatism—is at the heart of several story arcs, and Kaiki’s moral ambiguity creates literary richness and unpredictability in the narrative.
In stories like Nekomonogatari: White and Owarimonogatari, Kaiki evolves from a reluctant guardian to a true antihero. He makes terrifyingly rational decisions—sometimes cold-blooded—but he does so with motives grounded in honesty and self-preservation, not some grandiose moralizing or melodrama. That unpredictability and unshakable self-interest make him Morally interesting, if not likable.
What cements him as exceptional is his purity of perspective: Kaiki sees illusions for what they are and refuses to unsee them. He's the yin to Araragi’s idealist yang. Their ideological clash—faith versus pragmatism—is at the heart of several story arcs, and Kaiki’s moral ambiguity creates literary richness and unpredictability in the narrative.
In stories like Nekomonogatari: White and Owarimonogatari, Kaiki evolves from a reluctant guardian to a true antihero. He makes terrifyingly rational decisions—sometimes cold-blooded—but he does so with motives grounded in honesty and self-preservation, not some grandiose moralizing or melodrama. That unpredictability and unshakable self-interest make him Morally interesting, if not likable.
VS
The Death Devil – Chainsaw Man
The Death Devil has reached Earth and dramatically reshaped Part 2’s trajectory. Initially, readers assumed the soft-spoken, tearful high school girl was the Death Devil herself, until Chapter 198 flipped the narrative: she is actually the Famine Devil Fami, while the real Death Devil has been among them all along—using Fami’s identity as a cover. This twist reframes every previous interaction as part of a deeper scheme; Death isn’t a looming figure—it’s been walking beside Denji and others under an assumed identity.
What makes the real Death Devil uniquely terrifying is how she marries power with philosophical clarity. She remains calm, unflinching, and dismissive of trivial human concerns, viewing her role to save people from suffering as a genuine good. But this compassionate logic is horrifying when uttered by someone embodying mortality itself. She believes death is the ultimate mercy, and her quiet conviction transforms existential dread into an almost rational doctrine.
The reveal also deepens the horror of her influence: she’s orchestrating the prophecy, psychologically manipulating events through Fami’s earlier chaos and the chainsaw cult. She doesn’t have to shout—her silence and omnipresence convey everything. As the unseen hand steering fate, the Death Devil is not just an antagonist. She is the personification of inevitability, offering death as a reluctant but final kindness. That chilling conviction makes her Part 2’s most philosophically potent villain yet.
What makes the real Death Devil uniquely terrifying is how she marries power with philosophical clarity. She remains calm, unflinching, and dismissive of trivial human concerns, viewing her role to save people from suffering as a genuine good. But this compassionate logic is horrifying when uttered by someone embodying mortality itself. She believes death is the ultimate mercy, and her quiet conviction transforms existential dread into an almost rational doctrine.
The reveal also deepens the horror of her influence: she’s orchestrating the prophecy, psychologically manipulating events through Fami’s earlier chaos and the chainsaw cult. She doesn’t have to shout—her silence and omnipresence convey everything. As the unseen hand steering fate, the Death Devil is not just an antagonist. She is the personification of inevitability, offering death as a reluctant but final kindness. That chilling conviction makes her Part 2’s most philosophically potent villain yet.
VS
Hisoka Morow – Hunter x Hunter
Hisoka Morow is a mesmerizing enigma—an assassin-clown who views fighting as an exquisite dance. His razor-sharp instincts are matched by his flamboyant theatrics, blending unpredictability with elegance. Every duel with Gon, Killua, or Chrollo is less a battle and more a performance art piece, in which he seeks the thrill of conflict more than victory itself. Hisoka is driven by one simple, yet potent obsession: pure potential and raw power.
While his outward showmanship masks a savage core, his own code of honor defines his cruelty. Hisoka spares opponents when they’re strong, but punishes weakness with moral intensity. He predicts others' emotions, manipulating his prey into reaching their limits so he can savor the raw energy of their struggle. His unpredictable alliances—helpful one moment, murderous the next—cast him as neither friend nor foe but as a law unto himself.
What makes Hisoka unforgettable is how he crystallizes contradictions: cultured yet savage, mentor and threat, calm and fevered. His presence challenges the protagonists to question their ideals and strength. In Hisoka, we see that a villain can be both a teacher and a predator, a source of inspiration and terror—an immortal blend of elegance, cruelty, and performative grace.
While his outward showmanship masks a savage core, his own code of honor defines his cruelty. Hisoka spares opponents when they’re strong, but punishes weakness with moral intensity. He predicts others' emotions, manipulating his prey into reaching their limits so he can savor the raw energy of their struggle. His unpredictable alliances—helpful one moment, murderous the next—cast him as neither friend nor foe but as a law unto himself.
What makes Hisoka unforgettable is how he crystallizes contradictions: cultured yet savage, mentor and threat, calm and fevered. His presence challenges the protagonists to question their ideals and strength. In Hisoka, we see that a villain can be both a teacher and a predator, a source of inspiration and terror—an immortal blend of elegance, cruelty, and performative grace.
VS
King Bradley – Fullmetal Alchemist
King Bradley, also known as Wrath, is a villain who embodies control, discipline, and sheer lethal precision. As both a national leader and a homunculus, he walks the line between civility and slaughter, presenting a calm face while being capable of unimaginable violence. His role as Führer allows him to orchestrate entire wars while remaining completely in command of every battlefield he personally enters.
Unlike the other homunculi, Bradley ages, bleeds, and fights with the mind of a soldier rather than a monster. He believes in strength and purpose—disregarding weakness, mercy, or ideology. His respect for opponents like Greed or Buccaneer doesn’t stem from empathy but from a deep appreciation of resolve and strength under pressure.
Bradley is not fueled by passion or chaos. He is terrifying because of how measured he is. His presence is a reminder that evil doesn’t always arrive loudly—it can walk quietly in uniform, speak eloquently, and strike with cold finality.
Unlike the other homunculi, Bradley ages, bleeds, and fights with the mind of a soldier rather than a monster. He believes in strength and purpose—disregarding weakness, mercy, or ideology. His respect for opponents like Greed or Buccaneer doesn’t stem from empathy but from a deep appreciation of resolve and strength under pressure.
Bradley is not fueled by passion or chaos. He is terrifying because of how measured he is. His presence is a reminder that evil doesn’t always arrive loudly—it can walk quietly in uniform, speak eloquently, and strike with cold finality.
VS
Garou – One Punch Man
Garou is heroism corrupted by foresight. He styles himself the Hero Hunter to expose heroism’s hypocrisies and dismantle its façade. He targets strong heroes to test strength, not ideals—believing that power matters more than philosophy in a stagnant society.
He evolves from punching bags into mythic monster. His form transitions reflect his ideology: human anger swelling into physical threat. His transformation is both literal and metaphorical, underlining the pain of possessing truth without finding balance.
Garou is both villain and teacher. He forces society to reckon with its own prejudices—challenging heroes and citizens alike. His metamorphosis into monster is not folly, but spotlight: showing what happens when critique becomes vengeance.
He evolves from punching bags into mythic monster. His form transitions reflect his ideology: human anger swelling into physical threat. His transformation is both literal and metaphorical, underlining the pain of possessing truth without finding balance.
Garou is both villain and teacher. He forces society to reckon with its own prejudices—challenging heroes and citizens alike. His metamorphosis into monster is not folly, but spotlight: showing what happens when critique becomes vengeance.
VS
Uchiha Itachi – Naruto
Itachi Uchiha is sacrifice sealed with silenced screams. Responsible for genocide, he wears guilt as his shroud. His eyes, once blazing with pride, dim with sorrow. He walks as a symbol of unforgivable atrocity, yet every act is measured, weighed against a greater peace.
He manipulates Sasuke’s pain to deflect war. He endures betrayal, hatred, and torture to shield Konoha. Even his death is choreographed—to keep brother safe, enemy fooled, war contained. His actions aren’t redemption—they’re absolution offered through annihilation.
Itachi’s story compels us to ask: how heavy must love be to bury genocide? He remains a question every hero asks in future: what is too much to bear for peace?
He manipulates Sasuke’s pain to deflect war. He endures betrayal, hatred, and torture to shield Konoha. Even his death is choreographed—to keep brother safe, enemy fooled, war contained. His actions aren’t redemption—they’re absolution offered through annihilation.
Itachi’s story compels us to ask: how heavy must love be to bury genocide? He remains a question every hero asks in future: what is too much to bear for peace?
VS
Chrollo Lucilfer – Hunter x Hunter
Chrollo Lucilfer is the calm and collected leader of the Phantom Troupe, a group of thieves known for their ruthlessness and bloody reputation. What makes Chrollo so captivating is his unsettling calmness and his almost philosophical approach to life and death. Unlike many villains driven by emotion, Chrollo remains stoic and unemotional, making his decisions with a level of detached reason.
His greatest strength lies in his intelligence and strategic mind, making him a formidable foe even without brute force. His Stand, Skill Hunter, allows him to steal other Nen abilities, which only increases his versatility and danger. Chrollo is an enigma—a man who values freedom above all and will go to any lengths to achieve it.
Chrollo’s blend of intelligence, charm, and ruthlessness makes him a villain who is both calculated and unpredictable. His calm demeanor masks a terrifying potential for violence, and it’s this duality that makes him one of Hunter x Hunter's most intriguing and dangerous figures.
His greatest strength lies in his intelligence and strategic mind, making him a formidable foe even without brute force. His Stand, Skill Hunter, allows him to steal other Nen abilities, which only increases his versatility and danger. Chrollo is an enigma—a man who values freedom above all and will go to any lengths to achieve it.
Chrollo’s blend of intelligence, charm, and ruthlessness makes him a villain who is both calculated and unpredictable. His calm demeanor masks a terrifying potential for violence, and it’s this duality that makes him one of Hunter x Hunter's most intriguing and dangerous figures.
