Character Discussion Faves in these categories.

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
β€Ž
#2
Yonkou: Whitebeard
Admiral: Kizaru
Shichibukai: Mihawk
Commander: Goatakuri
Worst gen: Law or Zoro
Vice Admiral: Smoker
Villain: Crocodile
Ally: Wyper
DF power: Hie Hie no mi
Character design: Katakuri
Female: Nami
Attack/move: Ice Time 😎
 

Light D Lamperouge

𝕴𝖓 π•Ώπ–π–Žπ–˜ 𝖂𝖔𝖗𝖑𝖉 π•Ίπ–“π–‘π–ž 𝕴 𝖆𝖒 π•Άπ–Žπ–“π–Œ
β€Ž
#3
Shanks.

Kuzan. If he doesn't count Kizaru then.

Mihawk.

King.

Zoro.

No idea really. Let's say Smoker. And Garp. Garp >Smoker tho but then I'd have to say Smoker for fave marine lol.

Kuzan. If he doesn't count Kizaru. If he doesn't count either Garp.

Sir Crocodile.

Rayleigh/Law.

Never really thought about it.

Mihawk, Crocodile, Doffy, King. Sera kids like S Hawk, S Crocodile, S Flamingo. I know the stipulations say not to use the same chars, but no one else comes to mind right now.


Perona.


No idea.
 
Last edited:
K

Kotone

#5
Yonkou: Shanks
Admiral: Aokiji / Kizaru
Schichibukai: Boa
Commander: Kat
Worst gen: Zoro
Vice Admiral: Hina ??? If she is one
Marine: Aokiji / Kizaru
Villain: Rob
Ally: Ray
DF power: Lighting Light Ice
Character design: Sanji
Female: Nami
Attack/move: don't have one
 
#6
Who's your fave in all these different categories.

Yonkou:
Admiral:
Schichibukai:
Commander:
Worst gen:
Vice Admiral:
Marine:
Villain:
Ally:
DF power:
Character design:
Female:
Attack/move:

Note: don't use the same character in more than one category.
Yonko: Buggy
Admiral: Ryokugyu
Schichibukai: Crocodile
Commander: Sanji
Worst Gen: Zoro
Vice Admiral: Smoker
Marine: Belle-Mere, I’m counting her
Villain: With Crocodile out, Enel
Ally: Momo
DF Power: Yami Yami no Mi
Character Design: Named a bunch of my faves, so probably Doffy next
Female: Nico Robin
Attack/Move: NA

Edit Didn’t read no duplicates
 
Last edited:

TheAncientGorosei

I will never forgive Oda
β€Žβ€Žβ€Ž
#7
Note: don't use the same character in more than one category.
That's gonna make certain categories difficult.

Yonkou: They're all pretty shit, but Kaido.
Admiral: Easily Borsalino
Schichibukai: Donquixote Doflamingo
Commander: King the Wildfire
Worst gen: X Drake
Vice Admiral: Vergo-san
Marine: This is where it gets tricky, I named my favorite three marines already. Maybe Greenbull?
Villain: Sir Crocodile. I urge everyone to reread the Alabasta arc, he's a master class antagonist.
Ally: Trafalgar D. Law
DF power: Normally it'd be the Suna Suna no Mi, but with that gone, I gotta go with Enel's Goro Goro no Mi.
Character design: Normally would be King, then Drake, then Crocodile, then Doflamingo, then Borsalino, so... Fujitora?
Female: Ulti, hands down. Most other girls in the manga are not good. She's a rare exception.
Attack/move: This category is impossible this far down lol. I already listed most of my favorites. Venom Demon from Magellan?
 
#8
That's gonna make certain categories difficult.

Yonkou: They're all pretty shit, but Kaido.
Admiral: Easily Borsalino
Schichibukai: Donquixote Doflamingo
Commander: King the Wildfire
Worst gen: X Drake
Vice Admiral: Vergo-san
Marine: This is where it gets tricky, I named my favorite three marines already. Maybe Greenbull?
Villain: Sir Crocodile. I urge everyone to reread the Alabasta arc, he's a master class antagonist.
Ally: Trafalgar D. Law
DF power: Normally it'd be the Suna Suna no Mi, but with that gone, I gotta go with Enel's Goro Goro no Mi.
Character design: Normally would be King, then Drake, then Crocodile, then Doflamingo, then Borsalino, so... Fujitora?
Female: Ulti, hands down. Most other girls in the manga are not good. She's a rare exception.
Attack/move: This category is impossible this far down lol. I already listed most of my favorites. Venom Demon from Magellan?
Reread Alabasta shortly after Cross Guild reveal, and crocodile really is the best villain oda has ever written and if op hasn’t been so long and bogged down with shitty villains, Croc would be in the same conversation for great villains as Pain and Aizen.
 

TheAncientGorosei

I will never forgive Oda
β€Žβ€Žβ€Ž
#9
Reread Alabasta shortly after Cross Guild reveal, and crocodile really is the best villain oda has ever written and if op hasn’t been so long and bogged down with shitty villains, Croc would be in the same conversation for great villains as Pain and Aizen.
i don't think Aizen is a good villain lol. I'd put him below most OP arc antagonists, personally.

But I fully agree. Sir Crocodile's delightfully malevolent and keenly intelligent. The overconfidence he exudes is well entitled to him, considering how many contingencies he has + the raw power he had compared to the Straw Hats or Marines. Oda hasn't touched Sir Croc once since Alabasta, though Enel came close.
 
#10
i don't think Aizen is a good villain lol. I'd put him below most OP arc antagonists, personally.

But I fully agree. Sir Crocodile's delightfully malevolent and keenly intelligent. The overconfidence he exudes is well entitled to him, considering how many contingencies he has + the raw power he had compared to the Straw Hats or Marines. Oda hasn't touched Sir Croc once since Alabasta, though Enel came close.
And not just the contingencies but the pure maliciousness of it all without looking cartoonishly evil.

Croc destroying Yuba mid fight with Luffy was brutal and showed just how little Luffy actually registered to him and the silhouette of luffys body impaled by Crocs hook was insanely brutal.
 
#12
Yonkou: Shanks
Admiral: Fujitora (and Kuzan)
Schichibukai: Mihawk
Commander: Zoro
Worst gen: Zoro and Law
Vice Admiral: Smoker
Marine: Fuji and Smoker
Villain: Crocodile
Ally: Law and Wyper
DF power: Zushi Zushi no mi
Character design: Mihawk
Female: Robin
Attack/move: happiness punch
 
#13
Yonkou: Blackbeard
Admiral: Aokiji
Shichibukai: Doflamingo
Commander: Smoothie
Worst gen: Zoro
Vice Admiral: Garp
Marine: Shu
Villain: Black Maria
Ally: Ichiji
DF power: Clear-Clear Fruit (Absalom, Shiryu)
Character design: Yamato
Female: York
Attack/move: Desert la Spada
 
Last edited:
#14
Yonkou: Kaido
Admiral: Aokiji/Akainu
Schichibukai: Law
Commander: King
Worst gen: Luffy/Law
Vice Admiral: Momonga
Marine: Aokiji
Villain: Kaido/Enel
Ally:
DF power: Fuwa Fuwa no mi (Shiki's fruit) ; Enel's fruit is a close second
Character design: Kaido/King
Female: Ulti/Yamato
Attack/move: Law's Moveset/Shiki's Shishi Odoshi: Chimaki.
 
#16
Yonkou: Blackbeard
Admiral: Akainu
Schichibukai: Kuma (pre ts at least)
Commander: Beckman
Worst gen: Drake
Vice Admiral: Smoker
Marine: Vergo
Villain: Crocodile
Ally: Law
DF power: ice logia
Character design: Shiryu
Female: Hina
Attack/move: Ursus Shock
 
#17
Yonkou: BB or Buggy
Admiral: Kizaru
Schichibukai: DD pre TS
Commander: Katakuri
Worst gen: Law
Vice Admiral: Vergo
Marine: Sengoku
Villain: Crocodile
Ally: Gaimon
DF power: Dark Dark/Pika Pika
Character design: Fuji
Female: Robin pre TS
Attack/move: Room
 
Last edited:
#18
Yonkou: Shanks
Admiral: Aokiji
Schichibukai: Crocodile
Commander: Katakuri
Worst gen: Urouge
Vice Admiral: Bastille(looks cool, is shit tho)
Marine: Garp
Villain: Cesar
Ally: Kyros
DF power: Jackt Jacket (too silly)
Character design: Yamato
Female: Nami
Attack/move: Gomu Gatling and variants
 
#19
Yonkou: Luffy
Admiral: Kizaru
Schichibukai: Kuma
Commander: Katakuri
Worst gen: Zoro
Vice Admiral: Smoker
Marine: Koby
Villain: Katakuri
Ally: Carrot
DF power: Pika Pika no mi
Character design: Gol D Roger
Female: Nami
Attack/move: Gomu Gomu no Boh
 
#20
Yonkou: WB
Admiral: Aramaki
Shichibukai: Mihawk
Worst gen: Drake
Vice Admiral: Vergo
Marine: Akainu
Villain: Doffy
Ally: Kyros
DF power: Ope2
Character design: Takanome
Female: Perona
 
Top