General & Others Fishman Island Vs Punk Hazard Which Arc Is Better?

[kumae]

I don't know wich one to choose for me they are the best post TS arcs And i rate them as 9/10 compare it to now lol both had a good story and they kept pre TS vibes nami got a lot of relevance in both arcs and we got zotash in PH

 

[Don Diego]

i bet on fishman island

 

[pg13]

I don't know wich one to choose for me they are the best post TS arcs And i rate them as 9/10 compare it to now lol both had a good story and they kept pre TS vibes nami got a lot of relevance in both arcs and we got zotash in PH

How are they the best?

 

[BlackLegFring]

The Fishmen Island flashback was the best part of either arc, but overall PH was better.
- Setup the conflict with Doffy, one of the best antagonists in the story.
- Had interesting non-Strawhat interactions (Law, Smoker & Vergo).

A lot of FI was more of the same, but less than average. PH on the other hand provided a different dynamic.

 

[roronoa_fan]

To this day, I still don't know what the point of Punk Hazard was.

Lol, PH just defined almost everything from Dressrosa to Wano

 

[MagnetoEustassKidd]

Poll

looks like a reddit poll. Fishman Island is Better. Punkhazard was so boring. Zoro fighting a dragon, strawhats being chased by some goo monster. Zoro fighting monet. It all felt like filler.
[automerge]1682182468[/automerge]

The Fishmen Island flashback was the best part of either arc, but overall PH was better.
- Setup the conflict with Doffy, one of the best antagonists in the story.
- Had interesting non-Strawhat interactions (Law, Smoker & Vergo).

A lot of FI was more of the same, but less than average. PH on the other hand provided a different dynamic.

Delusional.

 

[kumae]

How are they the best?

Because in dressrosa started the downfall and those arcs have very good things and as i said are the only ones who gives pre TS vibes

 

[Don Diego]

The Fishmen Island flashback was the best part of either arc, but overall PH was better.
- Setup the conflict with Doffy, one of the best antagonists in the story.
- Had interesting non-Strawhat interactions (Law, Smoker & Vergo).

A lot of FI was more of the same, but less than average. PH on the other hand provided a different dynamic.

imho Fishman island flashback are the best part of all post Time skip events

 

[BlackLegFring]

imho Fishman island flashback are the best part of all post Time skip events

I personally like the Law/Corazon flashback and Reverie more (before Oda’s failure to deliver on events), but I totally get it.
[automerge]1682183757[/automerge]

looks like a reddit poll. Fishman Island is Better. Punkhazard was so boring. Zoro fighting a dragon, strawhats being chased by some goo monster. Zoro fighting monet. It all felt like filler.
[automerge]1682182468[/automerge]


Delusional.

What’s delusional about the comment?

 

[lee33]

Lol, PH just defined almost everything from Dressrosa to Wano

Like I said, I still have no idea what the point of PH was. SMILEs? Gigantification? Underground world? Ceaser? What has those subplots lead to? You need 50 chapters to do that? Other mangas literally have sagas end in 50 chapters. Pointless arc. Make your alliance with Law and move on but in typical Oda fashion he needs to add 90% filler.

 

[pg13]

Like I said, I still have no idea what the point of PH was. SMILEs? Gigantification? Underground world? Ceaser? What has those subplots lead to? You need 50 chapters to do that? Other mangas literally have sagas end in 50 chapters. Pointless arc. Make your alliance with Law and move on but in typical Oda fashion he needs to add 90% filler.

Punk Hazard and Dressrosa definitely could've been condensed to just 1 arc tbh

 

[straightforward]

fishman island had: pretty mermaids, a unique and funny minor villain in van der decken, goddess shyarly, chad fisher tiger, eye-candy marine setting, robin calling winbe a handsome man, big ship/poneglyph lore

PH had: jobber smoker, whinging 'giant' children, a pedo chicken to please the furries and a body-swap gimmick to compensate for the lack of actual humor (courtesy to the emo wanker law)


FI>>>>>>>PH