Versus Battle Geralt of Rivia (The Witcher) vs Aragorn (LOTR)

[RayanOO]

Here Geralt from the Witcher Show will fight Aragorn from LOTR movies.

No MAGIC ! Only a sword fight. Aragorn has Anduril and Geralt his big sword. Traditional gear/armor for both.
Let’s go.

@Zara @Natalija @Bango🍅 @Fruitji @TheAncientCenturion @DynaMight @Cross_Marian @Flower @Xlaw @MugiwaraMaster @Sentinel @Seth @Sakazuki-Singh etc

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

And a little musical theme to think about this fight

 

[Adam 🍎]

I think even TV show Geralt is better

Not only is Geralt super human he is also a trained killer whos job is to hunt things far more scary than humans or orcs

 

[HA001]

Geralt wins

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Both are top tier super humans. Aragorn can run for what, days without getting winded? He’s able to take on multiple Urukai. Meanwhile Geralt’s several times faster and stronger than a normal human being.

If it was straight swords, I think Aragorn would edge it out. But Geralt has access to tangible magic to make this easier. A few well placed signs and he’ll take Aragorn by surprise.

 

[Sakazuki-Singh]

Only played Witcher 3 and watched the LOTR trilogy

I'd say Geralt

 

[RayanOO]

If it was straight swords, I think Aragorn would edge it out. But Geralt has access to tangible magic to make this easier. A few well placed signs and he’ll take Aragorn by surprise.

No MAGIC ! Only a sword fight.

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Not a fan of either but from what I've seen, geralt wins this, mid diff in the worst case even with that scenario

 

[HA001]

Both are top tier super humans. Aragorn can run for what, days without getting winded? He’s able to take on multiple Urukai. Meanwhile Geralt’s several times faster and stronger than a normal human being.

If it was straight swords, I think Aragorn would edge it out. But Geralt has access to tangible magic to make this easier. A few well placed signs and he’ll take Aragorn by surprise.

Gaunter solos

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Gaunter solos

He’s the devil so ofc

 

[HA001]

He’s the devil so ofc

G O D

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Aragorn without magic

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

G O D

And he’s the man of mirrors, what’s the reflection of GOD?

 

[Cross_Marian]

It’s a pretty even match. Both are superhuman and both have a lot of experience.
Aragorn is a better leader, grew up with Elves and trained with them. The blood of Numenor is also strong within Aragorn.
Geralt is more the solo type, is a mutant, was trained by Vesemir and fought against a lot of monsters.
I still think that Aragorn is the better swordsman, so I go with him

 

[Jaguark101]

Straight up sword duel? then Aragorn takes it JUST barely though. He has fought off ringwraiths, Uruk hai etc. and he doesn't need special potions or spells to do it. That being said Geralt is no slouch either.

 

[HA001]

It’s a pretty even match. Both are superhuman and both have a lot of experience.
Aragorn is a better leader, grew up with Elves and trained with them. The blood of Numenor is also strong within Aragorn.
Geralt is more the solo type, is a mutant, was trained by Vesemir and fought against a lot of monsters.
I still think that Aragorn is the better swordsman, so I go with him

Spoiler

rip vesemir

 

[Adam 🍎]

I just don't see how Wraiths or Uruk are worse than all the monsters Geralt fought pre show plot.

Spoilers

Spoiler: 123

Pre Show Geralt was already a monster of a fighter and a renowned monster slayer. In his training days Geralt was said to be one of the best witchers to ever go through witcher school. Likewise genetical mutation was stronger with Geralt so he is stronger than normal Witchers too. On top of that Geralt was fighting Leshens, Vampires, Gyrphons and much worse since kid days.

Aragorn on other hand was almost killed by a troll in 2 hits wheres Geralt was killing trolls for years before the show plot

 

[Formerly Seth]

Both are top tier super humans. Aragorn can run for what, days without getting winded? He’s able to take on multiple Urukai. Meanwhile Geralt’s several times faster and stronger than a normal human being.

If it was straight swords, I think Aragorn would edge it out. But Geralt has access to tangible magic to make this easier. A few well placed signs and he’ll take Aragorn by surprise.

Do you think Aragorn would be vulnerable to Geralt's magic? Yrden for example.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Do you think Aragorn would be vulnerable to Geralt's magic? Yrden for example.

If it works via attacking the will/mind of the opponent, Aragorn in this case, no. Aragorn was able to shit talk Sauron via the palantir, a mentally grueling experience for anyone.

 

[Formerly Seth]

Still, overall I think Geralt takes this. Even if Yrden won't work he has Igni to put up a fire, Quen for defensive purposes, and also Aard which is capable of throwing people even as strong as Aragorn off balance.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Still, overall I think Geralt takes this. Even if Yrden won't work he has Igni to put up a fire, Quen for defensive purposes, and also Aard which is capable of throwing people even as strong as Aragorn off balance.

There's no magic in this fight

 

[NAMELESS]

If Alchemy and Magic is allowed,Geralt wins this easily!Base Geralt(no buffs or magic) vs Aragorn is more fair,but i still think Geralt takes this because of his experience:raised since his early days to be a killer!Aragorn is a good fighter with a lot of experience too,but considering that Geralt kills things way more dangerous than Orcs,i would say its clear that Geralt is the superior fighter!

Post automatically merged: Aug 24, 2021

But of course it would be no easy fight,Aragorn is strong too!Geralt wins high diff!