Questions & Mysteries How The Fuck Did Shanks End Up With Roger

[SakazOuki]

So Garling was the boss of God Valley at the time, naturally he would fight with Garp and Roger against Xebec
Somehow after the battle baby Shanks ends up with Roger


-Did Roger kidnap Shanks while Garp and Garling were engaged with Xebec
-Was Garling knocked out cold and couldn't retrieve his son
-Was it Shanks' mother who decided to leave her son for the wolves
-Did Shanks have a birth defect that deemed him incompetent for the mighty respectful Figarland family
-Did Garling at any point try to negotiate/ battle Roger for his son

Too many questions

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Rayleigh handled Shanks' old man

 

[Wh1p]

 

[Etzel Andergast]

So Garling was the boss of God Valley at the time, naturally he would fight with Garp and Roger against Xebec
Somehow after the battle baby Shanks ends up with Roger


-Did Roger kidnap Shanks while Garp and Garling were engaged with Xebec
-Was Garling knocked out cold and couldn't retrieve his son
-Was it Shanks' mother who decided to leave her son for the wolves
-Did Shanks have a birth defect that deemed him incompetent for the mighty respectful Figarland family
-Did Garling at any point try to negotiate/ battle Roger for his son

Too many questions

Garp and Roger vs Xebec
Garling vs Whitebeard

 

[GrandmasterChef Zonji]

So Garling was the boss of God Valley at the time, naturally he would fight with Garp and Roger against Xebec
Somehow after the battle baby Shanks ends up with Roger


-Did Roger kidnap Shanks while Garp and Garling were engaged with Xebec
-Was Garling knocked out cold and couldn't retrieve his son
-Was it Shanks' mother who decided to leave her son for the wolves
-Did Shanks have a birth defect that deemed him incompetent for the mighty respectful Figarland family
-Did Garling at any point try to negotiate/ battle Roger for his son

Too many questions

a Cliche Story tbh
- Rocks Pirates coming
- Garling Tried to fight and Loses
- Shanks Mom put him to Treasure Chest in hoping he is safe or someone find him and save him
- Roger, Garp, Ray and others came and defeat Rocks crew
- Because Roger didn't want to become a Hero, Garp let him take the Treasure Chest or They robbed the Treasure and then Leave
- And Boom when they open the Chest while on the Sea, They Saw baby Shanks

 

[Yoho]

The Roger pirates grabbed a treasure chest and he was inside

So basically kidnapping

 

[centurion]

The Roger pirates grabbed a treasure chest and he was inside

So basically kidnapping

The looks on their faces when they discovered him inside the chest say otherwise.

They were shocked/surprised, implying that they didn’t expect a baby inside that chest they stole.

 

[IsaziSempi]

I guess God valley was an important kingdom. Funny because nobody's ever mentioned it in the story. It was probably Garlings kingdom. I'll guess it right now though. Xebeck was Shanks uncle and Garl8ng was his brother. Or maybe his friend.

 

[Yoho]

The looks on their faces when they discovered him inside the chest say otherwise.

They were shocked/surprised, implying that they didn’t expect a baby inside that chest they stole.

True but they also didn't bring him back it may of been inadvertently but a kidnapping is a kidnapping

 

[silverfire]

This is canon to me.

 

[Wh1p]

The looks on their faces when they discovered him inside the chest say otherwise.

They were shocked/surprised, implying that they didn’t expect a baby inside that chest they stole.

Seems to me like due to the crisis at God Valley they (one of the Figarlands) decided to put Shanks in a treasure chest knowing it would get taken.