How we gonna decide the debate winners

[ShishioIsBack]

To Moderators
Did yall like the idea of a proper 1v1 debate
Would more people be interested

And how are we gonna decide the winner?

@Jiihad
@Yoho
@TheAncientCenturion
@Philosoraptor

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Going off Narutobase rules, those who organize the debate should look for 3 impartial judges.

After each debater gets two or three posts in a piece, the judges will analyze the arguments and say who made a more convincing case. Not always who they think would win, but who presented their arguments better, which debater successfully painted a picture of why character X can beat character Y.

 

[ShishioIsBack]

Going off Narutobase rules, those who organize the debate should look for 3 impartial judges.

After each debater gets two or three posts in a piece, the judges will analyze the arguments and say who made a more convincing case. Not always who they think would win, but who presented their arguments better, which debater successfully painted a picture of why character X can beat character Y.

Okay can yall select judges?

I recommend
@Sentinel
@MonsterKaido
@MarineHQ

They seem pretty impartial
If they are willing to judge that is

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Okay can yall select judges?

I recommend
@Sentinel
@MonsterKaido
@MarineHQ

They seem pretty impartial
If they are willing to judge that is

I can judge if you trust me

 

[ShishioIsBack]

I can judge if you trust me

Sure you can be one of the recommendations too

In the end its up to @Jiihad and @TheAncientCenturion

And obviously @Yoho can recommend some too

 

[Yoho]

Sure you can be one of the recommendations too

In the end its up to @Jiihad and @TheAncientCenturion

And obviously @Yoho can recommend some too

I haven't been here that long so I'm not sure whose 100% impartial

 

[Cruxroux]

I haven't been here that long so I'm not sure whose 100% impartial

Me bitches

 

[Jaguark101]

I'll be a judge

 

[ShishioIsBack]

I haven't been here that long so I'm not sure whose 100% impartial

The ones who are mentioned aren't exactly partial towards either Luffy or Zoro and think Luffy wins anyways.

 

[Jiihad]

I’d say:

@Gol D. Roger @MarineHQ off tha top of my head for judges

Also, my b. Haven’t had time to read through all tha responses. Gimme like a day or two

 

[Cruxroux]

The ones who are mentioned aren't exactly partial towards either Luffy or Zoro and think Luffy wins anyways.

Lemme balance the equation .

 

[AL sama]

I’d say:

@Gol D. Roger @MarineHQ off tha top of my head for judges

Also, my b. Haven’t had time to read through all tha responses. Gimme like a day or two

I think roger is pretty busy

 

[GUI VI]

I'm available. I'm probably one of the most imparcial(no adudes um the forum.

 

[Jiihad]

I think roger is pretty busy

Did he say that? Feel like I ain’t seen homie in a minute lol

 

[matt245]

I'd recommend myself as an impartial judge.

 

[AL sama]

Did he say that? Feel like I ain’t seen homie in a minute lol

yeah he has been like that for a while now

 

[Kiiro]

Impartial.... only those who aren't One Oiece fans, each of them have their own arguments

 

[matt245]

Impartial.... only those who aren't One Oiece fans, each of them have their own arguments

Finding a non One Piece fan in a One Piece forum is a borderline impossible task

 

[Zolo]

Only truthers can judge