Questions & Mysteries If you had the opportunity to dictate the next arc or write it even, what would you want to see?

Kizaruber Eats

Awkwardly existing in a world of chaos.
โ€Ž
#1
Just humour me on this, if you could dictate what the next arc of one piece is, either Oda letting you choose what it should be about or influencing/bribing him or even being allowed to write it yourself somehow, what would you like the arc to be about?

I'd really love to see a wild west arc desperately with a real Texan vibe too naturally. Gunslingers, strong gunslingers and thus haki usage and devil fruit with gunslinging combinations too.

I'd tie this into sniper island too as a connected island naturally specialising in snipers and connect it to daddy materson,yasopp, hibari, van Auger etc somehow.

I would have made it Shanks personal territory with him and his crew being te sheriff, deputy and enforcers or whatever.

I would have had the orange admiral debut from here, a martial artist and gunslinger who can fight both in close and far range easily but prefers long range too.
I would have made their justice either wild/chaotic justice, retributive justice, hunting justice or lawful justice (as in relying on trials and maybe juries or something and doung executions frequently as needed).

This would have been an Usopp and franky specialist arc but I'd make it Sanjis too a little, as he was meant to be a gunslinger too originally and somehow some shine for the other SHs especially Brook and Robin.

I would have had zoro and sanji improving their mobility and ranged attacks respectively, usopp learning to use guns even non lethally and franky getting to use Cannons on himself as upgrades/new weapons.

I'd love to see gunslinging cowgirls nami and Robin, Robins devil fruit would go INSANE with gun spamming and easily reloading rapidly and burst firing too.
But her and nami have insane potential for sniping too.
Although I really wanna see nami rock a shotgun too.

I'd probably give the SHs some kind of specialist, less lethal guns that synergies with their fighting styles like absorbing and shooting electricity, fire, ice or even compressed sound waves for example.

I'd explore what justice really means especially in regards to Marines but also pirates (bandits) and civilians. Honour, duelling etc.

Alternatively I'd have this territory be where the RHP faces the BBP, Shanks vs blackbeard in a fight to the death but I'd make at least jozu be present too and ideally izo if he wasn't dead too ofc sigh lol.

I'd rope in capone, apoo, Kidd too somehow potentially.

Another alternative idea is to make it specifically a Marine location for training their firearms users and potential vice Admirals and Admirals too or something.

Just throwing out ideas anyway. The wild west theme is the most important part to me, the absolute constant I need regardless.

Oda had his wild west one shot manga called Wanted too and I'd also be inspired by Trigun, Cowboy Bebop, Part 7 of Jojo, Black Lagoon for this but also obviously wild west films and series especially clint Eastwood and john wayne.
 

Yoho

โœŒ๐“ฃ๐“ฑ๐“ฎ ๐“ข๐“ฒ๐“ถ๐“น๐“ต๐“ฒ๐“ฌ๐“ฒ๐“ฝ๐”‚ ๐“ธ๐“ฏ ๐“›๐“ฒ๐“ฏ๐“ฎโœŒ
โ€Ž
#2
I'd love to see steam punk elements automatons, inventions ran on steam, a steam punk setting with a noir detective plot
 

TheKnightOfTheSea

๐•ท๐–”๐–—๐–‰ ๐–”๐–‹ ๐•ธ๐–”๐–”๐–“'๐–˜ ๐•พ๐–•๐–†๐–œ๐–“
โ€Ž
#3
I would love an underworld arc that focuses on the Red Hair Pirates, Revolutionary Army, Blackbeard Pirates, and features some zodiac va's and holy knights lead by a Gorosei as the "main villains". Have factions that have never really interacted like the RHPs and RA interact.

introduce the unknown figure in the OP candidate spread
 

Kizaruber Eats

Awkwardly existing in a world of chaos.
โ€Ž
#4
I'd love to see steam punk elements automatons, inventions ran on steam, a steam punk setting with a noir detective plot
Oh dude I'd love a steampunk arc! I thought vegapunk might be steampunk too hence the "punk" too ofc! Would fit the one piece world extremely well and the revolutionaries do have the steampunk aesthetic!

A noir detective plot?! Oh I'd love that so fucking much! I'd be salivating! Imagine Oda doing his own bizarre, goofy take on sherlock Holmes but steampunk and having to deal with Luffy? Lmfao.

There's so much that can be done with this and Emeth screamed steampunk too! We have the sea trains and "colapunk" too with franky lmao.

I would love an underworld arc that focuses on the Red Hair Pirates, Revolutionary Army, Blackbeard Pirates, and features some zodiac va's and holy knights lead by a Gorosei as the "main villains". Have factions that have never really interacted like the RHPs and RA interact.

introduce the unknown figure in the OP candidate spread
YES! I've been hoping for an underworld arc since the brokers at punk hazard and the underworld leaders at wci ofc! Huge potential there and crocodile, jinbei, franky, Robin, nami, buggy etc would shine in an arc like that too.

I remember king and queen talking about meeting a replacement for Joker too.

That would be a great way to introduce black horse, kuro whatever his name is and other zodiac VAs as you said ofc!

This would be perfect for the BBP and revolutionaries too AND @Paperchampion23 's dirty/yakuza god Shanks theory too!

These are really great ideas already guys, tyvm for responding and sharing! I'm very hyped already now!

I'd also love a more celtic, forest, fairy themed arc, a wizard of Oz with emerald city arc, another underwater and sky island arcs etc.
 
#5
Gaban's return and for us to learn about the egg on Roger's ship. Also the weaker SHs finally getting some upgrades
Also want to see a little elaboration on the BBP and Revolutionaries, like their backstories, powers, and some of their feats (even if it's just showing something like Burgess and Lafitte trashing random WBP affiliates and/or taking Devil Fruits from them)
 
#6
Its stupid to think about this.
I read the story someone else is telling. Its not my story, so I do not get to choose. I only get to read it.
I can only tell you what I wish to know. And hopefully soon.

What happened during the VC and why did it happen.
 
#9
An all out war/battle royal between the Emperors-Navy & WG-RA.
This I wanted this in Elbaf with Norse having 9 worlds. = 9 Major battles.
- Revolutionary (Sabo , Dragon)
- Marines (Akainu , Aramaki , Fujitora)
- WG (Garling , Nasujuro, Mars , Warcury , Jupiter)
- Pirates (Luffy , Zoro , Law , Kidd , Mihawk , Crocodile , Blackbeard , Shanks)

- Luffy vs Akainu (Luffy looses Akainu awakens)
- Blackbeard vs Shanks (Shanks dies)
- Zoro vs Nasujuro (Zoro wins)
- Aramaki vs Crocodile (Draws)
- Mihawk vs Fujitora (Mihawk)
- Sabo vs Warcury (Draws)
- Dragon vs Garling (Dragon)
- Law vs Marcus (Law)
- Kidd vs Jupiter (Kidd)

Luffy vs Akainu and Dragon vs Garling can be Interchangable.
Luffy vs Garling (Sun being eaten by Wolf norse reference)
Dragon vs Akainu (Legendary awaited Battle)

Everyone throw in hands and in the end Akainu Awakens and "Surtur" parallel , Destroys Entirety of Elbaf.

- Apart from this , I wanted to new crew mates for Law , Someone as reliable as Killer and Zoro. I bepo is there , I still think Law needs a heavy hitter.

- Kidd crew interaction with Lilith , Kidd has a lot of Reference to Vegapunk , First having attacks Named after Vegapunk , " Punk Victoria " and stuff. And his Awakening it's regarded as 007 , and all the satelites have nomenclature of 001 - 006.

- Luffy fighting Garling , lossing miserably, Zoro vs Jormugdarr , Partially destroying the elbaf in their battle , And piercing the snake covered in bloodm

- Some development on Cross guild. Maybe Impel down break

- Revolutionaries vs Holyknight.
 

Kizaruber Eats

Awkwardly existing in a world of chaos.
โ€Ž
#10
Its stupid to think about this.
I read the story someone else is telling. Its not my story, so I do not get to choose. I only get to read it.
I can only tell you what I wish to know. And hopefully soon.

What happened during the VC and why did it happen.
Never heard of thought experiments and theorising? How narrow minded. Not like the series is all about reckless imagination and ambition, along with creativity too.

Gaban's return and for us to learn about the egg on Roger's ship. Also the weaker SHs finally getting some upgrades
Also want to see a little elaboration on the BBP and Revolutionaries, like their backstories, powers, and some of their feats (even if it's just showing something like Burgess and Lafitte trashing random WBP affiliates and/or taking Devil Fruits from them)
Oh yeah those really bother me too! There must be something really important/big planned for the egg and Gaban hence why Oda still won't say or show anything with them or at least that's my cope too ofc lmao.

Aye I completely agree about the BBP and Revs too, I'd love to see what Lafitte is gonna do, I still can't believe he's only had a few panels post TS at most of screentime, he's not faced anyone directly, no devil fruit reveal nothing, Oda must be cooking something INSANE for him right?

:nicagesmile::pepecopium::jackcopium::emohiyo:

I'm so mad we never saw the BBP actually defeating DF users, killing them and taking their DFs. Their actual DF hunt. All we got was that failed attempt to get Boa's DF ofc, sigh.

A 40-70 chapter arc focusing on revolutionary vs Holy knight - Shanks pirates vs Blackbeard pirates paving the way for the Laugh tale.
This would be so great, I've been praying we're gonna get these too! Nice Kira pfp too btw!

An all out war/battle royal between the Emperors-Navy & WG-RA.
Aye this would be MUCH needed and extremely epic and awesome. Dragons complete inaction/passiveness is extremely frustrating and I fear he's not even gonna try to help Garp either. Luffy will be the one to try and save Garp naturally but maybe Sabo will show up at least? We need Garp meet/reunite with Sabo now hes confirmed alive and back too ofc. Same with Luffy and Garp regarding Sabo and the death of Ace and Garps unshamed loyalty to the WG and Marines despite all this.

Oda really keeps chickening out on us letting see Admirals vs Yonkos too, its really frustrating. He didnt even let us have Kuzan vs Katakuri too ffs although given it was a cover page story so we would barely get anything too ofc.

This I wanted this in Elbaf with Norse having 9 worlds. = 9 Major battles.
- Revolutionary (Sabo , Dragon)
- Marines (Akainu , Aramaki , Fujitora)
- WG (Garling , Nasujuro, Mars , Warcury , Jupiter)
- Pirates (Luffy , Zoro , Law , Kidd , Mihawk , Crocodile , Blackbeard , Shanks)

- Luffy vs Akainu (Luffy looses Akainu awakens)
- Blackbeard vs Shanks (Shanks dies)
- Zoro vs Nasujuro (Zoro wins)
- Aramaki vs Crocodile (Draws)
- Mihawk vs Fujitora (Mihawk)
- Sabo vs Warcury (Draws)
- Dragon vs Garling (Dragon)
- Law vs Marcus (Law)
- Kidd vs Jupiter (Kidd)

Luffy vs Akainu and Dragon vs Garling can be Interchangable.
Luffy vs Garling (Sun being eaten by Wolf norse reference)
Dragon vs Akainu (Legendary awaited Battle)

Everyone throw in hands and in the end Akainu Awakens and "Surtur" parallel , Destroys Entirety of Elbaf.

- Apart from this , I wanted to new crew mates for Law , Someone as reliable as Killer and Zoro. I bepo is there , I still think Law needs a heavy hitter.

- Kidd crew interaction with Lilith , Kidd has a lot of Reference to Vegapunk , First having attacks Named after Vegapunk , " Punk Victoria " and stuff. And his Awakening it's regarded as 007 , and all the satelites have nomenclature of 001 - 006.

- Luffy fighting Garling , lossing miserably, Zoro vs Jormugdarr , Partially destroying the elbaf in their battle , And piercing the snake covered in bloodm

- Some development on Cross guild. Maybe Impel down break

- Revolutionaries vs Holyknight.
Ooooh 9 major battles in Elbaf to represent the 9 realms is a GREAT idea, I love that! One battle in and thus maybe for each realm even?

Yeah ive been waiting for Akainu to Surtur Elbaf for ages now, especially after recent events too lmao.

Aye I agree, I was hoping Law would at least get Drake or Hawkins on his crew post Wano if not some Beast Pirates or even Smoothie potnentially. But he needs someone who would be loyal to him like Bepo is ideally too.

Oh god Kidd and Lilith has SO MUCH potential indeed, I wish he could have met Atlas too at least. The Punk symbolisms/parallels have really been bothering me and I LOVE the idea of him being regarded as the 7th Punk secretly, maybe Lilith makes him become a Vegapunk or it turns out he's the grandson of Vegapunk all along or something? With Frankys apparent relation to Queen too, why not? Sanji for Judge too ofc?
I dread to think who Caesar will turn out to be the father of next lmao.

Ironically, when Kidd, Law and Luffy drew straws, well tried to decide who would go where post Wano, Kidd was MEANT to go to Egghead originally by what he chose and thus Luffy would go to Elbaf and counter Shanks BUT CONVENIENTLY, Luffy misses out on Shanks and well we know what happened next too with Kidd ofc, sigh.

Fuck's sake Oda.

These are awesome ideas anyway man, tyvm for your contributions! Lots of very interesting and hype potential!
 
#12
not sure what i would wish myself, i think oda is going to draw the following:
moon is above elbaf
luffy wants to go up
finds out that barto and law are set to be executed
in anger, he punche shanks for beating barto
bb and kid invade elbaf, to take poneglyphs
luffy trusts shanks' strength, leaves for new marineford
 
Top